Gabriele Klara Lutz

Dr. Gabriele Klara Lutz


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

17Years (2010-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
14 July 2017 in BMC Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
GLGabriele Klara Lutz
Gabriele Klara Lutz
NPNina Pankoke
Nina Pankoke
HGHadass Goldblatt
Hadass Goldblatt
MHMarzellus Hofmann
Marzellus Hofmann
MSMichaela Stratmann
Michaela Stratmann
Professional competence is important in delivering high quality patient care, and it can be enhanced by reflection and reflective discourse e.g. in mentoring groups. However, students are often reluctant though to engage in this discourse. A group mentoring program involving all preclinical students as well as faculty members and co-mentoring clinical students was initiated at Witten-Herdecke University. This study explores both the attitudes of those students towards such a program and factors that might hinder or enhance how students engage in reflective discourse. A qualitative design was applied using semi-structured focus group interviews with preclinical students and semi-structured individual interviews with mentors and co-mentors. The interview data were analyzed using thematic content analysis. Students’ attitudes towards reflective discourse on professional challenges were diverse. Some students valued the new program and named positive outcomes regarding several features of professional development. Enriching experiences were described. Others expressed aversive attitudes. Three reasons for these were given: unclear goals and benefits, interpersonal problems within the groups hindering development and intrapersonal issues such as insecurity and traditional views of medical education. Participants mentioned several program setup factors that could enhance how students engage in such groups: explaining the program thoroughly, setting expectations and integrating the reflective discourse in a meaningful way into the curriculum, obliging participation without coercion, developing a sense of security, trust and interest in each other within the groups, randomizing group composition and facilitating group moderators as positive peer and faculty role models and as learning group members. A well-designed and empathetic setup of group mentoring programs can help raise openness towards engaging in meaningful reflective discourse. Reflection on and communication of professional challenges can, in turn, improve professional development, which is essential for high quality patient care.

24 November 2016 in BMC Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
GLGabriele Klara Lutz
Gabriele Klara Lutz
GRGudrun Roling
Gudrun Roling
BBBettina Berger
Bettina Berger
FEFriedrich Edelhäuser
Friedrich Edelhäuser
CSChristian Scheffer
Christian Scheffer
Good communication is a major factor in delivering high quality in care. Research indicates that current communication skills training alone might not sufficiently enable students to find context-specific creative solutions to individual complex personal and interpersonal challenges in the clinical context. This study explores medical students’ experiences with real communication dilemmas in a facilitated group setting. The aims were to gain a better understanding of whether and, if so, how reflective practice can enhance students’ ability to find creative individual solutions in difficult communication situations and to identify factors within the reflective setting that foster their creative competency. Thematic content analysis was used to perform a secondary analysis of semi-structured interview data from a qualitative evaluation of a group reflective practice training for final-year medical students. The categories that arose from the iterative deductive-inductive approach were analyzed in light of current scientific understandings of creativity. Reflection on real difficult clinical communication situations appears to increase medical students’ ability to handle such situations creatively. Although group reflection on clinical dilemmas involving personal aspects can stir up emotions, participating students stated they had learned a cognitive process tool that enhanced their communicative competence in clinical practice. They also described changes in personal attitudes: they felt more able to persevere and to tolerate ambiguity, described themselves more open and self-efficient in such complex clinical communication situations and thus more motivated. Furthermore, they reported on factors that were essential in this process, such as reflection on current and real challenges, a group format with a trainer. Reflective practice providing a cognitive process tool and using real clinical challenges and trainer support in communication education may provide learners with the skills and attitudes to develop creativity in practice. Implementing reflection training in clinical communication education may increase students’ overall communicative competency.

14 March 2023 in Healthcare
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LLLisa Lombardo
Lisa Lombardo
Jan P. EhlersJan P. Ehlers
Jan P. Ehlers
GLGabriele Klara Lutz
Gabriele Klara Lutz
Intra- and interpersonal competences (IICs) are essential for medical expertise. However, the effects of current medical curricula seem to not be sustainable enough, even though poorly trained IICs have negative effects on medical practice. A defensive attitude towards openly addressing personal–professional challenges seems to hinder a sustainable implementation of IICs training. Therefore, this study asks about the changeability of IICs and target factors of their implementation in medical education. The aim was to detect factors for the sustainable implementation of IICs in medical education from medical and non-medical perspectives. For this purpose, a total of 21 experts were interviewed. The interview material was analysed according to grounded theory principles to generate core categories to answer the research questions. As a first result, analysis revealed that IICs are changeable and developable, not in all, but in many students. It also showed four central prerequisites for successful implementation: the longitudinal integration of reflection and feedback in medical education and practice; a clear framework and individual path of education; the students’ mindset to develop themselves on a personal level; as well as the superiors’ mindset to openly deal with personal challenges in low hierarchies. Contrasting Carol Dweck’s mindset concept with our findings supports our theory that the development of a mindset which allows an open approach to personal deficits and challenges seems to be of central importance for both students and teachers. Two key factors in this process might be teaching about the impact of mindsets on learning and the willingness of superiors to openly address their personal challenges. To improve IICs in medical professionals, it seems helpful to pay more attention to the development of mindsets. Educating teachers and superiors about targeting factors could be a feasible direction for sustainable implementation.

22 August 2019 in BMC Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LLLisa Lombardo
Lisa Lombardo
Jan P. EhlersJan P. Ehlers
Jan P. Ehlers
GLGabriele Klara Lutz
Gabriele Klara Lutz
Professional intrapersonal and interpersonal competences (IICs) form an important part of medical expertise but are given little attention during clinical training. In other professional fields such as psychotherapy, education and aviation, training in IICs is an integral part of education and practice. In medicine, IICs tend to actually decline during studies. To date it is unclear why IICs are given less attention in medicine, despite evidence for their importance in the treatment process. In view of this, the study examined the role of IICs in the treatment process, the current situation of IIC training in medicine and, most importantly, the reasons for the comparatively low focus on IICs in the clinical training of medical students. Semi-structured interviews were carried out with 21 experts from a variety of medical specialties and non-medical professions that provide a training with a stronger focus on IIC development. The interviews were evaluated using grounded theory. The experts confirmed the idea that IICs are an equally important component in the treatment process, along with medical knowledge and technical skills. They also described large differences between the IICs possessed by physicians but noted a general developmental need. The key shortcoming was perceived to be a deep-seated defensiveness towards learning from mistakes and deficits e.g. through reflection and feedback. The interaction of different factors that seem to be reasons for this defensiveness and perpetuate it were identified: lack of support in dealing with insecurities in the face of responsibility; the notion of medicine as a science with the categories of right and wrong answers; and a range of pressures arising from the setting, such as hierarchical, economic and competition pressures. Our study showed, that the defensive attitude towards learning from mistakes and deficits especially in the field of IICs appears to be a subtle but powerful obstacle for implementing IICs in medical training, in contrast to other professional fields. This obstacle is sustained by various underlying barrier factors. We therefore propose that changes should be made within a cultural transformation targeting this defensive mindset and culture and its presumed reasons.

1 January 2019
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
KFKatja Frost
Katja Frost
FEFriedrich Edelhäuser
Friedrich Edelhäuser
MHMarzellus Hofmann
Marzellus Hofmann
DTDiethard Tauschel
Diethard Tauschel
GLGabriele Klara Lutz
Gabriele Klara Lutz
Introduction: The University of Witten/Herdecke (UW/H) was founded in 1982 as the first privately run German university. In addition to economics, dentistry, a center for life sciences and the institute for general studies, the main focus from the inception of the University was the development of a model course in medical studies. Methodology: A description of the history of the development of medical studies in relation to the reasons for its founding, its founding ideals and their implementation; phases of development, transformations and influencing factors are presented in detail. External assessments are also used for this purpose. Result: The "Herdecke Model" was first implemented with the initial group of medical students in 1983. In the past 36 years the curriculum for medical education in Witten/Herdecke has evolved to meet internal and external requirements. The goals of the founders for a reform of medical studies and the founding ideals of the UW/H have continued to lead the University through a continuous reform process of medical training. From the first model of a reform degree course at UW/H 1983 to the current Model Study Course/Modellstudiengang (MSG 2018plus), these reforms have manifested themselves in four major phases spanning a 15 year period. Landmarks of the reforms include the first systematic introduction of problem-oriented learning in Germany, and clinical and practical training with real patients in both clinical and general medical elective blocks that far surpass the Medical Licensure Act's requirements. Additionally noteworthy are the introduction of PY training wards and the active participation and co-design role students may hold. Discussion: Due to the small size of UW/H, reforms can be tested quickly and implemented with ease and flexibility. This facilitates a "laboratory setting" for the testing of future-oriented innovations. The small size has allowed various concepts to be able to be used as models, thus serving as stimuli for larger change in medical studies in Germany.

3 March 2010 in Das Gesundheitswesen
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BBB. Bücker
B. Bücker
MBM. Butzlaff
M. Butzlaff
JIJ. Isfort
J. Isfort
NKN. Koneczny
N. Koneczny
HVHorst Christian Vollmar
Horst Christian Vollmar
MRMonika A. Rieger
Monika A. Rieger
Hintergrund: Frühzeitig wieder aufgenommene Bewegung hat einen günstigen Einfluss auf den Verlauf von akuten, unkomplizierten Rückenschmerzen. Ausführliche, schriftliche Patienteninformationen können das Wissen der Patienten verbessern und zur Aktivierung beitragen. In der PIK-Studie wurde der Effekt einer kurzgefassten, evidenzbasierten Information auf Wissen, Funktion und „Bewegungsangst” untersucht. Methodik: Randomisiert kontrollierte Studie in 12 hausärztlichen Praxen. Patienten mit akuten, unkomplizierten Rückenschmerzen erhielten entweder eine schriftliche, kurzgefasste Information (Intervention) oder eine Patienteninformation ohne Inhalte zu Rückenschmerzen (Kontrolle). Schriftliche Befragung der Patienten vor Behandlung durch den Hausarzt, nach 1 Woche und nach 3 Monaten. Erhebungsinstrumente: SF-36, FABQ-D, FFbH-R, Wissensfragebogen zu Rückenschmerzen, Fragen zu Nutzung und Nutzen des Faltblatts und zu Verhaltensänderungen. Ergebnisse: Eingeschlossene Patienten: 174. Rücklaufquote: 74,7% (1 Woche), 67% (3 Monate). Für die Interventionsgruppe ergab sich ein tendenziell besserer Kenntnisstand nach 1 Woche und nach 3 Monaten eine tendenziell bessere Funktionalität. Keine Unterschiede fanden sich bei der Bewegungsangst. Die Patienten der Interventionsgruppe gaben tendenziell häufiger an, sich im Alltag mehr zu bewegen. Folgerungen: Mit kurzgefassten Informationen konnten in der vorliegenden Studie zwar nur kleine, aber in der Summe möglicherweise wichtige Effekte im Hinblick auf Kenntnisstand, Bewegungsförderung und Funktionsverbesserung erzielt werden. Background: If patients return early in the course of acute, uncomplicated back pain to their normal activities, their symptoms improve more quickly. Written detailed patient information can have a positive effect on knowledge and can increase physical activity. In this study the effect of a short evidence-based back pain leaflet on knowledge, function and patients’ beliefs was investigated. Methods: A randomised controlled trial was carried out in 12 primary care practices. Patients with acute, uncomplicated back pain received either the back-pain specific information (intervention) or a leaflet without content regarding back pain (control). Participants’ data were inquired before consultation of the general practitioner, as well as 1 week and 3 months later. Outcome measures were SF-36, FABQ-D, FFbH-R, knowledge concerning back pain, frequency of use of the leaflet, usefulness of the information and change of behaviour. Results: The included patients totaled 174. The response rates were 74.7% (1 week) and 67% (3 months). Patients receiving the intervention leaflet showed better knowledge at 1 week and greater improvement in function scores at 3 months. There was no effect on patients’ beliefs. Patients of the intervention group reported more activity in everyday life. Conclusion: Short written information may have small, in total possibly positive effects on knowledge, support of activity and function in patients with acute, uncomplicated back pain.