Tibial torsion significantly influences knee biomechanics, yet its interaction with ACL reconstruction history in elite alpine skiers remains under-investigated. In this cross-sectional observational study, we analyzed 20 elite alpine skiers (7 ACL-reconstructed, 13 non-injured) using a markerless motion capture system during dynamic tasks (Squat, Single-Leg Squat, Lunge). Static tibial torsion was assessed via the Transmalleolar Axis and Thigh–Foot Angle. The results revealed a critical divergence in biomechanical strategies based on tibial alignment (p < 0.05). Skiers with rotational deformity adopted a pattern we describe as a “Stiffness Strategy”, characterized by suppressed knee valgus and hip rotation, but relied on excessive ankle dorsiflexion (39.5°)—a compensatory mechanism that may become limited when constrained by rigid ski boots. In contrast, ACL-reconstructed skiers with normal alignment exhibited what we term an “Instability Strategy”, showing dynamic valgus collapse and persistent asymmetry. These findings suggest that “one-size-fits-all” rehabilitation may be insufficient. We propose that injury prevention protocols may benefit from incorporating anatomical screening, focusing on decoupling mobility for skiers with tibial torsion and enhancing dynamic stability for those with normal alignment.