Background: A plethora of data supports HPV-based screening to be the preferred strategy for cervical cancer prevention. The shift to a more sensitive first-line test brings the need of effective triage up for discussion. Currently, most algorithms apply cytology as a triage of HPV-DNA positive women. This study compared the performance of a 7-type HPV-mRNA test to cytology. Methods: From 1 January 2019 until 31 December 2021, cervical samples from 58,029 women were examined at the University Hospital of North Norway. A total of 30.5% (17,684/58,029) fulfilled the criteria for HPV-DNA primary screening. All positive samples were triaged by cytology and followed-up according to national guidelines through 2022. Additionally, a 7-type HPV-mRNA test was applied. The study endpoint was a histologically confirmed high-grade lesion (CIN2+). Results: A total of 5.6% (990/17,684) had positive HPV-DNA test, 97.2% (962/990) with valid HPV-mRNA results. A total of 55.5% (534/962) had abnormal cytology (ASC-US+), and 35.1% (338/962) had a positive HPV-mRNA test. A total of 13.9% (134/962) had CIN2+. The sensitivity (CIN2+) of cytology versus the HPV-mRNA test was 76.1% (102/134) versus 73.1% (98/134), p = 0.67. The specificity was 47.8% (396/828) versus 71.0% (588/624), p < 0.001. PPV was 19.1% (102/534) and 29.0% (98/338), p < 0.001, respectively. The number of colposcopies per CIN2+ detected by cytology and HPV-mRNA test was 5.2 and 3.1. Conclusion: The 7-type HPV mRNA test was significantly more specific than cervical cytology in a triage of HPV-DNA positive women. Using this biomarker as the threshold for colposcopy may better balance the benefits and harms of screening.
Background: Effective triage of women testing positive for high-risk HPV DNA is essential to reduce unnecessary colposcopies while preserving cancer prevention. Cytology, the current standard, has limited specificity and reproducibility. The genotype-specific 7-type HPV E6/E7 mRNA test (PreTect HPV-Proofer’7), targeting HPV types 16, 18, 31, 33, 45, 52, and 58, detects transcriptionally active infections and may enhance risk stratification. Methods: Between 2019 and 2023, 34,721 women aged 25–69 underwent primary HPV DNA screening with the Cobas 4800 assay at the University Hospital of North Norway, within the national screening program. Of these, 1896 HPV DNA-positive women were triaged with liquid-based cytology with atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance or worse (≥ASC-US) and the 7-type HPV mRNA test. Histological outcomes were followed through October 2024. Diagnostic performance for CIN2+ was evaluated overall and by genotype. Results: CIN2+ prevalence was 13.3%. The mRNA test reduced test positivity from 50.3% to 33.4% while maintaining comparable sensitivity (70.6% vs. 72.2%) and improving specificity (72.3% vs. 53.0%) and PPV (28.1% vs. 19.1%). Genotype-specific PPVs were highest for HPV16 mRNA (47.7%), followed by HPV33 (39.2%) and HPV31 (32.2%), all exceeding corresponding DNA-based estimates. Conclusion: Genotype-specific HPV mRNA triage offers superior risk discrimination compared to cytology, supporting more targeted, efficient, and accessible cervical cancer screening.
Background: Understanding the distribution of HPV types in cervical cancer cases is crucial for evaluating the effectiveness of HPV screening and vaccination in reducing cervical cancer burden. This study aimed to assess genotype prevalence in the pre-vaccine era among 178 cervical cancer cases detected during a 20-year screening period in Northern Norway and compare the potential efficacy of HPV vaccines in preventing cervical cancer. Methods: A total of 181 formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue samples from non-vaccinated women diagnosed with cervical cancer between 1995 and 2015 in Troms and Finnmark, Norway, were analyzed using a 45-type HPV DNA test. The results were compared to a 7-type HPV mRNA test targeting oncogenic types included in the nonavalent HPV vaccine. Results: Invalid HPV test results were observed in 1.7% (3/181) of the samples and were subsequently excluded from further analysis. Among the remaining cases, 92.7% (165/178) tested positive for HPV using any test combination. HPV DNA was detected in 159 cases (89.3%), while HPV mRNA was detected in 149 cases (83.7%). The most prevalent HPV types were 16 and 18, responsible for 70.8% of the cases, with the nonavalent vaccine types accounting for 86.6% of cases. HPV 35 was identified in eight cases (4.5%). Conclusion: The bivalent/quadrivalent HPV vaccines have the potential to prevent 76.4% (126/165) of HPV-positive cervical cancer cases, while the nonavalent vaccine could prevent 93.3% (154/165) of cases. Tailoring screening strategies to target HPV types with the highest oncogenic potential may improve cervical cancer detection and enable targeted interventions for high-risk individuals. The use of a 7-type HPV mRNA test holds promise as an advantageous approach.
Background: Effective triage of women testing positive for high-risk HPV DNA is essential to reduce unnecessary colposcopies while preserving cancer prevention. Cytology, the current standard, has limited specificity and reproducibility. The genotype-specific 7-type HPV E6/E7 mRNA test (PreTect HPV-Proofer`7), targeting HPV types 16, 18, 31, 33, 45, 52, and 58, detects transcriptionally active infections and may enhance risk stratification. Methods: Between 2019 and 2023, 34,721 women aged 25–69 underwent primary HPV DNA screening with the Cobas 4800 assay at the University Hospital of North Norway, within the national screening programme. Of these, 1,896 HPV DNA-positive women were triaged with liquid-based cytology with atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance or worse (≥ASC-US) and the 7-type HPV mRNA test. Histological outcomes were followed through October 2024. Diagnostic performance for CIN2+ was evaluated overall and by genotype. Results: CIN2+ prevalence was 13.3%. The mRNA test reduced test positivity from 50.3% to 33.4% while maintaining comparable sensitivity (70.6% vs 72.2%) and improving specificity (72.3% vs 53.0%) and PPV (28.1% vs 19.1%). Genotype-specific PPVs were highest for HPV16 mRNA (47.7%), followed by HPV33 (39.2%) and HPV31 (32.2%), all exceeding corresponding DNA-based estimates. Conclusion: Genotype-specific HPV mRNA triage offers superior risk discrimination compared to cytology, supporting more targeted, efficient, and accessible cervical cancer screening.
Background: Effective triage of HPV DNA-positive women is needed to reduce unnecessary colposcopies while maintaining cervical cancer prevention. We evaluated genotype-specific 7-type HPV E6/E7 mRNA triage in a real-world screening cohort. Methods: In this population-based single-centre study at the University Hospital of North Norway, 42,791 women underwent primary screening with the cobas HPV DNA assay during the period 2019–2024. Among 2370 HPV DNA-positive women, reflex cytology, 7-type HPV mRNA testing, and an ATHENA-derived triage strategy were compared using histologically confirmed CIN3+ through 31 December 2025 as the endpoint. Results: CIN3+ was detected in 60/2370 women (2.5%). Test positivity was 47.0% for cytology, 54.7% for ATHENA-derived triage, and 33.4% for HPV mRNA. Sensitivity was 78.3%, 86.7%, and 73.3%; specificity was 53.8%, 46.1%, and 67.7%; and PPV was 4.2%, 4.0%, and 5.6%, respectively. Colposcopies per CIN3+ detected were 23.7, 24.9, and 18.0. Conclusions: HPV mRNA triage improved referral precision and colposcopy efficiency, but with lower sensitivity than ATHENA-derived triage. These findings support 7-type HPV mRNA testing as a potentially useful molecular triage option where structured follow-up is feasible.
Background/Objectives: Co-testing may improve cervical cancer prevention by stratifying women into groups with different absolute risks of CIN2+, CIN3+, and cervical cancer. We evaluated real-world co-testing with cervical cytology and a genotype-specific HPV E6/E7 mRNA assay targeting HPV16, HPV18, and HPV45 (PreTect SEE) in routine clinical practice. Methods: We conducted a retrospective, registry-based cohort study at the Department of Clinical Pathology, University Hospital of North Norway. Eligible co-test samples (liquid-based cytology with concurrent HPV mRNA testing, both with valid results) from routine screening, follow-up, and clinically indicated testing were identified from the laboratory information system and passively followed for worst histological outcome through December 2025. Outcomes were no biopsy/<CIN2, CIN2+, CIN3+, and cervical cancer. Results: Among 116,217 eligible co-test samples (mean age 43.9 years), cumulative risks were 4.4% for CIN2+, 1.5% for CIN3+, and 0.1% for cervical cancer. Baseline HPV mRNA positivity was 3.9%, and cytology was ASC-US+ in 12.2% of samples. Co-testing produced a clear stepwise risk gradient. Double-negative results (NILM/mRNA−; 86.7%) had very low risks (CIN3+ 0.2%; cervical cancer 0.02%). ASC-US+/mRNA− results (9.3%) showed intermediate risks (CIN3+ 4.1%; cervical cancer 0.2%). NILM/mRNA+ results (1.1%) showed substantially higher risks despite normal cytology (CIN3+ 13.0%; cervical cancer 0.5%). Double-positive results (ASC-US+/mRNA+; 2.8%) had the highest risks (CIN3+ 28.5%; cervical cancer 2.3%). Within NILM, mRNA positivity captured 42.7% of CIN3+ cases and 25.0% of cancers. Genotype-specific analyses showed highest risks for HPV16, followed by HPV18 and HPV45. Conclusions: Co-testing with cervical cytology and a 3-type HPV mRNA assay provided strong, clinically interpretable risk stratification and identified a small but high-risk subgroup among women with normal cytology. These findings support genotype-specific HPV mRNA testing as an adjunct to cytology in routine care.