This study examines the non-linear relationship between European Structural and Investment (ESI) Funds and socio-economic development across EU member states from 2007 to 2020. To accomplish this, the study utilises a novel methodological approach, employing panel threshold regression to analyse the complex interactions between these variables. Using the Human Development Index (HDI) as a comprehensive measure of socio-economic progress, this research goes beyond traditional metrics, such as GDP, to capture a multidimensional view of development. The threshold variable, represented by the ratio of ESI Funds paid to GDP, highlights critical inflexion points where the impact of funding shifts, revealing both positive and negative effects. The study finds that ESI Funds positively impact socio-economic development up to a threshold of 0.7% of GDP, beyond which their effectiveness diminishes, emphasising the need for strategic allocation and management. Additionally, the analysis of control variables identifies a critical threshold range between 2% and 2.3% of GDP, indicating the growing importance of ESI Funds in fostering development within complex socio-economic contexts. This paper contributes to the foundational model of socio-economic development informed by ESI Funds, offering valuable insights for policymakers by emphasising the importance of balancing funding levels with strategic allocation to avoid diminishing returns.
In the broader context of European integration and regional convergence, European Structural and Investment Funds have become the main channels through which the European Union achieves balanced territorial development and, progressively, the transition to sustainability. Besides the impressive number of academic papers on these instruments, the structure of this field of research has been rarely mapped systematically. This paper aims to fill this gap by conducting a bibliometric study of the scientific literature based on the publications in the Web of Science Core Collection covering the period 1998-2026. The study finds that the field has experienced a major thematic reshuffle: whereas initially the focus was on the macroeconomic impact and regional convergence, the current scholarly works identify sustainable development as the most pivotal topic in the academic debate, thus signifying the increasing congruence between the EU funding instruments and the European Green Deal as well as the 2030 Agenda. The results also show that governance, management, and quality have become the main themes in the recent research, thereby indicating a move to the institutional and procedural aspects of fund implementation. Geographically, the research highlights a continuing imbalance in scientific output, mainly from beneficiary countries such as Romania and Poland. On the other hand, the academic impact is still concentrated in Western European countries. These outcomes provide a well-structured view of the field and suggest several lines for further research.