Based extensive fieldwork and interviews, this study explains teacher evaluation policy enactment as shaped by three conditions: 1) a principal’s backgrounds, role perceptions, knowledge of instruction, and interactions with teachers; 2) teachers’ perspectives; and 3) environmental demands. Notably, principals may lack the backgrounds, knowledge of teaching, role perceptions, and established interactional routines to engage teachers about their instruction in evaluative contexts. Furthermore, the teachers’ press to earn high evaluation scores may inhibit instructional leadership, as teachers become focused on the accountability aspects of evaluation rather than on the affordances of evaluation reforms to help them improve.
6 August 2026 in American Journal of Qualitative Research
This article highlights the tension of two different meanings of trustworthiness. Researchers are responsible for being empirically trustworthy by producing social scientific manuscripts of high quality. Researchers must also be relationally trustworthy by protecting the vulnerabilities and best interests of the research participants. However, researchers often face the dilemma of attending to both types of trustworthiness without strategies for addressing the challenges. This article, co-constructed by a researcher and participant, describes how member checking can promote both more rigorous research (empirical trustworthiness) and strengthen relationships and leave participants feeling valued and empowered (relational trustworthiness). To this end, this article highlights the challenges and affordances of the member checking process itself, examines the process’s impact on both the researcher and the participant, and offers guidelines for how member checking can simultaneously promote both more rigorous and more ethical research.
This multi-site ethnographic study focuses on the utility of using student growth data generated from teacher evaluations as a data-use intervention. Findings suggest that teachers developed a common perspective about evaluation but organizational contexts shaped teacher responses at the three sites differently. At two of the schools, teachers were responsible for administering their own assessments, organizing results, and presenting these results to the principal. In both schools, the data-use process was similar. Teachers administered a variety of assessments, chose from among the results, constructed artifacts metrics, and presented these metrics to the principal. At the third school, student achievement was calculated using an externally developed assessment and student growth scores were calculated at the district level. At this school, teachers maintained a unified front that disestablished the link between their performance and their students’ assessment results. The teachers maintained this stance in their interactions with colleagues and with the principal.
In this longitudinal case study, we examined school well-being during the change process. We operationalized the change process as the school renewal model and viewed school well-being from the perspective of the PERMA (positive emotion, engagement, relationships, meaning, and accomplishment) model. We found that all elements of the PERMA model were manifested in the school renewal process and that the school renewal process was not dominated solely by conflict and tension, as the literature typically suggests about the change process. The findings of the study suggest the possibility of reframing tension as productive rather than detrimental in the school renewal context. This study also advances the construct of school well-being as an organizational property.