Digital transformation is central to circular economy (CE) strategies, yet the intersection between digital innovation and women’s entrepreneurship remains underexplored. We examine how IoT, AI, blockchain, data analytics and platform technologies are represented in CE-oriented management research and assess the visibility of gender-inclusive and women entrepreneurship perspectives. We merged Scopus and Web of Science records (2015–2025), removed duplicates, screened for relevance, and mapped themes and networks using bibliometrix (R) and VOSviewer. Digital-CE scholarship was found to rise after 2018, dominated by smart manufacturing, circular supply chains, digital product passports and blockchain traceability. Four clusters emerged: digital circular manufacturing, circular business model innovation, waste and resource management, and policy–social aspects. Gender-related terms appear in only 1.35% of the corpus, revealing a gap between academic research and EU policy priorities for inclusive digital and circular transitions. We integrate a gender-inclusive lens and outline an agenda positioning women entrepreneurs as critical yet overlooked actors in digital circular ecosystems. As a bibliometric review, this study maps scholarly attention rather than the prevalence of women-led circular ventures. Beyond mapping, we advance the paper’s primary contribution by proposing a governance-oriented synthesis that frames digital infrastructures as administrative mechanisms shaping who can participate in, benefit from, and influence digital circular ecosystems.
Digital transformation has become a cornerstone of circular economy (CE) strategies, yet the intersection between digital innovation and women’s entrepreneurship remains poorly understood. This study examines how digital enablers such as IoT, AI, blockchain, data analytics and platform technologies are represented in CE-related business and management research, while assessing the visibility of gender-inclusive and women-entrepreneurship perspectives. Using a bibliometric design, we retrieved and merged Scopus and Web of Science records (2015–2025), applied de-duplication and relevance screening, and conducted performance analysis and science mapping through bibliometrix (R) and VOSviewer to identify core themes, leading journals, influential authors, collaboration networks and thematic clusters. The findings show a sharp rise of digital-CE scholarship after 2018, dominated by technological perspectives on smart manufacturing, circular supply chains, digital product passports and blockchain-enabled traceability. Four stable clusters emerged: digital circular manufacturing, circular business model innovation, waste and resource management, and policy–social aspects. However, gender-related terms appear in only 1.35% of the corpus, revealing a substantial gap between academic research and EU policy priorities for inclusive digital and circular transitions. The study contributes by integrating a gender-inclusive lens into digital-CE scholarship and outlining a future research agenda that positions women entrepreneurs as critical—yet currently overlooked—actors in shaping digital circular ecosystems.
22 December 2023 in Bulletin of "Turan" University
In modern conditions, most developed countries of the world have moved away from the linear model of economy, which leads to the depletion of natural resources, degradation of the environment and health. They have opted for a green growth strategy based on the use of innovative technologies. Despite the fact that production and consumption waste management is one of the main directions of implementation of the Concept on Transition of the Republic of Kazakhstan (RK) to a “green economy”, an effective system of collection and recycling has not been created in the sphere of municipal solid waste (MSW), which causes many problems. The aim of the study is to find opportunities for innovative business models for recycling and reuse of MSW in Kazakhstan. The theoretical significance of the article lies in the fact that based on the identification of the essence, principles and models of circular economy the necessity of active development of eco-entrepreneurship in the field of waste is justified. The practical significance lies in the problems of MSW sector and the main ways to solve them. To eliminate these problems and obstacles it is proposed to use innovative business models for waste recycling into secondary raw materials, to create conditions for the activation of the “green business”, based on the principles of closed-cycle economy. The study concluded that the MSW sector in Kazakhstan is a promising niche for the development of eco-entrepreneurship. It is recommended to use the circular principles, business models, create favourable conditions for business activities.
In the context of the COVID–19 pandemic, maintaining the sustainability of the socio-economic system is one of the main priorities of states. The basis of the economy is small and medium-sized businesses, whose representatives are daily faced with the solution of managerial and organizational tasks of different levels. Main purpose of study was to research the possibility “teal” strategies usage in activities of Kazakhstani companies. The article describes aspects of the implementation of the basics of “teal” strategy as a flexible form of business structures in offline and online modes. The introduction of elements of the “teal” strategy will allow integrating into the changing economic system in the future by revising the organizational structure of management. The article also discusses the experience of implementing the teal strategy on the example of foreign, including Russian, companies. The teal model in these companies is based on the principles of self-organization and self-development of the company's personnel, which allows the maximum use of human potential for self-development and internal motivation in achieving the company's business goals. Based on the results of the conducted research, the main conclusions are made about the possibility of applying the strategies of “teal” organizations in the practice of Kazakhstan SMEs. In addition, the difficulties of implementing “teal” strategies are identified and the main competencies necessary for the personnel of companies to transition to the proposed business structure models are proposed.
In March 2022, the FAO Food Price Index peaked at 159.7 as climate shocks collided with geopolitical disruption, pushing global hunger past 735 million and exposing how deeply climate variability penetrates the economics of agri-food systems. Yet the imprint of ocean–atmosphere oscillations on global food prices—the central economic signal of the agri-food system—has never been mapped systematically in the frequency domain. This study delivers the first multi-oscillation cross-spectral analysis of the climate–food price nexus, matching seven climate indices across the Pacific, Atlantic, and Indian Ocean basins with five disaggregated FAO Food Price Index sub-components over 432 monthly observations (1990–2025), verified through six robustness checks including surrogate-data testing. Four findings carry direct policy relevance. ENSO indicators lead global food prices by three to four months with a 100% surrogate-test pass rate—the cleanest actionable climate–price signal yet documented. The Indian Ocean Dipole leads prices by sixteen months, extending the early warning horizon from weeks to over a year. The apparent Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation–price correlation (r ≈ +0.60) is revealed to be a common-trend artefact. Dairy and vegetable oils emerge as the most climate-exposed commodity chains, while meat is buffered by feed-market intermediation. These results provide the empirical foundation for integrating real-time monitoring of climate oscillations into food system governance—a low-cost policy innovation that aligns economic stability objectives with climate adaptation goals, strengthens the resilience of agri-food value chains, and supports progress toward Sustainable Development Goal 2 (Zero Hunger).
This study examines the relationship between digitalisation, digital marketing innovation, and sustainable consumption using macro-level longitudinal data for 2012–2025 (T = 14 annual observations). The core empirical analysis is correlational and descriptive in character: ordinary least squares (OLS) regression is used to estimate associations between digital marketing indicators and sustainable-market outcomes. The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) are used as interpretive theoretical lenses for discussing possible behavioural mechanisms; mediation and moderation mechanisms motivated by these theories are discussed as exploratory propositions but are not formally tested as statistical models. The study conducts an exploratory assessment of these interrelationships at the macro level. The findings show that digitalisation, reflected in the growth of digital advertising expenditure and internet penetration, is associated with the expansion of sustainable-product markets, particularly in the organic and eco-friendly sectors. A 1% increase in global digital advertising expenditure is associated with an approximately 0.607% increase in the organic market in a log-log specification. However, this level association attenuates substantially once common temporal trends are removed via first-differencing; this contrast between level and first-differenced results is treated as a central empirical finding of the study. Complementary survey evidence indicates that Generation Z and Millennials account for an estimated 75% of sustainability-related purchasing decisions. The findings are also consistent with the persistence of a structural “Green Gap” between pro-environmental attitudes and actual purchasing behaviour. Descriptive and survey-based evidence further suggests that this gap co-varies with price sensitivity, informational frictions, habitual routines, and consumer trust. As descriptive contextual evidence only, the difference between survey-based attitudinal prevalence and aggregate sustainable market share (a group-level comparison, not an individual-level measurement of the intention–behaviour gap) is approximately 53–58 percentage points. The evidence is also consistent with the possibility that digital marketing’s contribution to sustainable consumption may be constrained by the risk of greenwashing, which can erode consumer trust, and by supply-side and economic barriers that lie outside the scope of digital marketing interventions. Overall, the study provides descriptive and correlational evidence that digitalisation and digital marketing innovation may provide an enabling context for responsible consumption, while their contribution likely depends on complementary supply-side, regulatory, and trust-related conditions.