Dilhan Toredi

Dr. Dilhan Toredi


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

2Years (2025-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 June 2026 in Law and Human Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
DTDilhan Toredi
Dilhan Toredi
SPSteven D. Penrod
Steven D. Penrod
Lineup construction relies on matching fillers to the suspect's appearance or to the eyewitness's description of the perpetrator (match to description, MTD). Recent work shows that low (vs. high)-similarity fillers beyond MTD improve discriminability. We tested lineups constructed with differing suspect-filler (SF) similarity levels beyond MTD (low, moderate, high) against MTD only, varying exposure duration, culprit race, and innocent suspect-culprit resemblance (guilty-innocent [GI] similarity). We expected the highest discriminability for low-SF similarity lineups, moderate next, MTD-only lower, and high lowest-alongside higher discriminability for long (cf. short) exposures, same-race (cf. cross-race) culprits, and low GI similarity (cf. high). We expected high-SF similarity to better protect high GI similarity innocents and low F-similarity to aid culprit identifications regardless of GI similarity. We also anticipated stronger benefits of low-SF similarity lineups for cross-race culprits and shorter exposures. All lineups, except MTD only, were constructed using an artificial intelligence-driven, objective, and reproducible measure and varied by SF similarity. Participants (N = 2,644) recruited via Prolific watched four short or long videos (half with White, half with African American culprits), completed a distractor task, and made lineup identifications (culprit-present or culprit-absent) with confidence ratings. Both low- and high-SF similarity lineups produced higher discriminability than MTD-only lineups. While low-SF similarity lineups enhanced guilty suspect detection, high-SF similarity lineups better protected innocent suspects. Furthermore, low-SF similarity lineups yielded the best identification accuracy, and high-SF similarity lineups yielded the best diagnosticity ratio. No interactions emerged. Using match-to-suspect beyond MTD-especially at the highest or lowest SF similarity-improves lineup performance regardless of factors outside the justice system's control. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2026 APA, all rights reserved).

1 August 2025 in Law and Human Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
DTDilhan Toredi
Dilhan Toredi
JMJamal Mansour
Jamal Mansour
SJSian Jones
Sian Jones
FSFaye Skelton
Faye Skelton
AMAlex McIntyre
Alex McIntyre
The cross-race effect (CRE) is a reliable and robust phenomenon, whereby individuals better recognize faces that belong to their race compared with another race. Our goal was to produce items for a self-report inventory (i.e., Cross-Race Effect Inventory [CRE-I]) that brings together known predictors of the CRE to improve the postdiction of cross-race eyewitness accuracy. We expected a CRE for White and Asian participants. We anticipated that developed CRE-I subscales would correlate positively with extant (some modified) scales and predict accuracy. Participants completed four trials (two White targets and two Asian targets). For each trial, they watched a mock-crime video, performed a distractor task, made a sequential lineup decision (target present or target absent), and indicated confidence in their lineup decision. After all trials, participants completed the potential items for the CRE-I. We replicated prior findings of a CRE for White participants but did not find a CRE for Asian participants. Exploratory factor analysis produced internally reliable scales for the CRE-I to be used with White eyewitnesses: General Face Recognition Ability, Race-Specific Face Recognition Ability, Racial Attitudes, Quantity of Contact, Quality of Contact, Motivated Individuation, and Cognitive Disregard. Responses to several scales predicted identification accuracy. In particular, three CRE-I scales predicted identification accuracy beyond the predictiveness of confidence: Race-Specific Face Recognition Ability, Racial Attitudes Toward White People, and Motivated Individuation of White People. Variables suggested separately by the perceptual expertise hypothesis and the social cognitive hypothesis predicted identification accuracy, providing support for integrative models of the CRE. The CRE-I contributes to the CRE literature in terms of both theory-by showing which factors among many may best relate to recognition-and practice-by improving evaluations of eyewitness reliability. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).

2 April 2026 in Cognition
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
DTDilhan Toredi
Dilhan Toredi
EMEric Y. Mah
Eric Y. Mah
MLMegan K. Lall
Megan K. Lall
HJHaiyang Jin
Haiyang Jin
BRBrett D. Roads
Brett D. Roads
JTJames W. Tanaka
James W. Tanaka
The Cross-Race Effect (CRE) refers to the robust finding that individuals more accurately recognize faces of their own race than those of other races. According to the Face Space Model, this effect arises because cross-race faces are represented more densely-i.e., with less differentiation-in psychological space than same-race faces (Valentine & Endo, 1992). Although some studies have demonstrated that same-race faces occupy more dispersed positions in multidimensional space (e.g., Byatt & Rhodes, 2004), few have directly examined the link between recognition performance and underlying psychological face representations. The present experiments tested the Face Space account of the CRE by assessing recognition accuracy and perceived facial similarity across racial group. In Experiments 1A and 1B, Asian, Black, and White participants completed old/new recognition tasks for same- and cross-race faces. In Experiments 2A and 2B, separate groups of participants rated facial similarity for the same stimuli and were represented in the face space. We hypothesized (a) superior recognition for same-race faces and (b) that cross-race faces would be judged as more similar and thus more densely clustered in Face Space. Results partially supported these predictions. Consistent with the Face Space account, distinctive faces were overall better recognized than less distinctive faces and some conditions revealed recognition performance was aligned with perceived face clustering by race. However, other conditions showed a dissociation between memory and similarity where cross-race faces were more poorly recognized than same-race faces but were perceived as equally similar. These findings suggest that the CRE may not be fully accounted for by representational density in Face Space alone and highlight the potential dissociation between cognitive and perceptual processes of same- and cross-race faces.

30 June 2025 in Perspectives on Psychological Science
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
DTDilhan Toredi
Dilhan Toredi
JMJamal K. Mansour
Jamal K. Mansour
SJSian Jones
Sian Jones
FSFaye Skelton
Faye Skelton
AMAlex McIntyre
Alex McIntyre
Meta-analyses have consistently demonstrated the robustness of the cross-race effect (CRE; i.e., better recognition of same-race faces compared with different-race faces). These analyses have unveiled variations in the dependent variables associated with the CRE across combinations of participant and target races. However, the underlying factors driving these variations remain poorly understood. We posit that although the CRE is robust, its generalizability may be contingent on the specific racial groups compared, particularly when contrasting majority and minority racial groups. In this article, we delve into the dynamics of the CRE across distinct racial groups and explore how minority-race status may influence research outcomes. We considered the articles included in the latest meta-analyses of the CRE with a spotlight on minority-race status. We suggest that minority-race status may explain why many studies considering non-White participants do not show a CRE. The CRE might not be as robust as it appears to be because much of the research on the effect has focused on majority-race participants and minority-race faces. Going forward, researchers should consider incorporating measures relevant to the minority effect, fully crossing participant and target races and studying a greater variety of races.

20 April 2026 in Applied Cognitive Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
DTDilhan Toredi
Dilhan Toredi
SPSteven D. Penrod
Steven D. Penrod
Increasing filler similarity to a suspect—beyond description matching—can improve lineup discriminability. We investigated the effects of suspect‐filler similarity on reflector variable‐accuracy calibrations across different levels of innocent suspect resemblance to the culprit. Match‐to‐description‐only lineups and description‐matched lineups with low, moderate, or high suspect‐filler similarity were constructed. Participants ( N = 2,644) viewed four videos, made identifications, rated their confidence, and had their response time recorded. Confidence‐accuracy and response time‐accuracy calibrations improved as suspect‐filler similarity increased and innocent suspect‐culprit similarity decreased—particularly for fast, high‐confidence decisions. When the innocent suspect strongly resembled the culprit, well‐calibrated high‐confidence accuracy was observed only when suspect‐filler similarity was high; all other levels of suspect–filler similarity produced overconfident high‐confidence identifications. These findings underscore the value of increasing suspect–filler similarity beyond description‐matching to enhance the reliability of identification judgments based on confidence and response time, especially when the innocent suspect strongly resembles the culprit.

21 September 2026 in Psychology, Public Policy, and Law
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PPPia Pennekamp
Pia Pennekamp
DTDilhan Toredi
Dilhan Toredi