Vortex pumps can impel solid-containing fluids and are therefore widely applied, from wastewater transport to the food industry. Despite constant efforts to improve vortex pumps, however, they have remained relatively inefficient compared to conventional centrifugal pumps. To find an optimized design of vortex pumps, this paper provides a systematic analysis on experimental studies that investigated how variations in geometric parameters influence vortex pump characteristics, in particular the pump head, the pressure coefficient and the efficiency for best point operation. To this end, an extensive literature search was conducted, and eighteen articles with 53 primary investigations were identified and meta-integrated. This showed that it is not yet clarified how vortex pumps operate. Two different assumptions of the underlying operating principle of a vortex pump lead to diverging design principles. From the results of this meta-analysis, we deduce recommendations for a more efficient design of a vortex pump and emphasize further aspects on the underlying operating principle of a vortex pump.
Clogging, or ‘ragging’, is a major headache for operators of sewage pumping stations, and can be very costly in terms of downtime and possible sewage pollution. Prof. Dr.-Ing. Paul Uwe Thamsen of TU Berlin – Fluidsystemdynamik explains how recent research may change all this.
Especially in the field of sewage pumps, the design of radial impellers focuses not only on maximum efficiency but also on functionality in terms of susceptibility to clogging by fibrous media. In general, the efficiency of sewage impellers is significantly lower than that of clear water impellers. These sewage impellers are designed with a low number of blades to ensure that fibrous media can be pumped. This paper describes the methodology of an optimisation for a sewage impeller. The optimisation is carried out on a semi-open two-channel impeller as an example. Therefore, a new impeller is designed for a given volute casing. Based on a basic design for given boundary conditions, the impeller is verified by means of numerical simulation. The manufactured impeller is then tested on the test rig to verify the simulation. With regard to the optical investigations, the clogging behaviour of the impeller is specifically improved over three different modifications in order to finally present an impeller with good efficiency and a low clogging tendency.
In order to characterize wastewater pumps regarding their clogging behaviour, a wide variety of test procedures with artificial wastewater exist. These tests provide a good insight into the clogging characteristics of a pump. However, conclusions about the clogging mechanisms and their sources cannot be drawn. This paper deals with the design and implementation of an optical access on the suction side of a wastewater pump to allow visualisation of the interaction between impeller and textile via high-speed recordings. The optical access is realized by an endoscope and a connected high-speed camera with a frame rate of 2000 fps and a resolution of 1024 × 1024 pixels. To ensure sufficient illumination of the impeller, a light ring assembled from 12 high power LEDs with a luminous flux of 5595 lumen are circumferentially arranged around the suction side of the pump. The light ring concept is scalable to fit any pump size. A clogging-affine impeller is developed, 3D printed and used for experimental investigations. For the investigated impeller, the blade’s upper area is identified to be crucial for pump clogging. Optical accessibility provides an important contribution to develop non-clogging impellers.
Wastewater pumps are increasingly clogged by solids containing fibers. Closed 2-channel impellers in particular are often highly susceptible to clogging due to their geometric properties, even though they have among the highest clear water efficiencies compared to other wastewater impellers. With the help of a clogging test rig, a prototype that can accommodate different closed 2-channel geometries, the use of three-dimensional simulation as well as an optical access for high-speed recordings, a methodology is to be created, whereby this impeller type can be effectively optimized. In this paper, the first impeller modification is calculated, manufactured, simulated, and tested with this methodology.