The purpose of this article was to review the effectiveness of wideband acoustic immittance (WAI) and tympanometry in detecting conductive hearing loss (CHL). Eight studies were included that measured CHL through air-and bone-conducted thresholds in at least a portion of their participants. One study included infants, three studies included children, one study included older children and adults, and three studies included adults. WAI identified CHL well in all populations. In infants and children, WAI in several single-frequency bands identified CHL with equal accuracy to measures of middle ear admittance using clinical tympanometry with a single probe tone (1000 Hz for infants; 226 Hz for children and adults). When WAI was combined across frequency bands, it identified CHL superior to traditional, single-frequency tympanometry. Only two studies used WAI tympanometry, which assesses the outer/middle ear across both frequency and introduced air pressure, and differing results were reported as to whether introducing pressure into the ear canal provides better identification of CHL. In general, WAI appears to be a promising clinical tool, and further investigation is warranted.
The goal of the study was to evaluate the effectiveness of tympanometry and wideband reflectance (WBR) in detecting conductive hearing loss (CHL) in young infants. Type of hearing loss was determined using auditory brainstem response using air- and bone-conducted tone bursts in 84 ears from 70 infants (median age = 10 weeks). Of these 84 ears, 60 are included in the current analysis: 43 with normal hearing (NH) and 17 with CHL. Tympanometry was measured using probe tone frequencies of 226, 678, and 1000 Hz. Tympanograms were evaluated in two ways: (1) Acoustic middle ear admittance (Ya, in millimhos); and (2) two-category classification (normal/abnormal), as described by Baldwin (2006). Measures of Ya were evaluated in two ways: by admittance-magnitude tympanograms and calculated admittance magnitude from subcomponents (conductance and susceptance). WBR was measured in response to a chirp stimulus after probe calibration. WBR was analyzed into thirteen 1/3 octave bands. Tests for statistical differences for two-category classification were analyzed using Chi-squared and Ya, and WBR were analyzed using repeated-measures analyses of variances. Cohen's d and likelihood ratios were computed for comparison with statistically significant differences. Ya measured with 678- and 1000 Hz probe tones was significantly different between ears with CHL and NH. Two-category classification of tympanograms using a 1000 Hz probe tone was significantly different between ears with CHL and NH. Neither two-category classification nor Ya was significantly different between ears identified with CHL and NH using a 226 Hz probe tone. WBR was significantly higher in the frequency bands 800 to 2500 Hz and in the frequency band centered at 6300 Hz in infants with CHL. Effect sizes (Cohen's d) were greater than 2 for several WBR frequency bands and Ya measured with 1000 Hz probe tones. The results were similar for calculations of Ya from admittance-magnitude and subcomponent tympanograms. Positive likelihood ratios for WBR ranged between 8.1 and 38, and those for Ya using 1000 Hz ranged between 12.5 and 32. CHL in young infants can be detected well with WBR or tympanometry using probe frequencies of 678 and 1000 Hz.
Otoacoustic emission (OAE) testing is now a standard component of the diagnostic audiology protocol for infants and toddlers and is an excellent tool for detecting moderate-to-profound cochlear hearing loss. Detection of hearing loss is especially important in infants and toddlers. Unfortunately, middle-ear dysfunction has a high incidence in this age range and can confound interpretation of OAEs. The goal of the study was to determine how transient-evoked otoacoustic emission (TEOAE) and noise levels were different when tympanometric peak pressures (TPP) measured from tympanograms were normal versus negative in the same individual. Another goal was to determine how TEOAE screening pass rates using a priori pass criteria were affected on days when TPP was negative. TEOAE and noise levels were collected in 18 cases under 2 conditions: on a day when the tympanogram TPP was normal and on a day when the tympanogram TPP was negative. Data were collected from 11 children aged 3 to 39 mo, some of whom were tested more than once. Paired t tests were performed to determine whether there were changes in overall TEOAE and noise levels and TEOAE and noise levels analyzed into half-octave bands. A one-way ANOVA was performed on differences across half-octave bands to determine whether TPP affected TEOAE levels for some frequency bands more than others. Equality-of-proportion Z tests were run to determine whether there were significant differences in the percentage of "passes" on days when TPP was negative and TPP was normal. Mean TEOAE level was lower when TPP was negative, but noise levels did not change between the 2 conditions. Mean TEOAE levels were lower for all frequency bands from 1000 to 4000 Hz and no significant differences were found among the mean reduction across frequency bands. There were no significant differences in the percentage of passes between TEOAEs collected on days when TPP was normal and when TPP was negative. Mean data indicated that when tympanograms had negative TPP, TEOAE level was lower by approximately 4 dB across all frequency bands. However, this affected the pass rate in only 5% to 6% of cases. Although the number of participants in the current study was small, the data suggest that it is possible to measure TEOAEs in children with negative TPP. If emission-to-noise ratio is used to identify hearing loss in mid-to-high frequency bands, the majority of children will still have TEOAEs that meet clinical criteria, this providing the clinician with important information about cochlear status.
Objective: Current Joint Committee on Infant Hearing guidelines recommend the use of transient-evoked otoacoustic emissions (TEOAEs) as a screening tool to identify hearing loss for newborns cared for in the well-baby nursery. Newborns who do not pass the TEOAE screen before leaving the hospital are typically rescreened as outpatients by 1 mo of age, at which time, approximately 50 to 70% pass screening criteria. To better understand why many infants are referred at initial screening but pass at the rescreening, more complete knowledge of developmental differences in the TEOAE levels, noise floor, or a combination of both for infants who pass and fail birth screening is needed. In addition, it has been shown that infants with occluding ear-canal debris are more likely to not pass TEOAE screening at the hospital than those without occluding ear-canal debris. This study explores whether changes in TEOAE levels in half-octave frequency bands are related to changes in ear-canal debris over the first month of life. Design: Seventy-nine neonates from a well-baby nursery had their hearing screened before leaving the hospital and again at approximately 1 mo of age. All participants passed the follow-up screening. Overall TEOAE levels and levels in half-octave frequency bands centered at 1.5, 2, 3, and 4 kHz were measured. Judgments of ear-canal debris were made by otoscopy and were rated using one of three categories at both visits. Results: TEOAE levels in infants significantly increased from birth to 1 mo of age across all frequencies tested, regardless of whether they passed or failed the screening at birth. The increase in TEOAE level was frequency dependent, with the greatest increases occurring in the highest frequency bands. No significant correlation between debris change and frequency-specific changes was found for either ear. Infants who failed the screening at birth but who subsequently passed at 1 mo of age had significantly lower TEOAE levels at the rescreening than did infants with passing TEOAE levels at birth. However, pass/fail status at birth was only a weak predictor of TEOAE levels at 1 mo of age. Conclusions: The increase in TEOAE levels during the first month of life is frequency dependent, with greater increases occurring at higher frequencies. Increased TEOAE levels were not associated with changes in ear-canal debris.
13 October 2022 in Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders