The management of fine bauxite tailings, rich in clay minerals, represents an environmental and operational challenge for the aluminum industry. This study (Part 1) presents a pilot-scale investigation into the dewatering of these ultrafine tailings using a decanter centrifuge, 0.62 m in diameter, as an alternative to conventional wet storage. Tests were conducted at three bowl speeds, 1600 rpm, 1700 rpm, and 1800 rpm, corresponding to G-forces of 888, 1003, and 1124 G. The feed slurry behaved as a non-Newtonian, yield-pseudoplastic fluid, as confirmed by rheology tests. A comprehensive mass balance and performance analysis were conducted. The results demonstrated a monotonic improvement in key performance metrics with increasing bowl speed. Accordingly, increasing the G-force from 888 G to 1124 G improved the final cake solid content from 66.3% to 71.5% (by weight), together with an increase in the average solid recovery from 40.0% to 56.2%. Partition curve analysis revealed the primary limitation: while recovery of particles coarser than 20 µm was very high (>98%), recovery of particles finer than 20 µm remained low, ranging from 22.0% to 35.1%. Partition curve analysis using the Whiten model identified a mechanical cut size (d50c) ranging from 9.72 µm to 12.0 µm. Hydraulic bypass increased from 8.35% to 14.9% with increasing bowl speed, indicating a significant non-size-selective component of separation. Rheological analysis further showed that the apparent viscosity at 100 s−1 decreased from 0.332 to 0.111 Pa·s across the tested conditions, confirming enhanced slurry mobility and its contribution to increased ultrafine bypass. While overall solid recovery reached 56.2% at 1124 G, the mechanical capture of the ultrafine fraction (<5 µm) remains the primary bottleneck for industrial viability. It is concluded that while the decanter centrifuge is mechanically viable for producing a high-solid cake, the limited recovery of fines would create an unsustainable circulating load in an industrial plant. These results demonstrate that G-force alone, within the tested range, is insufficient to manage these tailings and provide the basis for the mathematical modeling required to design the process, as described in Part 2 of this investigation.