This work presents an experimental comparison of three speed control strategies for a permanent magnet DC (PMDC) rover actuator implemented on a resource-constrained embedded microcontroller platform. The system operates under fixed-rate discrete control with quantized encoder velocity feedback, representative of low-cost embedded systems. The controllers evaluated are a classical PID, a PID controller designed via discrete pole placement, and a Mamdani fuzzy controller. Beyond conventional tracking and transient response metrics, the proposed evaluation framework incorporates jerk-based kinematic indicators to assess the mechanical activity induced by control actions under both nominal and mechanically disturbed operating conditions. Experimental validation was performed over a range of operating speeds using repeated trials, and the observed differences were evaluated through nonparametric statistical testing. The results show that controller rankings depend strongly on operating conditions: the classical PID provides smoother motion under nominal conditions, whereas the fuzzy and compensated PID controllers achieve superior disturbance rejection when external mechanical perturbations are introduced. These findings reveal a clear tradeoff between mechanical smoothness and tracking robustness, and demonstrate that controllers exhibiting better tracking performance do not necessarily produce the smoothest kinematic response. The principal contribution of this work is the experimental demonstration that jerk-based indicators provide essential complementary information to conventional performance metrics for the evaluation and selection of embedded speed controllers in mechatronic systems subject to variable mechanical loading.
This work provides an experimental comparison between classical PID, analytically compensated PID, and fuzzy control applied to the speed control of a rover actuator based on a permanent magnet DC motor. Unlike most studies, which focus on classical metrics such as transient response and steady-state error, this work incorporates kinematic indicators such as acceleration and jerk to characterize the dynamic effort applied to the actuator. The results indicate that the fuzzy controller achieves the fastest transient response and the best disturbance rejection, although at the cost of an IAJ 2.378 times higher than that of the classical PID and a peak jerk 79.36% higher under nominal conditions. The classical PID exhibits the smoothest kinematic profile under nominal operation, but under disturbances it generates jerk peaks 2.39 times higher than the fuzzy controller and an IAJ 1.67 times higher than the compensated PID, evidencing its inadequacy under variable loads. The compensated PID achieves the lowest cumulative IAJ under disturbance, outperforming the fuzzy controller by 6.7%, and provides the best overall balance between response speed, disturbance rejection, and cumulative mechanical wear.