Understanding how geometry, surface condition, and polarity influence surface flashover is important for improving the reliability of polymeric insulation in high-voltage systems exposed to transient overvoltages. The purpose of this study was to experimentally investigate visible arc path behaviour on polymeric insulators made of polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), polyvinyl chloride (PVC), and nylon under standard 1.2/50 µs lightning voltage impulses. Cylindrical, concave, and convex profiles were tested in a rod–plane configuration for both positive and negative polarities under clean and sunflower oil- coated surface conditions. Seven arc types were observed. While the visible arc path was governed mainly by geometry and polarity, the electrical breakdown response exhibited material-dependent effects. Positive-polarity oil-coated samples generally exhibited longer time-to-breakdown, while negative-polarity tests produced higher breakdown voltages, and oil often reduced the withstand level. The large variability in time-to-breakdown data indicates that impulse flashover is strongly stochastic and sensitive to small surface or field variations. The findings highlight the need for improving control of surface films, expanding environmental testing, and conducting further modelling to predict flashover behaviour across different insulator designs.