The Journal of Chinese Linguistics (Preprint)© 2022 by the Journal of Chinese Linguistics. ISSN 0091-3723/On the biological basis of prosody: A response to Duanmu’s rhythmic analysis. By Shengli Feng. All rights reserved. INSIGHT ON THE BIOLOGICAL BASIS OF PROSODY: A RESPONSE TO DUANMU’S RHYTHMIC ANALYSIS Shengli Feng Beijing Language and Culture University, Beijing The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong 1. WHAT IS RHYTHM: DUANMU’S ANALYSIS Rhythm is a fundamental notion in music, poetry, as well as the prosodic systems of human language. Though there have been rich discussions about what rhythm is and how it functions, it has taken until now to arrive at a general and precise definition of rhythm as in Duanmu (2022), which states as follows: (1) Definition of rhythm a. Rhythm is the repetition of a unit of alternation. b. A unit of alternation consists of two non-identical parts A and B. Based on the definition of rhythm, Duanmu (2022, 262) also develops a representation of poetic line as in (2) and that of poem as in (3). Acknowledgments I thank San Duanmu (端木三) and Yafei Li (李亚非) for their inspiring ideas, comments and suggestions in writing this paper. I also thank Qiuwu Ma (马秋武), Qi Gong (宫 齐), Zhiqiang Li (李智强), Wen Cao (曹文), Feng-fan Hsien (谢丰帆), Xiangdong Shi (施向东), Chunhong Shi (施春宏), and the anonymous reviewers for their comments. The arguments made here do not necessarily all agree with theirs. This research is partially supported by the National Social Science Fund of China (20VJXG038) and the Research Fund at Faculty of Linguistic Sciences of Beijing Language and Culture University (22YJ140006). Shengli Feng ( 冯 胜 利 ) [fengshengli@blcu.edu.cn]; Institute of Zhang-Huang Academic Theories, Faculty of Linguistics Sciences, Beijing Language and Culture University, Beijing 100083, China; https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5960-0092 2 JOURNAL OF CHINESE LINGUISTICS (PREPRINT) (2) Representation of the perfect grid as a poetic line a. Unit of repetition: a disyllabic trochaic foot b. Parts of alternation: A is a stressed syllable; B is an unstressed syllable. (3) Representation of a poem a. Unit of repetition: a poetic line b. Parts of alternation: A is a given number of feet; B is a boundary #. The arguments and the analyses offered by Duanmu are insightful and important. In general, whether in the East or in the West, the notion of rhythm and that of repetition are almost interchangeable. However, in poetry, as Duanmu points out, rhythm is organized by repetition of alternating units, and it operates in all languages at all levels too (see also Feng and Shi 2021). The new definition of rhythm makes a necessary and important correction on previous misunderstandings of what human rhythm involves. Duanmu (2022) also offers a judgment experiment on perceived rhythmicality of Chinese poems and discovers some rhythmic contrasts between riming and poem structure on the one hand, and shuāngshēng 双 声 ‘repeated adjacent onsets’, diéyùn 叠韵 ‘repeated adjacent rimes’, consonance, and assonance on the other. The former two have significant effects on perceived rhythmicality, while the latter four contribute little to this aspect. This study has far-reaching ramifications for future studies on rhythmic objects with their perceived rhythmicality. 2. DIFFERENT OPINIONS Although Duanmu’s (2022) analysis is insightful, there are some crucial points about the nature of rhythm which differ from Feng and Shi’s (2021) proposal, as summarized in Duanmu (2022, 271), repeated in (4). (4) Feng and Shi (2021, 42) distinguish rhythm in language and rhythm in nature: Rhythm in language (jiélǜ 节 律 ): The repetition unit contains an alternation. Rhythm in nature (jiézòu 节 奏 ): The repetition unit contains no alternation. ON BIOLOGICAL PROSODY 3 Duanmu (2022, 272) comments as follows: Feng and Shi (2021) are probably right to propose that there is a difference between rhythm in speech and rhythm in other things. However, the difference does not seem to lie in the lack of alternation in non-speech rhythms. For example, there is an alternation between beat and pause in drum beats, and there is an alternation between day and night in a daily cycle. We can, instead, distinguish speech rhythm and other rhythms by the units of alternation: In speech, the alternating units are phonological categories, such as syllables...