The catalytic hydrogenation of furfural is a key reaction to valorize lignocellulosic biomass into value-added chemicals. In this work, the influence of different hydrogen donors on furfural hydrogenation under continuous-flow conditions was evaluated using a 10% Pd/C catalyst in a Phoenix Flow Reactor. Molecular hydrogen (H2), 2-propanol (transfer hydrogenation), and sodium borohydride (NaBH4) were tested under identical conditions (150 °C, 20 bar, 0.1 mL·min1). Each hydrogen source led to distinct reaction pathways and product distributions. H2 promoted selective formation of furfuryl alcohol (FA) via a Langmuir–Hinshelwood mechanism, with transient formation of tetrahydrofurfuryl alcohol (THFA). 2-propanol favored carbonyl reduction while enabling gradual formation of 2-methylfuran (2-MF) at longer reaction times. NaBH4 yielded FA exclusively through direct hydride transfer but showed operational limitations due to precipitation under flow conditions. Catalyst deactivation was observed in all systems, mainly associated with carbonaceous deposition. While H2 and 2-propanol showed comparable catalytic efficiency, NaBH4 exhibited lower efficiency and limited scalability. These results highlight the critical role of hydrogen donor selection in controlling reaction pathways, selectivity, and process feasibility in continuous-flow biomass valorization.