Widespread mortality of reef‐building coral substantially reduces the capacity for reef growth and makes available extensive bare substrate areas that in the absence of coral recovery will be eroded by a variety of external and internal bioeroders. Here, we analyze rates of external erosion on six different types of carbonate substrates under in situ conditions over a 2‐yr period. We measure vertical changes in the surface elevation of four species of recently dead corals afflicted by the stony coral tissue loss disease outbreak, and other two common types of calcareous substrates, long‐dead Acropora palmata fronds and bare calcareous hardground, as a reference for “bare” carbonate substrates that occur widely in Caribbean reefs. The surface of the recently dead colonies experienced significant erosion after 2 yr of exposure, but at different rates depending on the species. Dead skeletons of Orbicella faveolata experienced the greatest rates of erosion after 2 yr at −9.9 mm (±3.2 mm); Dendrogyra cylindrus eroded −3.6 mm (±2.8 mm), Pseudodiploria strigosa −3.3 mm (±3.7 mm), and Siderastrea siderea −1.2 mm (±0.9 mm), while long‐dead substrates remained unchanged. There was significant erosion in the presence of parrotfish grazing scars and of short algal turf mats, while crustose coralline algae cover and sand‐and‐high turf mats were not associated with significant changes in elevation, arguably indicating a protective effect. This study provides new insights into how and at what rates external carbonate erosion is shaping contemporary reefs at fine spatial and temporal scales.
Promoting resilience is highly relevant to preserving biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. For coral reefs, parrotfish protection emerged as a mainstream action for reversing the degradation experienced by these systems. The rationale is that restoring their populations will increase grazing activity and reinforce control of fast‐growing macroalgae, facilitating coral cover recovery. A lack of a link between parrotfish trends and macroalgae and coral cover trends at a large scale has, however, often been the case. Suggesting more complex underlying dynamics that should be reexamined. In this review, we discuss how lumping parrotfish species as if they were functionally redundant may obscure trends. And how a lack of appreciation of other functions around the parrotfish paradigm, specifically bioerosion, may have unforeseen and potentially adverse effects on degraded reefs. We show that bioerosion responded more directly and quickly to spatial and temporal changes in parrotfish assemblages than macroalgae consumption, arguably due to the varying vulnerability among Caribbean parrotfishes to fisheries and habitat loss. For highly degraded reefs, positive changes in parrotfish populations could hence compromise the remaining coral skeleton structures and the reef framework, further accentuating reef degradation, where increases in macroalgae consumption could not necessarily compensate for higher rates of bioerosion.
Sea urchins perform key ecological functions in coral reefs, such as herbivory and erosion of calcareous structures, which intensify at night. The Cayo Arenas reef, Campeche Bank, Mexico, is located far from the coast, which has helped to protect it from direct anthropogenic threats. However, no information is available on the status of sea urchin populations and the bioerosion processes they perform in the reef. For this reason, we conducted diurnal and nocturnal surveys to characterize urchin density as a function of the diel cycle and to calculate their bioerosive potential. The surveys were conducted at 3 sites with different survey depths (10–19 m) and varying reef heterogeneity related to 2 components: coral cover and sand cover. All surveys were conducted in July 2023. In general, an abundant population of urchins was observed, which was mainly composed of Diadema antillarum. At night, the abundance (14.5 ± 3.8 ind) and bioerosion rate (1.55 ± 0.53 kg CaCO3·m–2·y–1) were higher than during the day (2.6 ± 0.8 ind and 0.2 ± 0.06 kg CaCO3·m–2·y–1). In addition, depth and reef geomorphology seemed to influence the pattern of urchin density. At sites with high reef heterogeneity, sea urchin density was higher at night, which could be associated with a greater availability of refuge from predators. Our results show an underestimation of urchin population densities in daytime surveys and, therefore, their impact on the ecosystem as bioerosion agents because sea urchins are mostly nocturnal but are commonly surveyed during the day.
Coral reefs deliver vital services via a complex three-dimensional framework sustained by the balance between calcium carbonate production and erosion, or the net carbonate budget state. In many tropical western Atlantic reefs, ecological decline has reduced carbonate production, yielding near-neutral or negative budgets. Yet some reefs retain high coral cover and, theoretically, should also have high net positive budgets, yet often show modest carbonate accumulation. We used the remote reef of Cayo Arenas in the Campeche Bank, Gulf of Mexico, to test whether in reefs under suboptimal (variable) environmental conditions, high coral production is offset by robust bioeroder communities, producing neutral budgets. At 14 sites, we quantified carbonate producers and bioeroders to estimate gross production, bioerosion, and net budget states. Despite relatively high live coral cover, mean net carbonate budgets were approximately neutral. Crucially, this neutrality arose not from depressed biological activity (as in degraded reefs) but from an active equilibrium: vigorous carbonate production coupled with substantial bioerosion. These reefs, therefore, represent a contemporary, functional reef state in net stasis. Distinguishing active-neutral from impoverishment-neutral regimes is critical for predicting reef trajectories under environmental change and for targeting management, although near-stasis emerging from high carbonate turnover can appear functionally intact yet operate with limited buffering capacity against net carbonate loss.
Traditional methods for estimating calcium carbonate production on coral reefs rely on in-water line transects that sample only a fraction of the reefscape, inherently introducing spatial biases and under-representing the heterogeneity of coral assemblages. Here, we diagnose how these spatial assumptions influence carbonate production estimates by comparing line transects with full-spur, plan-view mapping derived from structure-from-motion photogrammetry. Three entire reef spurs (ca 850 m² total) within a highly degraded Caribbean reefscape were mapped to quantify coral cover, species composition and gross calcium carbonate production. Full-spur mapping revealed lower but more representative mean coral cover and production than conventional transects, indicating systematic overestimation driven by transect placement and reefscape-structure effects associated with partial spatial sampling (i.e. the spatial configuration of edges, flanks and gaps that can be under-represented by conventional and low-density transect sampling designs). While transect-derived averages masked heterogeneity into near-homogeneous, higher-mean matrices, full-spur mapping resolved strongly patchy production, with small, low-cover patches concentrating a disproportionate share of output amid extensive low-production areas. By coupling spatial structure with process at the scale of natural reef units, this framework exposes hidden biases in long-standing monitoring practices and strengthens the foundations for predicting geomorphic persistence in an era of accelerating reef decline.
Fishing Refuge Zones (FRZs) seek to promote the recovery of exploited populations and associated ecosystems, although their effectiveness depends on various factors, such as habitat condition, the reduction of local stressors, and management implementation. We evaluated changes in the reef fish community of the Akumal FRZ, in the Mexican Caribbean, ten years after its establishment, with emphasis on commercial and herbivorous fishes. In 2025, we revisited 23 shallow and deep reef front sites surveyed in 2015 using visual censuses and benthic video transects. Fish biomass, abundance, and richness were analyzed using generalized linear mixed models; size structure using kernel density estimates; and the relationship between fish biomass and benthic condition using redundancy analysis. Commercial species showed no significant differences in biomass, richness, or size structure, but had lower abundance in 2025. In contrast, herbivores showed higher biomass and a shift toward a larger modal size, although with lower abundance and richness. These changes occurred on a reef with lower coral cover in 2025 and a predominance of brown algae in both periods. The results show a partial and functionally heterogeneous response, in a context of persistent degradation and limitations in management implementation and continuity.