This study evaluates the accuracy and usability of two low-cost uncrewed aerial system (UAS) multispectral sensors—MicaSense RedEdge-M and SlantRange 3p—using a dual-scale comparison framework. Calibrated 3% and 48% reflectance tarps and Analytical Spectral Device (ASD) field spectrometry were used for point-scale absolute validation. The NEON imaging spectrometer (NIS), a well-calibrated airborne hyperspectral sensor, was utilized for a field-scale comparison by spectrally resampling the hyperspectral data to align with the multispectral bands and performing spatial co-registration and aggregation of the multispectral data to a common 1 m grid. Over the 48% tarp, MicaSense Near-infrared (NIR) reflectance was 7.2% below the ASD reference while SlantRange NIR was 7.9% lower, validating previous studies that have observed the underestimation of the NIR band with UAS multispectral sensors. Both sensors overestimated the 3% tarp across all bands when compared to the ASD measurements. Field-scale regressions yielded R2 values above 0.90 for most bands, while NIR slopes were 0.74 for MicaSense and 0.72 for SlantRange. Consistent with these trends, the largest radiometric errors occurred in the NIR region, where both sensors increasingly underestimated high-reflectance surfaces relative to NIS. Median Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) differences relative to NIS were −0.027 and −0.064, and these became more negative with an increasing NIS NDVI. Edge buffering reduced MicaSense bias, whereas the SlantRange showed limited edge effects. These results demonstrate that low-cost UAS multispectral imagery can support ecological applications when calibration, reflectance range, view geometry, and ecosystem-specific validation requirements are explicitly considered.
This study evaluates the accuracy and usability of two low-cost unmanned aerial system (UAS) multispectral sensors—MicaSense RedEdge and SlantRange 3p—by comparing their reflectance measurements and NDVI to those of the NEON Imaging Spectrometer (NIS), a well-calibrated airborne hyperspectral sensor. Field validation was conducted using calibrated reflectance tarps, and spectrally resampled NIS data served as a reference standard. Reflectance comparisons showed both sensors performed well across most land cover types but exhibited systematic biases that prevented statistical equivalence in most bands. The MicaSense sensor generally overestimated reflectance, while the SlantRange sensor underestimated it, particularly in the Green and NIR bands. These biases propa-gated into NDVI calculations, where both UAS sensors reported lower NDVI values than the NIS, with SlantRange showing a larger negative bias. Despite the lower NDVI values and artifacts, including BRDF effects at image edges and background noise over dark sur-faces, the results support the viability of UAS-based multispectral sensing for ecological applications requiring moderate to high accuracy. The study also highlights the critical importance of radiometric calibration and sensor-specific limitations in reflectance range. This comparison framework provides a foundation for broader cross-platform validation efforts and helps inform best practices for ecological remote sensing using low-cost UAS systems.