Power systems are making a transition from purely technical, centrally planned systems to market based, decentralized systems. The need for balancing power and frequency control reserves are increasing, partially due to variable renewable production, which gives an opportunity for new incomes but also a challenge in terms of changed modes of operation with risk for reduced life time for controllable power plants. This paper investigates how the allocation of a sold volume of frequency control reserves within a large hydropower production fleet can affect the costs of providing primary and secondary reserves, in terms of its impact on wear and fatigue, production losses and the quality of the delivered frequency control. The results show that for primary control, low static gain in the governors results in poor quality and a large amount of load cycles of the units. High static gain, on the other hand, increases the production losses. The control work of the fleet can be reduced by using a proper balance of primary and secondary control gain on each unit, although the intuitive results from linear models exaggerate this effect. Automatic secondary control improves the system frequency quality but also increases the wear.
24 April 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion
The upcoming modifications to the criteria for providing Frequency Containment Reserves (FCR) in the Nordic synchronous area present severe challenges for some hydropower units. By quantifying the difference between the required FCR power response and the actual response provided by the unit, an additional power response from an energy storage system can be specified to augment the hydropower unit, thus securing its participation in FCR in the future. A practical method to control the storage system, by applying a band-pass filter on the negative frequency deviation, is presented in this paper. The method is verified using a set of field measurements from Swedish hydropower units currently providing FCR. It is found that all tested units are able to satisfy the upcoming criteria with the specified storage systems. The optimality of the method is discussed by comparing the storage system power and energy ratings to the theoretical minimum. Obtained power ratings between 3% and 24% of the FCR power, combined with a short storage system duration of up to 2.5 minutes, indicate that the method presents a possible application for high-power and low-energy storage technologies.
9 October 2020 in IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion
The grid frequency stability is decreasing in many AC grids due to less inertia in these systems, and their stability is commonly evaluated through simulation. Hydropower often delivers frequency control, yet research on hydropower model validation for large grid frequency disturbances is scarce. We performed frequency control tests on a Kaplan unit and evaluated three models(called the standard grey-box, Kaplan grey-box, and white-box models) against validation data. The grey-box model parameters were identied with grey-box system identication, whereas the white-box model used index test data to relate guide vane opening and runner blade angle to net head, ow, and efciency. All models accounted for steering mechanism backlash. The results showed that the white-box model was overall more reliable than the two grey-box models. However, all models had difculties in simulating the output power the rst few seconds after a large change in frequency. Moreover, backlash sizes had considerable performance impacts on all models. The uncertainties in hydropower model response during the rst few seconds after a disturbance emphasize the importance of sufcient stability margins in grid frequency stability simulations.
A rather novel approach for delivery of inertia-like grid services through energy storage devices is described and validated by physical experiments and on-site measurements. In this approach, denoted “amplified inertia response”, an actual inertial response from a grid-connected synchronous machine is amplified. This inertia emulation approach is contrasted by what is called synthetic inertia, which uses a frequency-locked loop in order to extract the grid frequency. The synthetic inertia faces the usual input signal filtering challenges if the signal-to-noise ratio is low. The amplified inertia controller avoids the input filtering since it only amplifies the natural inertial response from a synchronous machine. However, rotor angle oscillations lead to filtering requirements of the amplified version as well, but on the output signal of the controller. Experimental comparisons are conducted both on the measurement output from the physical experiments in a microgrid and on analysis based on input from on-site measurements from a 55 MVA hydropower generator connected to the Nordic grid. In the specific cases compared, we observe that the amplified inertia version is the better method for smaller power systems, with large frequency fluctuations. On the other hand, the synthetic inertia method is the better in larger power systems as compared to the amplification of the inertial response from a real production unit.