Temporal gravity retrieval simulation results of a future Bender-type double pair mission concept, performed by five processing centers of a Sino-European study team, have been inter-compared and assessed. They were computed in a synthetic closed-loop simulation world by five independent software systems applying different gravity retrieval methods, but were based on jointly defined mission scenarios. The inter-comparison showed that the results achieved a quite similar performance. Exemplarily, the root mean square (RMS) deviations of global equivalent water height fields from their true reference, resolved up to degree and order 30 of a 9-day solution, vary in the order of 10% of the target signal. Also, co-estimated independent daily gravity fields up to degree and order 15, which have been co-estimated by all processing centers, do not show large differences among each other. This positive result is an important pre-requisite and basis for future joint activities towards the realization of next-generation gravity missions.
GPS-based, satellite-to-satellite tracking observations have been extensively used to elaborate the long-scale features of the Earth’s gravity field from dedicated satellite gravity missions. We proposed compiling a satellite gravity field model from Gravity Field and Steady-State Ocean Circulation Explorer (GOCE) satellite accelerations directly estimated from the onboard GPS data using the point-wise acceleration approach, known as the carrier phase differentiation method. First, we composed the phase accelerations from the onboard carrier phase observations based on the sixth-order seven-point differentiator, which can eliminate the carrier phase ambiguity for Low Earth Orbiter (LEO). Next, the three-dimensional (3D) accelerations of the GOCE satellite were estimated from the derived phase accelerations as well as GPS satellite ephemeris and precise clock products. Finally, a global gravity field model up to the degree and order (d/o) 130 was compiled from the 71 days and nearly 2.5 years of 3D satellite accelerations. We also recovered three gravity field models up to d/o 130 from the accelerations derived by differentiating the kinematic orbits of European Space Agency (ESA), Graz, and School of Geodesy and Geomatics (SGG), which was the orbit differentiation method. We analyzed the accuracies of the derived accelerations and the recovered gravity field models based on the carrier phase differentiation method and orbit differentiation method in time, frequency, and spatial domain. The results showed that the carrier phase derived acceleration observations had better accuracy than those derived from kinematic orbits. The accuracy of the recovered gravity field model based on the carrier phase differentiation method using 2.5 years observations was higher than that of the orbit differentiation solutions for degrees greater than 70, and worse than Graz-orbit solution for degrees less than 70. The cumulative geoid height errors of carrier phase, ESA-orbit, and Graz-orbit solutions up to degree and order 130 were 17.70cm, 21.43 cm, and 22.11 cm, respectively.
In contrast to most of the coseismic gravity change studies, which are generally based on data from the Gravity field Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) satellite mission, we use observations from the Gravity field and steady-state Ocean Circulation Explorer (GOCE) Satellite Gravity Gradient (SGG) mission to estimate the coseismic gravity and gravity gradient changes caused by the 2011 Tohoku-Oki Mw 9.0 earthquake. We first construct two global gravity field models up to degree and order 220, before and after the earthquake, based on the least-squares method, with a bandpass Auto Regression Moving Average (ARMA) filter applied to the SGG data along the orbit. In addition, to reduce the influences of colored noise in the SGG data and the polar gap problem on the recovered model, we propose a tailored spherical harmonic (TSH) approach, which only uses the spherical harmonic (SH) coefficients with the degree range 30–95 to compute the coseismic gravity changes in the spatial domain. Then, both the results from the GOCE observations and the GRACE temporal gravity field models (with the same TSH degrees and orders) are simultaneously compared with the forward-modeled signals that are estimated based on the fault slip model of the earthquake event. Although there are considerable misfits between GOCE-derived and modeled gravity gradient changes (ΔVxx, ΔVyy, ΔVzz, and ΔVxz), we find analogous spatial patterns and a significant change (greater than 3σ) in gravity gradients before and after the earthquake. Moreover, we estimate the radial gravity gradient changes from the GOCE-derived monthly time-variable gravity field models before and after the earthquake, whose amplitudes are at a level over three times that of their corresponding uncertainties, and are thus significant. Additionally, the results show that the recovered coseismic gravity signals in the west-to-east direction from GOCE are closer to the modeled signals than those from GRACE in the TSH degree range 30–95. This indicates that the GOCE-derived gravity models might be used as additional observations to infer/explain some time-variable geophysical signals of interest.
The dynamic approach integrates Global Positioning System and K-band range-rate (KRR) observations to enable precise orbit determination (POD) and gravity field recovery. However, background model uncertainties and temporal aliasing introduce frequency-dependent noise into the post-fit KRR residuals, thereby degrading overall solution accuracy. To mitigate these effects, empirical signals are typically modeled using either dynamic (DYN) or kinematic (KIN) parameterization strategies. Nevertheless, the combined use of DYN and KIN parameterizations remains largely unassessed, and their potential synergistic impact on POD and gravity field recovery merits systematic evaluation. This study evaluates the individual and joint impacts of DYN and KIN (DYN+KIN) on The Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) Follow-On orbit accuracy and monthly gravity field recovery using nearly one year of 2019 data (excluding February due to severe data gaps). The refined solutions act as empirical temporal filters, effectively suppressing low-frequency components in KRR residuals, particularly below 1-cycle-per-revolution. Relative to nominal ambiguity-fixed reduced-dynamic orbits, the refined solutions mainly enhance the cross-track component, with DYN+KIN showing the largest improvement, while along-track precision experiences only minor (sub-millimeter) degradation. Overall three-dimensional orbit accuracy improves from 3.8 cm to 3.0 cm (DYN), 2.8 cm (KIN), and 2.8 cm (DYN+KIN). In terms of gravity field recovery, the DYN+KIN solution begins to exhibit more pronounced deviations from the other solutions beyond degree and order 30. Over oceanic regions, residual mass anomaly analysis shows that the DYN+KIN solution is associated with an approximately 16% higher noise level compared to the individual DYN and KIN strategies, which exhibit modest noise reductions relative to the nominal solution. The DYN+KIN also exhibits a dampened ~160-day periodicity in the temporal evolution of low-degree coefficients (e.g., C2,0), likely due to spectral overlap between empirical parameter frequencies and low-degree gravity signal components. These results indicate that over-parameterization introduces spectral redundancy and absorbs geophysical signals, underscoring the need to balance parameter flexibility and signal fidelity in gravity recovery strategies.