For frequently used engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) CeO2-, SiO2-, and Ag, past, current, and future use and environmental release are investigated. Considering an extended period (1950 to 2050), we assess ENMs released through commercial activity as well as found in natural and technical settings. Temporal dynamics, including shifts in release due to ENM product application, stock (delayed use), and subsequent end-of-life product treatment were taken into account. We distinguish predicted concentrations originating in ENM use phase and those originating from end-of-life release. Furthermore, we compare Ag- and CeO2-ENM predictions with existing measurements. The correlations and limitations of the model, and the analytic validity of our approach are discussed in the context of massive use of assumptive model data and high uncertainty on the colloidal material captured by the measurements. Predictions for freshwater CeO2-ENMs range from 1 pg/l (2017) to a few hundred ng/l (2050). Relative to CeO2, the SiO2-ENMs estimates are approximately 1,000 times higher, and those for Ag-ENMs 10 times lower. For most environmental compartments, ENM pose relatively low risk; however, organisms residing near ENM ‘point sources’ (e.g., production plant outfalls and waste treatment plants), which are not considered in the present work, may be at increased risk.
The consequences that engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) may cause in the environment have been under investigation for more than 15 years. Hundreds of millions of euros/dollars have been invested into safety issues of ENMs, and much progress has been made in the understanding of their fate and effects in the environment. After an initial phase of “observing the effects,” research has shifted toward elucidating the mechanisms of fate and ecotoxicological effects. This also included a stronger focus on exposure issues and the development of analytical methods and computational models to predict exposure. First environmental risk assessments for ENM were performed, and much progress has been achieved on the way to nanospecific and material‐specific assessments. The release of ENM from products and their transformation in technical and natural compartments profoundly affect the form in which the ENMs are present in the environment. A crucial aspect in all areas isifthere are truly nanospecific issues of the novel‐added functionalities of ENM that are different from dissolved metals, larger particles, or natural particles. This review outlines progress in understanding the environmental dimensions of ENMs and areas that merit further investigation: To what extent are ENMs different from their natural counterparts and how “long” do we need to track them in natural and technical systems? A major challenge will be in developing methods for studying particle‐mediated processes and their effects on ecosystems and organisms in a more general sense, going beyond just ENM, for example, to natural nanoparticles, microplastics, and extracellular vesicles.
1 December 2015 in Science of The Total Environment
All nanomaterial exposure estimates require fundamental knowledge about the production volumes of the nanomaterials. Published values of production volume can vary by orders of magnitude, mainly caused by ambiguities in the definition of what a nanomaterial actually is. The recommendation for a definition of “nanomaterials” by the European Commission has to some extent clarified this issue. In the meantime, first data are available for registered production volumes of nanomaterials in France based on a mandatory registration scheme. We have compared the tonnages of registered production and import of substances in nanoform in France with the estimated total market volumes of these substances, which include both non-nanoforms (bulk) and nanoforms. These substances comprised CaCO3, carbon black, TiO2, SiO2, ZnO, AZO-based and diketo-pyrrolo-pyrrole-based (DPP) pigments as well as carbon nanotubes. The results show that some materials such as SiO2 and DPP have a good match between reported nanoform and total production volumes, whereas for other materials such as TiO2 and ZnO the reported nanoform production volumes are only a fraction of the total production volumes. This means that for SiO2 and DPP the “conventional form” and the nanoform are identical, while TiO2 and ZnO have been used as bulk materials in several applications. With this knowledge that for SiO2 the global production of “conventional” silica is in fact all nano-silica, we can apply the information on the uses of conventional silica to refine the material flow model for nano-silica. The results of this updated modeling show an input mass flow of (nano)silica to environmental compartments that is four to five times larger than previously modelled. The flows to natural and urban soils even increased by a factor of 13, because not only the production but also single specific applications (such as the use in tires) may have a considerable impact on the environmental exposure. Future environmental risk assessments ought to prioritize both by production volume and/or by the probability of direct environmental releases, considering that data on conventional substances may often represent forms of the substances that are nanomaterials in terms of the definition that is recommended by the European Commission.
Engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) are intentionally designed in different nano-forms of the same parent material in order to meet application requirements. Different grouping and read-across concepts are proposed to streamline risk assessments by pooling nano-forms in one category. Environmental grouping concepts still are in their infancy and mainly focus on grouping by hazard categories. Complete risk assessments require data on environmental release and exposure not only for ENMs but also for their nano-forms. The key requirement is to identify and to distinguish the production volumes of the ENMs regarding nano-form-specific applications. The aim of our work was to evaluate whether such a grouping is possible with the available data and which influence it has on the environmental risk assessment of ENMs. A functionality-driven approach was applied to match the material-specific property (i.e. crystal form/morphology) with the functions employed in the applications. We demonstrate that for nano-TiO2, carbon nanotubes (CNTs), and nano-Al2O3 the total production volume can be allocated to specific nano-forms based on their functionalities. The differentiated assessments result in a variation of the predicted environmental concentrations for anatase vs. rutile nano-TiO2, single-wall vs. multi-wall CNTs and α- vs. γ-nano-Al2O3 by a factor of 2 to 13. Additionally, the nano-form-specific predicted no-effect concentrations for these ENMs were derived. The risk quotients for all nano-forms indicated no immediate risk in freshwaters. Our results suggest that grouping and read-across concepts should include both a nano-form release potential for estimating the environmental exposure and separately consider the nano-forms in environmental risk assessments.