Random effects probit and logit are nonlinear models, so we need predicted probabilities and marginal effects to communicate the economic significance of results. In these calculations, how one treats the individual-specific error term matters. Should one (i) set them equal to zero or (ii) integrate them out? We argue that (ii) is the quantity that most readers would expect to see. We discuss these in the context of the statistical package Stata, which changed its default predictions from (i) to (ii) in version 14. In Appendix 5, we illustrate how to calculate predictions and marginal effects using method (ii) in Stata 13 and earlier.
The strategy frequency estimation method (Dal Bó and Fréchette in Am Econ Rev 101(1):411-429, 2011; Fudenberg in Am Econ Rev 102(2):720-749, 2012) allows us to estimate the fraction of subjects playing each of a list of strategies in an infinitely repeated game. Currently, this method assumes that subjects tremble with the same probability. This paper extends this method, so that subjects’ trembles can be heterogeneous. Out of 60 ex ante plausible specifications, the selected model uses the six strategies described in Dal Bó and Fréchette (2018), and allows the distribution of trembles to vary by strategy.
1 June 2019 in Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics
We run an experiment to compare belief formation and learning under compound risk and under ambiguity at the individual level. We estimate a four-type mixture model assuming that subjects may either follow Bayes Rule or behave according to the multiple priors model of Epstein and Schneider (2007) for each type of uncertainty. Our results indicate that majority of subjects are Bayesian, both under compound risk and under ambiguity, while the second most frequent type are subjects that are Bayesian under compound risk but who use multiple priors model of learning under ambiguity. In addition, we find strong evidence against a common assumption that participants' initial beliefs (and priors) are consistent with information provided about the uncertain process.