In this study, a Bayesian-based three-cornered hat (BTCH) method is developed to improve the estimation of terrestrial evapotranspiration (ET) by integrating multisource ET products without using any a priori knowledge. Ten long-term (30 years) gridded ET datasets from statistical or empirical, remotely-sensed, and land surface models over contiguous United States (CONUS) are integrated by the BTCH and ensemble mean (EM) methods. ET observations from eddy covariance towers (ETEC) at AmeriFlux sites and ET values from the water balance method (ETWB) are used to evaluate the BTCH- and EM-integrated ET estimates. Results indicate that BTCH performs better than EM and all the individual parent products. Moreover, the trend of BTCH-integrated ET estimates, and their influential factors (e.g., air temperature, normalized differential vegetation index, and precipitation) from 1982 to 2011 are analyzed by the Mann–Kendall method. Finally, the 30-year (1982 to 2011) total water storage anomaly (TWSA) in the Mississippi River Basin (MRB) is retrieved based on the BTCH-integrated ET estimates. The TWSA retrievals in this study agree well with those from the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE).
It is of great significance for the validation of remotely sensed evapotranspiration (ET) products to solve the spatial-scale mismatch between site observations and remote sensing estimations. To overcome this challenge, this paper proposes a comprehensive framework for obtaining the ground truth ET at the satellite pixel scale (1 × 1 km resolution in MODIS satellite imagery). The main idea of this framework is to first quantitatively evaluate the spatial heterogeneity of the land surface, then combine the eddy covariance (EC)-observed ET (ET_EC) to be able to compare and optimize the upscaling methods (among five data-driven and three mechanism-driven methods) through direct validation and cross-validation, and finally use the optimal method to obtain the ground truth ET at the satellite pixel scale. The results showed that the ET_EC was superior over homogeneous underlying surfaces with a root mean square error (RMSE) of 0.34 mm/d. Over moderately and highly heterogeneous underlying surfaces, the Gaussian process regression (GPR) method performed better (the RMSEs were 0.51 mm/d and 0.60 mm/d, respectively). Finally, an integrated method (namely, using the ET_EC for homogeneous surfaces and the GPR method for moderately and highly heterogeneous underlying surfaces) was proposed to obtain the ground truth ET over fifteen typical underlying surfaces in the Heihe River Basin. Furthermore, the uncertainty of ground truth ET was quantitatively evaluated. The results showed that the ground truth ET at the satellite pixel scale is relatively reliable with an uncertainty of 0.02–0.41 mm/d. The upscaling framework proposed in this paper can be used to obtain the ground truth ET at the satellite pixel scale and its uncertainty, and it has great potential to be applied in more regions around the globe for remotely sensed ET products’ validation.
Validation of remotely sensed evapotranspiration (RS_ET) products is important because their accuracy is critical for various scientific applications. In this study, an integrated validation framework was proposed for evaluating RS_ET products with coarse spatial resolution extending from homogenous to heterogeneous land surfaces. This framework was applied at the pixel and river basin scales, using direct and indirect validation methods with multisource validation datasets, which solved the spatial mismatch between ground measurements and remotely sensed products. The accuracy, rationality of spatiotemporal variations, and error sources of RS_ET products and uncertainties during the validation process were the focuses in the framework. The application of this framework is exemplified by validating five widely used RS_ET products (i.e., GLEAM, DTD, MOD16, ETMonitor, and GLASS) in the Heihe River Basin from 2012 to 2016. Combined with the results from direct (as the priority method) and indirect validation (as the auxiliary method), DTD showed the highest accuracy (1-MAPE) in the vegetation growing season (75%), followed by ETMonitor (71%), GLASS (68%), GLEAM (54%), and MOD16 (44%). Each product reasonably reflected the spatiotemporal variations in the validation dataset. ETMonitor exhibited the highest consistency with the ground truth ET at the basin scale (ETMap) (R = 0.69), followed by GLASS (0.65), DTD (0.63), MOD16 (0.62), and GLEAM (0.57). Error sources of these RS_ET products were mainly due to the limitations of the algorithms and the coarse spatial resolution of the input data, while the uncertainties in the validation process amounted to 15–28%. This work is proposed to effectively validate and improve the RS_ET products over heterogeneous land surfaces.
Accurate estimation of surface evapotranspiration (ET) in the Heihe River Basin using remote sensing data is crucial for understanding water dynamics in arid regions. In this paper, by coupling physical constraints and machine learning for hybrid modeling, we develop a hybrid model based on surface conductance optimization. A hybrid modeling algorithm, two physical process-based ET algorithms (Penman–Monteith-based and Priestley–Taylor-based ET algorithms), and three pure machine learning algorithms (Random Forest, Extreme Gradient Boosting, and K Nearest Neighbors) are comparatively analyzed for estimating the ET. The results showed that, in general, the machine learning model optimized by parameters was able to better predict the surface conductance of the hybrid model. Driver analyses showed that radiation, normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), and air temperature had high correlations with ET. The hybrid model had a better prediction performance for ET than the other five models, and it improved the R2 of the two physical process-based algorithms to 0.9, reduced the root mean square error (RMSE) to 0.5 mm/day, reduced the BIAS to 0.2 mm/day, and improved the Kling–Gupta efficiency (KGE) to 0.9. The hybrid model outperformed the others across different time scales, displaying lower BIAS, RMSE, and higher KGE. Spatially, its ET patterns aligned with regional vegetation changes, with superior accuracy in annual ET estimation compared to the other models. Comparison with other ET products shows that the estimation results based on the hybrid model have better performance. This approach not only improves the accuracy of ET estimation but also improves the understanding of the physical mechanism of ET estimation by pure machine learning models. This study can provide important support for understanding ET and hydrological processes under different climatic and biotic vegetation in other arid and semi-arid regions.
The validation of remotely sensed evapotranspiration (ET) products is important for the development of ET estimation models and the accuracy of the scientific application of the products. In this study, different ET products such as HiTLL, MOD16A2, ETMonitor, and SoGAE were compared using multi-source remote sensing data and ground-based data to evaluate their applicability in the Heihe River Basin (HRB) during 2010–2019. The results of the comparison with the site observations show that ETMonitor provides a more stable and reliable estimation of ET than the other three products. The ET exhibited significant variations over the decade, characterized by a general increase in rates across the HRB. These changes were markedly influenced by variations in land use and topographical features. Specifically, the analysis showed that farmland and forested areas had higher ET rates due to greater vegetation cover and moisture availability, while grasslands and water bodies demonstrated lower ET rates, reflecting their respective land cover characteristics. This study further explored the influence of various factors on ET, including land use changes, NDVI, temperature, and precipitation. It was found that changes in land use, such as increases in agricultural areas or reforestation efforts, directly influenced ET rates. Moreover, meteorological conditions such as temperature and precipitation patterns also played crucial roles, with warmer temperatures and higher precipitation correlating with increased ET. This study highlights the significant impact of land use and climatic factors on spatiotemporal variations in ET within the HRB, underscoring its importance for optimizing water resource management and land use planning in arid regions.