Gamification is a trending topic in the scientific community. It is the art of incorporating game elements and game design principles into non-game context. The phenomenon has garnered tremendous attention especially in the field of education and academics. Yet, since it appeared a decade ago, its ascension both in education and other domains hasn’t been uniform, with several failed and inconclusive results. Consequently, scholars have, over the years, made several efforts to probe why gamification isn’t succeeding as hoped. We attempt, therefore, to contribute to this effort by reviewing and discussing some of the core reasons why gamification seems to be faltering in the field of learning and education. Our findings revealed four (4) factors why gamification could be failing. Shallow gamification which is the simplistic and surficial application of game elements on a learning system or activity without transforming the core experience is one determinant. Overjustification effect, the excessive and arbitral use of rewards (extrinsic motivators), which hampers intrinsic motivation is another success determinant. The ‘badges, points, and leaderboards (BPL) gamification’ (or BPL triad) which refers to the use of basic game elements such as the badges, points, and leaderboards is also one reason gamification is still struggling. Lastly, the overreliance on narrow models and theories to explain or design gamified experiences is identified as a factor for gamification haziness. Our study suggests several antidotes to these highlighted challenges, such as deep intentional designs that transcend surface-level implementation of game elements (what is called ‘deep gamification’). Amidst the spree of excessive extrinsic rewards anyhow, we propose a careful consideration of implementing reward-based game elements, especially in multiple learning settings. Again, a move-away from the narrow and overly used models such as the self-determination theory, and flow theory could open success pathways. As we believe, narrow theoretical lens through which gamification is often viewed serves as a limiting factor, impeding the field's progression and obscuring the full potential of gamification as an approach.
27 December 2024 in Neural Computing and Applications
Extant literature has highlighted the vulnerability of Automatic Fingerprint Identification System (AFIS) to various forms of attacks, indicating presentation attack as the most predominant. This form of attack involves the malicious utilization of ubiquitous materials such as silicone, gelatin, playdoh, among many others, to fabricate synthetic fingerprints to circumvent AFIS. As a result, various studies have posited some countermeasures, encompassing the use of hardware- based and software-based techniques. The hardware-based methods necessitate the integration of supplementary sensors for capturing other live human traits such as pulse rate, odour etc. Conversely, the software-based methods are focused on feature extraction and deep learning schemes. However, despite the robustness of the software-based approach as compared to the hardware-based technique, both schemes are still faced with an immense challenge in developing fingerprint spoof generalized models to mitigate the concern of cross-material (novel) detection. As a result, various studies have highlighted that the issue of fingerprint spoofing should be treated an” opened-set problem” (training only live fingerprints), rather than a” closed-set problem” (training live & spoof), birthing the development of fingerprint one-class classifiers. This article presents a comprehensive detail on fingerprint spoofing, extant countermeasures and the challenge still faced by fingerprint spoof detectors.