Misinformation has found a new natural habitat in the digital age. Thousands of forums, blogs, and alternative news sources amplify fake news and inaccurate information to such a degree that it impacts our collective intelligence. Researchers and policy makers are troubled by misinformation because it is presumed to energize or even carry false narratives that can motivate poor decision-making and dangerous behaviors. Yet, while a growing body of research has focused on how viral misinformation spreads, little work has examined how false narratives are in fact constructed. In this study, we move beyond contagion inspired approaches to examine how people construct a false narrative. We apply prior work in cognitive science on narrative understanding to illustrate how the narrative changes over time and in response to social dynamics, and examine how forum participants draw upon a diverse set of online sources to substantiate the narrative. We find that the narrative is based primarily on reinterpretations of conventional and scholarly sources, and then used to provide an alternate account of unfolding events. We conclude that the link between misinformation, conventional knowledge, and false narratives is more complex than is often presumed, and advocate for a more direct study of this relationship.
1 November 2017 in Environmental Modelling & Software
Online tech support communities have become valuable channels for users to seek and provide solutions to specific problems. From the resource exchange perspective, the sustainability of a social system is contingent upon the size of its members as well as their communication activities. To further extend the resource-based model, the current research identifies a variety of social roles in a large tech support Q&A forum and examines longitudinal changes in the community's structure based on the identification. Moreover, this study also investigates the relationship between the community's functionality and its traffic. Results suggest that the proportion of unsolved questions negatively impacts the number of future incoming questions and the outcome of a given question is not only dependent on users' interactions within the discussion, but also on the community activities preceding the question. These observations can help community managers to improve system design and task allocation.
The dynamics of charitable donor co-attendance networks can help fundraisers assess and improve fundraising outcomes. To improve understanding of donor-giving patterns, this study examines a large, multi-year network describing the co-attendance of donors at charitable fundraising events. We analyze the dynamics of co-attendance networks based on their topological structure, shift in node characteristics, and various network properties. Among other results, we observe a 76% increase in giving value for donors that showed increased centrality rank over nonoverlapped snapshots. In the data we examined, 19.14% of the donors whose giving increased and 16.24% of donors that remained in the same giving range exhibited increased co-attendance with high-capacity donors, whereas none of the donors that shifted to a lower class exhibited increased co-attendance with high-capacity donors over the periods, potentially illustrating a positive peer effect on donors. Some similarity was also observed in the giving characteristics of donors who co-attend events, with a 0.211 assortativity coefficient for the giving class of donors as a characteristic of donors when considering network dynamics using a rolling window size of 3 years. This is followed by analyzing the group-level similarities that reveal an interlinked clique of communities with diverse sizes. Our results show that large communities have a higher fraction of wealthy donors.