Current national and international guidelines recommend genetic testing in women with breast cancer (BC) who fulfill recognized or established family history (FH) or clinical criteria. These criteria are surrogates for
BRCA (
BRCA1 [OMIM 113705] and
BRCA2 [OMIM 600185]) probability, with genetic testing usually offered at approximately a 10% probability threshold of being a
BRCA carrier.
1,2 Being a
BRCA (mutation) carrier refers to carrying an inheritable genetic pathogenic variant that predisposes to development of
BRCA-associated cancers. However, patients with BC and genetic pathogenic variants do not always have a positive FH, and these criteria miss a large proportion (approximately 50%) of pathogenic variant carriers.
3-5 A genetic testing strategy based on clinical criteria or FH depends on the patient and their physician’s awareness and understanding of the importance of FH, FH accuracy, communication within or between families, and timely referrals to clinical genetics departments. Limited awareness by health care professionals and the public, complexity of the current structure, restricted genetic counseling services, and current testing pathways have fostered restricted access and massive underuse of genetic testing services.
6-8 Only 20% to 30% of eligible patients are referred and access testing, and 97% of estimated carriers in the population remain unidentified,
7 missing substantial opportunities for precision prevention.
6 Testing all patients with BC at diagnosis can increase testing access and uptake and identify many more pathogenic variant carriers for screening and prevention. We herein evaluate the cost-effectiveness of this alternative approach of providing genetic testing to all patients with BC regardless of FH.