Jeannine McManus

Dr. Jeannine McManus

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

13Years (2014-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
18 September 2018 in PLOS Biology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LELily Van Eeden
Lily Van Eeden
AEAnn Eklund
Ann Eklund
JMJennifer R. B. Miller
Jennifer R. B. Miller
JLJosé Vicente López-Bao
José Vicente López-Bao
GCGuillaume Chapron
Guillaume Chapron
ATAdrian Treves
Adrian Treves
Carnivore predation on livestock often leads people to retaliate. Persecution by humans has contributed strongly to global endangerment of carnivores. Preventing livestock losses would help to achieve three goals common to many human societies: preserve nature, protect animal welfare, and safeguard human livelihoods. Between 2016 and 2018, four independent reviews evaluated >40 years of research on lethal and nonlethal interventions for reducing predation on livestock. From 114 studies, we find a striking conclusion: scarce quantitative comparisons of interventions and scarce comparisons against experimental controls preclude strong inference about the effectiveness of methods. For wise investment of public resources in protecting livestock and carnivores, evidence of effectiveness should be a prerequisite to policy making or large-scale funding of any method or, at a minimum, should be measured during implementation. An appropriate evidence base is needed, and we recommend a coalition of scientists and managers be formed to establish and encourage use of consistent standards in future experimental evaluations.

1 September 2016 in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ATAdrian Treves
Adrian Treves
MKMiha Krofel
Miha Krofel
JMJeannine McManus
Jeannine McManus
Livestock owners traditionally use various non‐lethal and lethal methods to protect their domestic animals from wild predators. However, many of these methods are implemented without first considering experimental evidence of their effectiveness in mitigating predation‐related threats or avoiding ecological degradation. To inform future policy and research on predators, we systematically evaluated evidence for interventions against carnivore (canid, felid, and ursid) predation on livestock in North American and European farms. We also reviewed a selection of tests from other continents to help assess the global generality of our findings. Twelve published tests – representing five non‐lethal methods and 7 lethal methods – met the accepted standard of scientific inference (random assignment or quasi‐experimental case‐control) without bias in sampling, treatment, measurement, or reporting. Of those twelve, prevention of livestock predation was demonstrated in six tests (four non‐lethal and two lethal), whereas counterintuitive increases in predation were shown in two tests (zero non‐lethal and two lethal); the remaining four (one non‐lethal and three lethal) showed no effect on predation. Only two non‐lethal methods (one associated with livestock‐guarding dogs and the other with a visual deterrent termed “fladry”) assigned treatments randomly, provided reliable inference, and demonstrated preventive effects. We recommend that policy makers suspend predator control efforts that lack evidence for functional effectiveness and that scientists focus on stringent standards of evidence in tests of predator control.

30 April 2014 in Oryx
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JMJeannine McManus
Jeannine McManus
ADA. J. Dickman
A. J. Dickman
DGD. Gaynor
D. Gaynor
BSB. H. Smuts
B. H. Smuts
DMD. W. Macdonald
D. W. Macdonald
Livestock depredation has implications for conservation and agronomy; it can be costly for farmers and can prompt retaliatory killing of carnivores. Lethal control measures are readily available and are reportedly perceived to be cheaper, more practical and more effective than non-lethal methods. However, the costs and efficacy of lethal vs non-lethal approaches have rarely been compared formally. We conducted a 3-year study on 11 South African livestock farms, examining costs and benefits of lethal and non-lethal conflict mitigation methods. Farmers used existing lethal control in the first year and switched to guardian animals (dogsCanis familiarisand alpacasLama pacos) or livestock protection collars for the following 2 years. During the first year the mean cost of livestock protection was USD 3.30 per head of stock and the mean cost of depredation was USD 20.11 per head of stock. In the first year of non-lethal control the combined implementation and running costs were similar to those of lethal control (USD 3.08 per head). However, the mean cost of depredation decreased by 69.3%, to USD 6.52 per head. In the second year of non-lethal control the running costs (USD 0.43 per head) were significantly lower than in previous years and depredation costs decreased further, to USD 5.49 per head. Our results suggest that non-lethal methods of human–wildlife conflict mitigation can reduce depredation and can be economically advantageous compared to lethal methods of predator control.

24 December 2014 in Ecology and Evolution
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JMJeannine McManus
Jeannine McManus
DDDesire Dalton
Desire Dalton
AKAntoinette Kotzé
Antoinette Kotzé
BSBool Smuts
Bool Smuts
ADAmy Dickman
Amy Dickman
MKMark Keith
Mark Keith
While African leopard populations are considered to be continuous as demonstrated by their high genetic variation, the southernmost leopard population exists in the Eastern and Western Cape, South Africa, where anthropogenic activities may be affecting this population's structure. Little is known about the elusive, last free-roaming top predator in the region and this study is the first to report on leopard population structuring using nuclear DNA. By analyzing 14 microsatellite markers from 40 leopard tissue samples, we aimed to understand the populations' structure, genetic distance, and gene flow (Nm). Our results, based on spatially explicit analysis with Bayesian methods, indicate that leopards in the region exist in a fragmented population structure with lower than expected genetic diversity. Three population groups were identified, between which low to moderate levels of gene flow were observed (Nm 0.5 to 3.6). One subpopulation exhibited low genetic differentiation, suggesting a continuous population structure, while the remaining two appear to be less connected, with low emigration and immigration between these populations. Therefore, genetic barriers are present between the subpopulations, and while leopards in the study region may function as a metapopulation, anthropogenic activities threaten to decrease habitat and movement further. Our results indicate that the leopard population may become isolated within a few generations and suggest that management actions should aim to increase habitat connectivity and reduce human–carnivore conflict. Understanding genetic diversity and connectivity of populations has important conservation implications that can highlight management of priority populations to reverse the effects of human-caused extinctions.

7 March 2018 in African Journal of Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
CDCarolyn Devens
Carolyn Devens
TTThulani Tshabalala
Thulani Tshabalala
JMJeannine McManus
Jeannine McManus
BSBool Smuts
Bool Smuts

8 June 2021 in Agriculture and Human Values
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
LBLouise Boronyak
Louise Boronyak
Brent JacobsBrent Jacobs
Brent Jacobs
AWArian Wallach
Arian Wallach
JMJeannine McManus
Jeannine McManus
SSS. Stone
S. Stone
HZH. Zaranek
H. Zaranek