Historically stable areas across North Africa, known as pseudo invariant calibration sites (PICS), have been used as targets for the calibration and monitoring of optical satellite sensors. However, two major drawbacks exist for these sites: first is the dependency on a single location to be always invariant, and second is the limited amount of observation achieved using these sites. As a result, longer time periods are necessary to construct a dense dataset to assess the radiometric performance of on-orbit optical sensors and confirm that the change detected is sensor-specific rather than site-specific. This work presents a global land cover classification to obtain an extended pseudo invariant calibration site (EPICS) on a global scale using Landsat-8 Operational Land Imager (OLI) data. This technique provides multiple calibration sites across the globe, allowing for the building of richer datasets in a shorter time frame compared to the traditional approach (PICS), with the advantage of assessing the calibration and stability of the sensors faster, detecting possible changes sooner and correcting them accordingly. This work identified 23 World Reference System two (WRS-2) path/row locations around the globe as part of the global EPICS. These EPICS have the advantage of achieving multiple observations per day, with similar spectral characteristics compared to traditional PICS, while still producing a temporal coefficient of variation (ratio of temporal standard deviation and temporal mean) less than 4% for all bands, with some as low as 2.7%.
This study presents the selection of 20 Extended Pseudo Invariant Calibration Sites (EPICS) for radiometric calibration and the derivation of their hyperspectral profiles using the DLR Earth Sensing Imaging Spectrometer (DESIS) and Hyperion data. The hyperspectral profile of one of these clusters, the GONA-EPICS cluster, was validated against ground truth measurements from the RadCalNet Gobabeb Namibia (GONA) site, demonstrating statistical agreement within their respective uncertainties through Welch’s test. The applicability of these hyperspectral profiles was further evaluated by generating Spectral Band Adjustment Factor (SBAF) between Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2A using the GONA-EPICS hyperspectral profile and comparing them to SBAF values derived from RadCalNet GONA site measurements. SBAF results were statistically the same, while SBAF derived from the combined DESIS and Hyperion data exhibited reduced uncertainty compared to those derived using Hyperion data alone, which is attributed to DESIS’s finer spectral resolution (2.5 nm vs. 10 nm). To assess EPICS applicability in cross-calibration, Cluster 13-GTS, which includes pixels from the Libya 4 CNES ROI, was used as a target. Cross-calibration gains obtained using EPICS and the T2T cross-calibration methodology were compared to those from the traditional cross-calibration approach using Libya 4 CNES ROI. Results demonstrated statistically similar gains, with EPICS achieving an uncertainty better than 6% across all bands compared to 4.4% for the traditional method, while enabling global coverage for daily cross-calibration opportunities. This study introduces globally distributed EPICS with validated hyperspectral profiles, offering enhanced spectral resolution and reliability for radiometric calibration and stability monitoring. The methodology supports efficient global scale sensor calibration and prepares for future hyperspectral missions.
This study introduces a global land cover clustering using an unsupervised algorithm, incorporating the novel step of filtering data to retain only temporally stable pixels before applying K-means clustering. Unlike previous approaches that did not assess the pixel-level temporal stability, this method provides more reliable clustering results. The K-means identified 160 distinct clusters, with Cluster 13 Global Temporally Stable (Cluster 13-GTS) showing significant improvements in temporal stability. Compared to Cluster 13 Global (Cluster 13-G) from earlier research, Cluster 13-GTS reduced the coefficient of variation by up to 1% and increased the number of calibration locations from 23 to over 50. This study also validated these clusters using TOA reflectance from ground-truth measurements collected at the Radiometric Calibration Network (RadCalNet) Gobabeb (RCN-GONA) site, incorporating data from Landsat 8, Landsat 9, Sentinel-2A, and Sentinel-2B. The GONA Extended Pseudo Invariant Calibration Sites (EPICS) GONA-EPICS cluster used for the validation provided statistically comparable mean TOA reflectance to RCN-GONA, with a reduced chi-square test indicating minimal differences within the cluster’s uncertainty range. Notably, the difference in reflectance between RCN-GONA and GONA-EPICS was less than 0.023 units across all the bands. Although GONA-EPICS exhibited slightly higher uncertainty (6.4% to 10.3%) compared to RCN-GONA site (<5%), it offered advantages such as 80 potential calibration points per Landsat cycle and reduced temporal instability, and it provided alternatives to reduce the reliance on single sites like traditional PICS or RCN-GONA, making it a valuable tool for calibration efforts. These findings highlight the potential of the newly developed EPICS for radiometric calibration and stability monitoring of optical satellite sensors. Distributed across diverse regions, these global targets increase the number of calibration points available for any sensor in any orbital cycle, reducing the reliance on traditional PICS and offering more robust targets for radiometric calibration efforts.
Calibrating optical sensors has become a priority to maintain data quality and ensure consistency among sensors from different agencies. Achieving and monitoring radiometric calibration often involves the identification of temporally stable targets on the Earth’s surface. Although some locations across North Africa have traditionally been used as primary targets for calibration purposes, it is crucial to explore alternative options to account for potential changes in these sites over time. This study conducted a global assessment of pixel-level temporal stability using Landsat 8 OLI data, with the primary goal of identifying regions suitable for global radiometric calibration efforts. This work followed a two-stage approach, including the testing and selection of an effective combination of statistical tests to differentiate between temporally stable and unstable pixels and the generation of a worldwide mosaic of temporally stable pixels through a per-pixel statistical analysis employing a combination of Spearman’s rho and Pettitt’s test for assessing long-term trends and detecting change points. Notably, comparing the temporal mean top-of-atmosphere (TOA) reflectance before and after applying the generated temporal filter to a site with documented unstable pixels revealed a substantial reduction in mean variation, up to 6%. In addition, slopes observed in the pre-filter mean TOA reflectance, ranging between −0.002 and −0.005, became zero or near-zero and statistically insignificant after the temporal filter was applied, demonstrating a reduction in total uncertainties by 3 to 4%. These findings evidence the potential of this work, placing it as a potential foundation in the continuous search to identify additional targets for global radiometric calibration efforts.