This study investigates and compares archaeological site management practices across diverse cultural contexts, focusing on how cultural factors influence preservation, stakeholder involvement, and management strategies. Employing a mixed-methods comparative design, the research integrates field observations, interviews with site managers and local stakeholders, and archival analysis. Three case studies, the Giza Necropolis in Egypt, Madain Saleh in Saudi Arabia, and the Al-Ain Archaeological Sites in the United Arab Emirates, form the empirical foundation for this analysis. Thematic and qualitative comparative analyses are used to identify cross-cultural patterns, challenges, and best practices. The findings reveal that management approaches are profoundly shaped by their respective cultural settings. Regions with strong traditions of community participation, such as Al-Ain, tend to integrate local knowledge and foster sustainable preservation outcomes. In contrast, state-dominated systems, as seen in Egypt and Saudi Arabia, often face constraints related to bureaucratic processes and limited local engagement. Across all contexts, factors such as governance structures, funding mechanisms, and cultural attitudes toward heritage emerge as decisive in shaping management effectiveness and sustainability. The results offer essential perspectives for the strategy of engaging local communities in the management of archaeological sites, and may be beneficial for implementation in other Arab countries.
This study investigates how foreign tour guides mediate Emirati heritage within the United Arab Emirates’ (UAE) cultural tourism sector and how their interpretations influence perceptions of authenticity and national identity. Employing a qualitative, interpretivist, multi-site case study across Dubai, Abu Dhabi, and Sharjah, it integrates participant observation, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis to explore interactions among institutional narratives, guide performances, and tourist perceptions. Findings reveal that foreign guides function as key cultural mediators who perform and translate Emirati heritage across linguistic and cultural boundaries. Authenticity emerges as enacted and relational, co-constructed through performance, empathy, and visitor engagement. Institutional heritage discourses promoting unity, progress, and tolerance frame these interpretations, but guides exercise agency, generating hybrid narratives blending Emirati and global elements. The study advances performance theory by highlighting guided agency within institutional scripts, supports performative over objectivist authenticity, applies Bhabha’s ‘third space’ to hybrid mediation, and demonstrates national identity as performatively constructed through a multicultural workforce. It contributes empirically to understanding non-national interpreters in Gulf heritage contexts and recommends intercultural training and inclusive heritage frameworks.
In recent years, Egyptian state institutions have invested considerably in the restoration of historic synagogues and the public presentation of Jewish material culture as part of a broader narrati...