Ketika daerah perbatasan belum mampu menjadi beranda dan etalase estetis bagi suatu negara, pembangunan daerah perbatasan layak menjadi sebuah isu strategis yang perlu diprioritaskan dalam implementasi kebijakan desentralisasi. Sistem desentralisasi dan otonomi daerah yang diterapkan oleh pemerintah Indonesia memang dianggap menjadi pilihan yang paling tepat untuk wilayah Indonesia yang merupakan negara kepulauan dengan keragaman sosial-budaya, bahasa, dan geografi. Hal tersebut tentu membutuhkan perhatian dan penanganan khusus dari pemerintah pusat dan daerah. Namun, saat ini masih banyak persoalan yang belum diselesaikan di daerah perbatasan Indonesia. Pada realitasnya, masih banyak masyarakat di daerah perbatasan yang belum merasakan tingkat kesejahteraan yang sama dengan masyarakat di daerah. Masyarakat di daerah perbatasan belum sepenuhnya dilibatkan langsung dalam penyusunan kebijakan daerah mereka sehingga kebijakan tersebut belum mampu mengakomodasi kebutuhan masyarakat yang sesuai dengan realitas di daerah perbatasan. Pemerintah daerah selama ini juga hanya memiliki kewenangan terbatas dan terkesan masih sangat terikat dengan pemerintah pusat. Bahkan, Badan Nasional Pengelola Perbatasan (BNPP) dan Badan Pengelola Perbatasan Daerah (BPPD) yang selama ini dibentuk dengan tujuan untuk mengawal dan mempercepat pembangunan di daerah perbatasan, hanya menjalankan fungsi koordinasi yang justru terkesan memperpanjang rantai birokrasi. Buku ini adalah jawaban atas beberapa persoalan tersebut. Dengan beberapa analisis terkait persoalan di daerah perbatasan, buku ini juga menyajikan informasi tentang prinsip-prinsip yang seharusnya diterapkan dalam pengelolaan otonomi daerah perbatasan serta beberapa strategi yang dapat diujicobakan untuk meningkatkan perbaikan pembangunan daerah perbatasan.
Background: Indonesia’s border regions are strategically important for national sovereignty but remain underdeveloped despite decentralization reforms since 2001. Border governance is constrained by institutional fragmentation, weak coordination, and fiscal dependency. This study examines why decentralization has not translated into effective border development by identifying multilevel governance gaps across Indonesia’s border provinces. Methods: This study applies a comparative qualitative design across seven border provinces: North Kalimantan, West Kalimantan, East Nusa Tenggara, North Sulawesi, Riau Islands, Maluku, and Aceh. Data were collected through field observations, 35 semi-structured interviews with stakeholders at multiple governance levels, and policy documents from the National Border Management Agency (BNPP) and regional agencies. The data were thematically analyzed using the United Nations Public Administration Network (UNPAN) seven-gap framework and interpreted through Bolleyer and Thorlakson’s multilevel governance typology. Results: The findings reveal a decentralization paradox: although Indonesia formally adopts decentralization, border governance operates through an interdependent-centralized model. Key failures appear in fiscal dependency, policy-objective misalignment, territorial constraints, limited institutional capacity, and weak accountability. The National Border Management Agency (BNPP) and Regional Border Management Agency (BPPD) remain constrained by unclear authority distribution and weak executive coordination. Conclusion: Decentralization in Indonesia’s borderlands has produced institutional dependency rather than substantive autonomy. Regulatory harmonization, fiscal sustainability, stronger institutional capacity, and improved intergovernmental coordination are essential to transform borderlands into more inclusive development regions.
29 September 2025 in Journal of Indonesian Economy and Business
Introduction/Main Objectives: In order to achieve target 1.1 of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), i.e., to end extreme poverty by 2030, the Indonesian Government encourages the distribution of social assistance as one of the main programs. Background Problems: There are several issues related to the distribution of social assistance that impact the effectiveness of this program. This study aims to investigate the challenges and evaluate possible solutions for the effectiveness of social assistance distribution. Novelty: This study proposes alternative solutions to improve the effectiveness of social assistance distribution in Indonesia. Research Methods: This research uses a descriptive qualitative approach and SOAR analysis (strengths, opportunities, aspirations, and results). The data have been obtained from a literature review and focus group discussions. Finding/Results: The results of the analysis identify three problems, namely (i) inaccuracy of the target beneficiary data, (ii) absence of formed cooperative between stakeholders in the distribution process, and (iii) the amount of cash in the social assistance has not been able to meet the cost of living in several regions in Indonesia. Solutions that can be used to overcome these problems are (1) updating the data and improving the accuracy of targeting of social assistance, (2) strengthening the synergy of the social assistance program organized by government, (3) an adjustment, carried out by local governments, of the value of social assistance benefits, and (4) strengthening the supervision of the social assistance distribution process. Conclusion: The alternative solutions above are "tactical" approaches that need to be employed by the government to increase the effectiveness of social assistance distribution to alleviate extreme poverty.