Robustness of four wheat simulation model were tested with 2-year field experiments of three cultivars across a wide range of sowing dates in two different climatic regions: Faisalabad (semi-arid) and Layyah (arid), in Punjab-Pakistan. Wheat growing season temperature ranged from -0.1°C to 43°C. The wide series of sowing dates was a unique opportunity to grow the wheat in an environment which temperatures varies from -0.1°C to 43°C. The CERES-Wheat, Nwheat, CROPSIM-Wheat and APSIM-Wheat model were calibrated against the least-stressed treatment for each wheat cultivar. Overall, the four models described performance of early, optimum and late sown wheat well, but poorly described yields of very late planting dates with associated high temperatures during grain filling. The poor accuracy of simulations of yield for extreme planting dates point to the need to improve the accuracy of model simulations at the high end of the growing temperature range, especially given the expected future increases in growing season temperature. Improvement in simulation of maximum leaf area index of wheat for all models is needed. APSIM-Wheat only poorly simulated days to maturity of very and extremely late sown wheat compared to other models. Overall, there is a need of improvement in function of models to response high temperature.
Maize is one of the main cereal crops in Pakistan with sensitivity to drought at various developmental stages known to influence the yield. The impact of variable weather conditions on maize yield can be analyzed with crop simulation models. The CSM-CERES-Maize model has been widely used to assess irrigation strategies for maize. This research was conducted to test the CSM-CERES-Maize model for its ability to accurately predict maize biomass and grain yield under water limiting and non-limiting conditions in semiarid conditions. Four growth stage-based irrigation treatments and two potential soil moisture deficit-based treatments were defined. During model calibration, the simulated maximum leaf area index (LAI), total dry matter (TDM), and grain yield were all within 10% of observed values. During model evaluation, there was generally satisfactory agreement between observed and simulated values for two hybrids (Monsanto-919 and Pioneer-30Y87) with the model showing variability of −17.9–20.0%, −9.2–14.3%, and −19.6–19.9% for maximum LAI, TDM, and grain yield, respectively, for the two hybrids among various treatments. The CERES-Maize model was useful in providing information to decision-making regarding diverse irrigation regimes at the farm level in a semiarid environment.
1 April 2017 in Journal of Integrative Agriculture