In this paper, we present a comparative study of tribological properties of TiN coatings deposited by low-voltage electron beam evaporation, magnetron sputtering and cathodic arc deposition. The correlation of tribological behavior of these coatings with their intrinsic properties and friction condition was studied. The influence of surface topography and the surrounding atmosphere was analyzed in more detail. We limited ourselves to the investigation of tribological processes that take place in the initial phase of the sliding test (the first 1000 cycles). A significant difference in the initial phase of the sliding test of three types of TiN coatings was observed. We found that nodular defects on the coating surface have an important role in this stage of the sliding test. The tribological response of TiN coatings, prepared by cathodic arc deposition, is also affected by the metal droplets on the coating surface, as well as those incorporated in the coating itself. Namely, the soft metal droplets increase the adhesion component of friction. The wear rates increased with the surface roughness of TiN coatings, the most for coatings prepared by cathodic arc deposition. The influences of post-polishing of the coating and the surrounding atmosphere were also investigated. The sliding tests on different types of TiN coatings were conducted in ambient air, oxygen and nitrogen. While oxygen promotes tribo-chemical reactions at the contact surface of the coating, nitrogen suppresses them. We found that the wear rate measured in ambient air, compared with that in an oxygen atmosphere, was lower. The difference is probably due to the influence of humidity in the ambient air. On the other hand, wear rates measured in a nitrogen atmosphere were much lower in comparison with those measured in an oxygen or ambient air atmosphere.
11 September 2013 in Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering
Reports of the influence of surface roughness on the adhesion and tribological performance of contemporary nitride coatings with different layer designs are still scarce in the literature. Therefore, in this study, we evaluated the behavior of a single-layer TiAlN, a bilayer TiAlN/CNx, and a nanolayer AlTiN/TiN coating. Coatings were deposited in an industrial magnetron sputtering unit on the substrates of EN 100Cr6 steel, prepared to four degrees of surface roughness (Sa = 10–550 nm). The coatings’ adhesion was determined by scratch tests performed perpendicular and parallel to the machining marks. Dry reciprocating sliding tests in air were employed to evaluate the coatings’ tribological behavior against an Al2O3 ball. Before and after the tests, coating properties were characterized by 3D profilometry, confocal microscopy, and energy dispersive spectroscopy. Deposition of all coatings significantly altered the surface topography and increased the roughness of the samples. No general rule could be established for the effect of surface roughness on tribological behavior and adhesion of different hard coatings. For very fine surface finishes the adhesion and tribological performance of TiAlN and TiAlN/CNx coatings was independent of the surface roughness. For the roughest surfaces, a decrease in adhesion and an increase in the wear rate were observed. The AlTiN/TiN coating exhibited the largest sensitivity of adhesion to roughness and scratching direction. The coefficient of friction and wear rate increased when AlTiN/TiN roughness exceeded Sa ≈ 100 nm.