18 January 2023 in International Journal of STEM Education
There has been substantial research undertaken on the integration of computational thinking (CT) in K-12 mathematics education in recent years, particularly since 2018 when relevant systematic reviews were conducted on the topic. Many empirical studies in this area have yet to elaborate clearly and explicitly on how CT may support mathematics learning, or otherwise, in CT-based mathematics activities. Addressing this research gap, we conducted a systematic review on the integration of CT in K-12 mathematics education with a focus on CT-based mathematics instruction and students learning under such instruction. The Web of Science database was searched for in terms of studies published from 2006 to 2021, from which 24 articles were selected to provide illustrations of CT-based mathematics instruction and related student learning, and they were further analyzed according to education levels and contexts, programming tools, learning outcomes in CT and mathematics, and the mutual relationship between CT and mathematics learning. Among the results, this review found that geometrized programming and student-centered instructional approaches were facilitators of productive learning in CT and mathematics. Moreover, CT-based mathematics learning entails an interactive and cyclical process of reasoning mathematically and reasoning computationally, which can occur when: (1) applying mathematics to construct CT artefacts; (2) applying mathematics to anticipate and interpret CT outputs; and (3) generating new mathematical knowledge in parallel with the development of CT. The findings contribute to an in-depth understanding of what, and how, CT-based mathematics instruction impacts student learning in K-12 contexts.
30 May 2024 in Journal of Educational Computing Research
A growing body of research is focusing on integrating artificial intelligence (AI) and computational thinking (CT) to enhance student learning outcomes. Many researchers have designed instructional activities to achieve various learning goals within this field. Despite the prevalence of studies focusing on instructional design and student learning outcomes, how instructional efforts result in the integration of AI and CT in students’ learning processes remains unclear. To address this research gap, we conducted a systematic literature review of empirical studies that have integrated AI and CT for student development. We collected 18 papers from four prominent research databases in the fields of education and AI technology: Web of Science, Scopus, IEEE, and ACM. We coded the collected studies, highlighting the students’ learning processes in terms of research methodology and context, learning tools and instructional design, student learning outcomes, and the interaction between AI and CT. The integration of AI and CT occurs in two ways: the integration of disciplinary knowledge and leveraging AI tools to learn CT. Specifically, we discovered that AI- and CT-related tools, projects, and problems facilitated student-centered instructional designs, resulting in productive AI and CT learning outcomes.
25 October 2023 in Journal of Educational Computing Research
Computational thinking (CT) has received much attention in mathematics education in recent years, and researchers have begun to experiment with the integration of CT into mathematics education to promote students’ CT and mathematical thinking (MT) development. However, there is a lack of empirical evidence and new theoretical perspectives on the mechanisms of interaction between CT and MT. To address this research gap, this study analyses the participants’ thinking processes in solving programming-based mathematical problems from a flexibility perspective, focusing on the interplay between computational and mathematical thinking, that is, how CT and MT work together to influence and determine the problem-solver’s choice of solution strategy. Using data collected from a large design-based study, we summarise two types of flexibility and six subtypes of flexibility demonstrated by participants in the programming-based mathematical problem-solving process using thematic analysis. These different types of flexibility provide researchers and mathematics educators with new theoretical perspectives to examine the interplay of CT and MT. Findings will also contribute toward student learning characteristics in programming-based mathematical problem-solving to sketch the big picture of how CT and MT emerge in complementary or mismatching ways.
5 May 2026 in ZDM – Mathematics Education
Integrating computational thinking (CT) and artificial intelligence (AI) to foster interdisciplinary learning has received much-needed attention worldwide in educational research, though less emphasis has been placed on simultaneously developing CT and AI learning outcomes in disciplinary (e.g., mathematics) classroom contexts. CT and AI are closely linked to mathematics, where knowledge of data practices, mathematical modelling, and generic skills such as problem-solving are highly emphasized. This paper reports on a design-based research study with four design cycles, aiming to generate empirically grounded design principles for curricular and instructional innovations in school mathematics contexts that simultaneously support CT and AI learning. Drawing upon the theoretical perspectives of CT as modelling and programming as white-boxing, and taking exemplary tasks developed from our design-based study, we detail four design principles: (1) Encourage tinkering with computational artefacts; (2) Leverage CT as modelling for authentic problem-solving; (3) Consider tool-based developmental trajectories; and (4) Exploit the white-box effect to foster mathematical and AI literacy. From this, we conceive mathematics, CT, and AI as interconnected disciplines, where learning outcomes are not treated separately but rather as translatable across different disciplinary boundaries. We conclude by discussing the opportunities and challenges of implementing the curricular and instructional designs, offering insights to inform how CT and AI concepts and processes can be meaningfully embedded in mathematics education.