Objective: The purpose of this study was to compare outcomes between orthopaedic trainees using various preoperative training platforms (physical simulation [PS], virtual reality [VR], and reading/videos) in a slipped capital femoral epiphysis model. Methods: Participants were randomly assigned to one of the three groups: (1) reading/video control group (n = 7), (2) VR group (n = 7), or (3) PS group (n = 7). Participants in the VR group completed a VR slipped capital femoral epiphysis module while participants in the PS group practiced the placement of a screw in the physical module before evaluation of percutaneous screw placement in the PS model. Outcomes evaluated included overall surgical time, amount of fluoroscopy, Global Rating Scale score, radiographic screw position, physical screw accuracy, presence of breeching of the articular surface or femoral neck, and overall platform rating (0 to 10). Results: No difference was observed in surgical time, Global Rating Scale score, radiographic or physical accuracy of screw position, or articular surface breaching between the groups. Subjectively, there was a difference in utility of platform rating between the groups (PS: 10 ± 0, VR: 7 ± 2, and control: 6 ± 1, P = 0.001). Conclusion: Training with VR was subjectively rated higher in value compared with reading/video methods and had similar performance outcomes compared with training with PS.
Periacetabular osteotomy (PAO) is a common surgical treatment for developmental dysplasia of the hip. To obtain the optimal method of fixation during PAO, different screw fixation techniques have been proposed for stabilizing the acetabular fragment. This study assesses the biomechanical performance of two popular 3-screw fixation techniques: iliac (IS) and transverse (IT) configurations, through finite element simulations. Additionally, different 2-screw combinations are simulated to investigate the biomechanical significance of each screw of the fixation configurations. The study findings show that yield load of the pelvic bone subject to gait loading for IT configuration is on average 7% higher compared to that of the IS. Although the yield load of the IT is predicted to be slightly higher, no significant difference in bone stiffness and displacement of the acetabular fragment are found between two configurations. Simulation results, therefore, do not demonstrate a significant biomechanical advantage of the IT configuration over the IS. Furthermore, the biomechanical comparison between the 2-screw combinations of IS and IT fixations demonstrates that the most anterior screw in IS, located at the iliac crest, and the most medial screw in the IT are the most critical elements in providing sufficient stability and support for acetabular fragment.
20 November 2020 in Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics
Background: Deformity index (DI) and extrusion index (EI) are 2 radiographic methods currently used to quantify femoral head deformity in the active stages of Legg-Calvé-Perthes disease. This study aimed to quantify the interobserver reproducibility of the 2 methods using a large, international group of pediatric orthopaedic surgeons with diverse clinical experience. Methods: Radiographs of patients (age 6 to 11 y at time of diagnosis) prospectively enrolled in an international multicenter-cohort study, were measured by members of our study group. For each radiograph, the raters independently assessed EI (n=33 cases) and DI (n=32 cases), along with the rater’s subjective assessment of the extent of hip deformity (ie, none, mild, moderate, or severe). Reliability analysis was conducted using intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and κ techniques. Results: The ICC for EI on the affected side was 0.68 (95% confidence interval: 0.57-0.79). The calculated DI ICC was 0.53 (95% confidence interval: 0.41-0.68). Subjectively, an average of 68±3.5% of surgeons agreed on the subjective description of each patient’s femoral head deformity. Conclusions: EI is measured with a reasonably high rate of correlation among surgeons from disparate backgrounds. Agreement is lower among the same group of surgeons when the more complex DI is used. DI is most useful when utilized by a small number of experienced observers in a research setting, whereas EI may have better clinical applicability. Level of Evidence: Level III—reliability study.