20 January 2025 in Nature Reviews Biodiversity
To address the losses of river biodiversity worldwide, various conservation actions have been implemented to promote recovery of species and ecosystems. In this Review, we assess the effectiveness of these actions globally and regionally, and identify causes of success and failure. Overall, actions elicit little improvement in river biodiversity, in contrast with reports from terrestrial and marine ecosystems. This lack of improvement does not necessarily indicate a failure of any individual action. Rather, it can be attributed in part to remaining unaddressed stressors driving biodiversity loss; a poor match between the spatial scale of action and the scale of the affected area; and absence of adequate monitoring, including insufficient timescales, missing reference and control sites or insufficient selection of targeted taxa. Furthermore, outcomes are often not reported and are unevenly distributed among actions, regions and organism groups. Expanding from local-scale actions to coordinated, transformative, catchment-scale management approaches shows promise for improving outcomes. Such approaches involve identifying major stressors, appropriate conservation actions and source populations for recolonization, as well as comprehensive monitoring, relevant legislation and engaging all stakeholders to promote the recovery of river biodiversity.
14 February 2020 in Ecology and Evolution
Ecological data sets often record the abundance of species, together with a set of explanatory variables. Multivariate statistical methods are optimal to analyze such data and are thus frequently used in ecology for exploration, visualization, and inference. Most approaches are based on pairwise distance matrices instead of the sites‐by‐species matrix, which stands in stark contrast to univariate statistics, where data models, assuming specific distributions, are the norm. However, through advances in statistical theory and computational power, models for multivariate data have gained traction. Systematic simulation‐based performance evaluations of these methods are important as guides for practitioners but still lacking. Here, we compare two model‐based methods, multivariate generalized linear models (MvGLMs) and constrained quadratic ordination (CQO), with two distance‐based methods, distance‐based redundancy analysis (dbRDA) and canonical correspondence analysis (CCA). We studied the performance of the methods to discriminate between causal variables and noise variables for 190 simulated data sets covering different sample sizes and data distributions. MvGLM and dbRDA differentiated accurately between causal and noise variables. The former had the lowest false‐positive rate (0.008), while the latter had the lowest false‐negative rate (0.027). CQO and CCA had the highest false‐negative rate (0.291) and false‐positive rate (0.256), respectively, where these error rates were typically high for data sets with linear responses. Our study shows that both model‐ and distance‐based methods have their place in the ecologist's statistical toolbox. MvGLM and dbRDA are reliable for analyzing species–environment relations, whereas both CQO and CCA exhibited considerable flaws, especially with linear environmental gradients.
1 September 2024 in European Journal of Soil Science
For nature conservation and planning, terrestrial ecosystems are commonly classified based on their plant communities. Although soils are fundamental to ecosystem functioning, ecosystem classifications based on soil organisms are rare, and it is poorly understood whether their assemblage compositions follow existing classification schemes. We examined whether commonly used ecosystem types capture variation in earthworm (Lumbricidae) assemblages—a crucial biotic component of soil ecosystems. To this end, we created four ecosystem classifications by combining large‐scale climatic classifications (Biogeographic Regions [BGR] and Holdridge Life Zones [HLZ]) with small‐scale land cover classifications (CORINE Land Cover [CLC] and European Nature Information System [EUNIS]). European earthworm assemblage data from the sWORM and Edaphobase databases were analysed for variation in composition within and among ecosystem types, using Permutational Analysis of Variance and Analysis of Similarities. Additionally, we used Typical Species Analysis to establish typical earthworm assemblages (TAs) for each ecosystem type. Ecosystem classifications using the BGR explained more variance than HLZ, but HLZ showed a higher separation of assemblages between ecosystem types. The differentiation between Atlantic and Continental climates in the BGR could explain the superiority over the HLZ, which had only one category for the cool temperate zone of our study region. The typical assemblages contained on average six species, with some habitat generalists present in most. This study shows that combinations of ecosystem properties from different spatial scales can be used to distinguish between earthworm assemblages at the European level. However, earthworm assemblages across Europe were highly similar due to low species richness and the dominance of a few widespread species. This limits the possibility of applying TAs on large spatial scales, for example, for environmental monitoring. We suggest that future studies should explore the use of more species‐rich groups of soil organisms to characterize ecosystem types.
23 November 2025 in Ecography
River networks are complex ecosystems characterized by a continuous exchange of material and energy through longitudinal gradients. These ecosystems are threatened by various human‐induced stressors, which frequently co‐occur and may interact in complex ways, potentially triggering cascading effects throughout the river network. Aiming at assessing single and combined effects of flow intermittency and light pollution on macroinvertebrate communities, we performed a multiple stressors experiment in 18 flow‐through mesocosms. Each mesocosm was designed to mimic a simplified river network, with two upstream tributaries merging downstream, allowing us to assess both local and cascading effects. The experiment was performed in summer 2021 over seven weeks, applying the stressors either separately or co‐occurring in the upstream sections, following a randomized block design. Flow intermittency was simulated as the ponded phase of the drying process, whereas light pollution was applied with LED strips set to 10 lux. Drifting macroinvertebrates were sampled weekly during the treatment phase, and benthic macroinvertebrates were sampled at the end of the treatment phase. Both stressors, when applied individually, reduced benthos richness and abundance, whereas drift decreased with flow intermittency and increased with light pollution. When co‐occurring upstream, stressors showed the dominant effects of flow intermittency on the benthos and interactive effects on the drift. The effects of the single stressors and their interactions cascaded along the river network, with stronger downstream effects when stressors co‐occurred upstream. These findings show that the spatial distribution of multiple stressors along the river network can affect their resultant downstream effects, highlighting the importance of framing multiple‐stressors research in a spatial context. Considering the pressing needs of the growing human population, our results represent a step forward in anticipating the effects of cumulative stressors and in informing efficient conservation strategies for protecting freshwater ecosystems.
24 December 2025 in Environment International
Environmental risk assessment (ERA) of plant protection products (PPPs) in the European Union is conducted on a substance-by-substance basis. This hampers the comparison of risks across substances, taxa, uses, or ecosystems, thereby limiting the identification of lower-risk alternatives. We propose a conceptual framework for benchmarking, i.e., systematic comparison and ranking of PPPs based on standardised risk profiles. The framework builds on our analyses of key challenges in the current ERA, including heterogeneity in higher-tier data, divergent representative use scenarios, inconsistent time scales, and the absence of a centralised data repository. The framework addresses these issues by promoting consistent criteria, streamlining input variables, and enhancing data integration. The practical applicability is illustrated with a proof-of-concept using Tier 1 aquatic effect data and FOCUS Step 1 exposure. Benchmarking outcomes may be influenced by current gaps in hazard assessment, but the framework is designed for iterative updates and can be extended to biocontrol agents through adjustable endpoints. By leveraging harmonised test methods and existing regulatory data, the framework aims to support science-based, comparative, and adaptive ERA processes. This approach supports a shift from a substance-by-substance review to a comparative, systems-based ERA. Implementing benchmarking would enhance regulatory efficiency, improve transparency, and promote a more sustainable pesticide use in line with biodiversity protection goals.
30 September 2024 in bioRxiv
River networks are complex ecosystems characterized by a continuous exchange of material and energy through longitudinal gradients. These ecosystems are threatened by various human-induced stressors, which frequently co-occur and may interact in complex ways, potentially triggering cascading effects in the river network. Aiming at assessing single and combined effects of flow intermittency and light pollution on macroinvertebrate communities, we performed a multiple stressors experiment in 18 flow-through mesocosms. Each mesocosm was designed to mimic a simplified river network, with two upstream tributaries merging downstream, to assess both local and cascading effects. The experiment was performed in Summer 2021 for seven weeks (26 days of colonization, 23 days of treatment), applying the stressors either separately or combined in the upstream sections, in a randomized block design. Flow intermittency was simulated as the ponded phase of the drying process, whereas light pollution was applied with LED strips (set at 10 lux) that automatically turned on at sunset and off at sunrise. Drifting macroinvertebrates were sampled weekly during the treatment phase, and benthic macroinvertebrates at the end of the treatment phase. Both stressors individually applied had negative effects on the benthos, whereas drift decreased with flow intermittency and increased with light pollution. When combined upstream, stressors showed dominant effects of flow intermittency on the benthos and interactive effects on the drift. The effects of the single stressors and their interactions propagated along the river network, with stronger downstream effects when stressors co-occurred upstream. These findings showed that the spatial distribution of multiple stressors along the river network can affect their resultant downstream effects, highlighting the importance of framing multiple stressors research in a spatial context. Considering the pressing needs of the growing human population, our results represent a step forward in anticipating cumulative stressors effects, informing efficient conservation strategies for protecting freshwater ecosystems.