We performed a series of hydraulic stimulations at 1.1 km depth in the Bedretto underground laboratory, Switzerland, as part of an overall research strategy attempting to understand induced seismicity on different scales. Using an ultra‐high frequency seismic network we detect seismic events as small as Mw < −4, revealing intricate details of a complex fracture network extending over 100 m from the injection sites. Here, we outline the experimental approach and present seismic catalogs as well as a comparative analysis of event number per injection, magnitudes, b‐values, seismogenic index and reactivation pressures. In our first‐order seismicity analysis, we could make the following observations: The rock volume impacted by the stimulations in different intervals differs significantly with a lateral extent from a few meters to more than 150 m. In most intervals multiple fractures were reactivated. The seismicity typically propagates upwards toward shallower depth on parallel oriented planes that are consistent with the stress field and seem to a large extent associated with preexisting open fractures. This experiment confirms the diversity in seismic behavior independent from the injection protocol. The overall seismicity patterns demonstrate that multi‐stage stimulations using zonal isolation allow developing an extended fracture network in a 3D rock volume, which is necessary for enhanced geothermal systems. Our stimulations covering two orders of magnitude in terms of injected volume will give insights into upscaling of induced seismicity from underground laboratory scale to field scale.
Understanding the seismicity and hydromechanical processes during hydraulic stimulation in hectometer-scale in situ experiments is crucial for bridging the gap between laboratory studies, decameter-scale in situ experiments, and large-scale geothermal projects. These insights can help to optimize the use of geothermal energy. A key example of this is the Bedretto Underground Laboratory in Switzerland, where multiple hydraulic stimulation experiments were conducted between 2021 and 2023 at a hectometer scale. In this study, we present modifications of standard seismic event processing techniques for mesoscale experiments, enabling the accurate detection and location of picoseismic events at these scales. We differentiate between the needs of seismic catalogs for rapid hazard assessment, which require real-time detection of large-magnitude events, and postprocessed catalogs, which are essential for detailed analysis of activated fracture networks, for which a complete seismic catalog is essential. In addition, we evaluate the impact of picking accuracy, background 1D velocity model, and network coverage on the final event locations within a mesoscale underground 3D seismic network, a novelty in experimental seismology.
22 November 2024 in Journal of Open Source Software
Detecting earthquakes and compiling the events into earthquake catalogs are fundamental tasks in seismology. Acoustic emission sensors allow for the detection of the tiniest so-called picoseismic events, representing fractures on the cm or dm scale (-5<magnitude<0). Even smaller seismic events are recorded in the laboratory. Picoseismic events have corner frequencies of 1 kHz-100 kHz. They are typically recorded with sampling frequencies of 200 kHz to 1 MHz and cannot be handled by standard seismic processing software that is developed for signals with frequencies f<500 Hz. Commercial software for continuous recording and processing of picoseismicity exists (e.g., GMuG-conti, fastloc.REEL) and is successfully used in scientific in-situ experiments (e.g., hydraulic stimulation, earthquake nucleation, nuclear waste disposal). However, commercial software comes with restrictions that are undesirable for university-based in-situ experiments in underground laboratories; where tailoring the software to experiment with specific questions or adding newly developed analysis techniques are routine operations in order to advance the study of the rock response in greater detail. The open-source DUGseis software package fills this gap. It has been developed to manage, process, and visualize continuous, high-frequency seismic data. The package can be used to create real-time and post-processing earthquake catalogs and to directly visualize their event waveforms and locations in a graphical interface. Since the software is Python-based, users can easily add their own processing routines.
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlash related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments worldwide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometre-scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback afb value and the Gutenberg–Richter b value) and ground motion models (GMMs) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduces once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are (1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies and (2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can contribute to improving our understanding of the the physical reasons leading to such variable seismogenic responses. The presented analysis implied that such experiments may be limited in terms of upscaling but are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
Understanding seismicity and hydro-mechanical processes during hydraulic stimulation in hectometer-scale in-situ experiments is an important step for bridging the gap between laboratory studies and deca-meter scale in-situ experiments on the one hand and large-scale geothermal projects on the other hand. These insights can help to optimize the use of geothermal energy. A key example of such a project on the hectometer scale is the Bedretto Underground Laboratory in Switzerland, where multiple hydraulic stimulation experiments were conducted between 2021 and 2023. In this study, we present the seismic event processing steps adapted to mesoscale experiments, providing a framework for future mesoscale projects. We outline two main goals for seismic catalog creation of hydraulic stimulations: First, the development of real-time catalogs aimed at hazard assessment, which prioritize the detection of large-magnitude events. These catalogs are optimized for rapid decision-making but may overlook smaller events. Second, we focus on post-processed catalogs designed for detailed analysis of activated fracture networks, where a complete seismic catalog is essential. Additionally, we evaluate the influence of picking accuracy, homogeneous 1D velocity model, and the network coverage on the final event locations in the context of a mesoscale underground 3D seismic network, a novelty in experimental seismology. This analysis highlights the sensitivity of picoseismic event locations to these factors, providing critical insights for accurate seismic monitoring in complex geological settings.