Barbara Haya

Barbara Haya

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Barbara Haya

Goldman School of Public Policy, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

16Years (2011-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
20 October 2021 in Global Change Biology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
GBGrayson Badgley
Grayson Badgley
JFJeremy Freeman
Jeremy Freeman
JHJoseph J. Hamman
Joseph J. Hamman
BHBarbara Haya
Barbara Haya
ATAnna Trugman
Anna Trugman
DCDanny Cullenward
Danny Cullenward
Carbon offsets are widely used by individuals, corporations, and governments to mitigate their greenhouse gas emissions on the assumption that offsets reflect equivalent climate benefits achieved elsewhere. These climate‐equivalence claims depend on offsets providing real and additional climate benefits beyond what would have happened, counterfactually, without the offsets project. Here, we evaluate the design of California's prominent forest carbon offsets program and demonstrate that its climate‐equivalence claims fall far short on the basis of directly observable evidence. By design, California's program awards large volumes of offset credits to forest projects with carbon stocks that exceed regional averages. This paradigm allows for adverse selection, which could occur if project developers preferentially select forests that are ecologically distinct from unrepresentative regional averages. By digitizing and analyzing comprehensive offset project records alongside detailed forest inventory data, we provide direct evidence that comparing projects against coarse regional carbon averages has led to systematic over‐crediting of 30.0 million tCO2e (90% CI: 20.5–38.6 million tCO2e) or 29.4% of the credits we analyzed (90% CI: 20.1%–37.8%). These excess credits are worth an estimated $410 million (90% CI: $280–$528 million) at recent market prices. Rather than improve forest management to store additional carbon, California's forest offsets program creates incentives to generate offset credits that do not reflect real climate benefits.

14 November 2024 in Nature Communications
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BPBenedict S. Probst
Benedict S. Probst
MTMalte Toetzke
Malte Toetzke
AKAndreas Kontoleon
Andreas Kontoleon
LALaura Díaz Anadón
Laura Díaz Anadón
JMJan C. Minx
Jan C. Minx
VHVolker H. Hoffmann
Volker H. Hoffmann
Carbon markets play an important role in firms’ and governments’ climate strategies. Carbon crediting mechanisms allow project developers to earn carbon credits through mitigation projects. Several studies have raised concerns about environmental integrity, though a systematic evaluation is missing. We synthesized studies relying on experimental or rigorous observational methods, covering 14 studies on 2346 carbon mitigation projects and 51 studies investigating similar field interventions implemented without issuing carbon credits. The analysis covers one-fifth of the credit volume issued to date, almost 1 billion tons of CO2e. We estimate that less than 16% of the carbon credits issued to the investigated projects constitute real emission reductions, with 11% for cookstoves, 16% for SF6 destruction, 25% for avoided deforestation, 68% for HFC-23 abatement, and no statistically significant emission reductions from wind power and improved forest management projects. Carbon crediting mechanisms need to be reformed fundamentally to meaningfully contribute to climate change mitigation.

21 March 2023 in Frontiers in Forests and Global Change
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
BHBarbara K. Haya
Barbara K. Haya
SESamuel Evans
Samuel Evans
LBLetty Brown
Letty Brown
JBJacob Bukoski
Jacob Bukoski
VBVan Butsic
Van Butsic
DSDaniel L. Sanchez
Daniel L. Sanchez
Improved forest management (IFM) has the potential to remove and store large quantities of carbon from the atmosphere. Around the world, 293 IFM offset projects have produced 11% of offset credits by voluntary offset registries to date, channeling substantial climate mitigation funds into forest management projects. This paper summarizes the state of the scientific literature for key carbon offset quality criteria—additionality, baselines, leakage, durability, and forest carbon accounting—and discusses how well currently used IFM protocols align with this literature. Our analysis identifies important areas where the protocols deviate from scientific understanding related to baselines, leakage, risk of reversal, and the accounting of carbon in forests and harvested wood products, risking significant over-estimation of carbon offset credits. We recommend specific improvements to the protocols that would likely result in more accurate estimates of program impact, and identify areas in need of more research. Most importantly, more conservative baselines can substantially reduce, but not resolve, over-crediting risk from multiple factors.

29 June 2020 in Climate Policy
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BHBarbara Haya
Barbara Haya
DCDanny Cullenward
Danny Cullenward
ASAaron Strong
Aaron Strong
EGEmily Grubert
Emily Grubert
RHRobert Heilmayr
Robert Heilmayr
MWMichael Wara
Michael Wara
Carbon offsets allow greenhouse gas emitters to comply with an emissions cap by paying others outside of the capped sectors to reduce emissions. The first major carbon offset programme, the United Nations’ Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), has been criticized for generating a large number of credits from projects that do not actually reduce emissions. Following the controversial CDM experience, California pioneered a second-generation compliance offset programme that shifts the focus of quality control from assessments of individual projects to the development of offset protocols, which define project type-specific eligibility criteria and methods for estimating emissions reductions. We assess the ability of California’s ‘standardized approach’ to mitigate the risk of over-crediting greenhouse gas reductions by reviewing the development of two California offset protocols – Mine Methane Capture and Rice Cultivation. We examine the regulator’s treatment of three sources of over-crediting under the CDM: non-additional projects, inflated counterfactual baseline scenarios, and perverse incentives that inadvertently increase emissions. We find that the standardized approach offers the ability to reduce, but not eliminate, the risk of over-crediting. This requires careful protocol-scale analysis, conservative methods for estimating reductions, ongoing monitoring of programme outcomes, and restricting participation to project types with manageable levels of uncertainty in emission reductions. However, several of these elements are missing from California’s regime, and even best practices result in significant uncertainty in true emission reductions. Relying on carbon offsets to lower compliance costs risks lessening total emission reductions and increases uncertainty in whether an emissions target has been met. Key policy insights

23 January 2024 in Nature Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
AGAnnelise Gill-Wiehl
Annelise Gill-Wiehl
DKDaniel Kammen
Daniel Kammen
BHBarbara K. Haya
Barbara K. Haya

10 June 2024 in Global Environmental Change
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
TWThales A.P. West
Thales A.P. West
BBBarbara Bomfim
Barbara Bomfim
BHBarbara K. Haya
Barbara K. Haya