Background: Fentanyl is a synthetic opioid associated with illicit drug use and overdose deaths. The SEFRIA Immunalysis (IAL) and ARK fentanyl assays are both FDA-cleared, open channel immunoassays for fentanyl detection in urine. However, limited data are available in the literature comparing these assays. The objective of this study was to perform a direct comparison of these two fentanyl immunoassays. Methods: IAL and ARK fentanyl immunoassays were performed on a Roche Cobas e602 automated chemistry analyzer. Repeatability and total imprecision were compared by diluting fentanyl into urine at concentrations above, below, and at the manufacturers’ cutoffs of 1.0 ng/mL. Cross-reactivity was assessed for norfentanyl and the fentanyl analogs acetylfentanyl, acrylfentanyl, and furanylfentanyl. Concordance was assessed in 90 patient samples using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) as the gold standard. Results: Repeatability varied from 11.4%–17.8% on the IAL assay and 2.8%–5.5% on the ARK assay. Total imprecision was 18.9%–40.7% on the IAL assay and 2.9%–6.4% on the ARK assay. Both assays cross-reacted with acetylfentanyl (∼100%), acrylfentanyl (∼100%), and furanylfentanyl (∼20%), but only the ARK assay cross-reacted with norfentanyl (∼3%). An admixture of 0.5 ng/mL fentanyl and 6 ng/mL norfentanyl produced a positive result on the ARK assay. Total concordance between IAL and ARK for 90 tested patient samples was 93% (kappa = 0.85). Relative to LC-MS/MS, the IAL assay had a concordance of 90% (kappa = 0.79) and the ARK assay had a concordance of 94% (kappa = 0.88). Including norfentanyl in the LC-MS/MS confirmation increased the concordance of the ARK to 96% (kappa = 0.90). Conclusions: The ARK assay recognized the metabolite norfentanyl, demonstrated superior precision, and had better concordance with LC-MS/MS compared to the IAL assay.
Background: Drug screening by immunoassay is common in pediatric populations. However, false-positive and -negative results due to antibody cross-reactivity and dilute urine are frequent and underappreciated. Accurate ascertainment of drug exposure in children has significant clinical and medico-legal consequences. Design and Methods: We developed and characterized an LC–MS/MS drug screening assay to supplant immunoassay and detect 38 compounds at the lowest concentrations distinguishable from analytic noise. Once implemented, we conducted a retrospective analysis of 3985 pediatric urine drug screens performed a year before (n = 1663) and after (n = 2322) implementation to examine the frequency and breadth of drug detection in our pediatric population. Results: Using immunoassay, 23% (293/1269) of samples from the general pediatric and 37% (147/394) of nursery populations had presumptively positive results. Of the presumptive positive compounds, 85% (288/338) from the general pediatric population and 40% (65/162) from the nursery cohort were confirmed by mass spectrometry. After LC–MS/MS implementation, 31% (628/2052) of general pediatric, and 18% (48/270) of the nursery samples were positive for 1 or more compounds. In the nursery population, immunoassays over-detected the presence of THC but under-detected exposure to cocaine. Conclusion: A broadly targeted, analytically sensitive LC–MS/MS drug screening assay detects a larger number and variety of compounds in a single step compared to a screen-then-confirm approach initiated by immunoassay in our pediatric population. Rapid delivery of accurate results enables timely, appropriate disposition of patients in a variety of settings including the emergency department and labor/delivery.
Current guidelines recommend universal screening for substance use disorders in obstetric patients, and neonatal drug testing is also frequently performed. Meconium is often the preferred specimen type to detect neonatal drug exposure due to a longer window of detection compared to urine, but most laboratories send out meconium testing to specialized reference laboratories, which can delay results for several days or more. Here, we evaluate a rapid and definitive liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry method for neonatal urine drug testing and compare results obtained using this method to paired meconium drug testing in 1,424 neonates for amphetamines, cocaine, cannabinoids, opiates, oxycodone and phencyclidine. Urine testing showed equivalent sensitivity to current meconium methods for detecting in utero exposure to amphetamines and cocaine.
26 July 2024 in American Journal of Clinical Pathology
Objectives: Urine drug testing (UDT) is a critical tool used in medical, forensic, and occupational settings, but interpreting results can be challenging. We performed a study to assess the ability of health care professionals to interpret UDT results accurately. Methods: In total, 911 clinical and laboratory professionals in the United States and Canada responded to a survey with questions gauging expertise in UDT interpretation. Responses were analyzed to identify knowledge gaps. Results: Toxicologists and laboratory PhD scientists performed well, with means of 4.82 and 4.63 questions answered correctly (out of 6 possible), respectively. Physicians specializing in pathology, emergency medicine, primary care, and internal medicine, however, displayed concerning knowledge gaps, as did laboratorians with nondoctoral degrees. Experience and training correlated with interpretation accuracy. Identification of simulated compliance as well as understanding opioid exposure, metabolism, and immunoassay cross-reactivity were among the most clinically significant knowledge gaps. More than 30% of survey respondents indicated that they would seek UDT information from the internet or peers rather than clinical or laboratory experts. Conclusions: The study highlighted the need for targeted education and better collaboration between clinical and laboratory experts and other health care professionals to ensure that when physicians order UDT, they can accurately interpret results and reduce harm.