Type II-S oil shale carries sulfur in thermolytically weak C–S and S–S linkages, causing H2S co-evolution that complicates conventional non-isothermal retorting. This work applies a four-stage (multi-stage) isothermal fractionation (MS-IF) protocol (100, 350, 550 and 850 °C) to a Jordanian Al-Lajjun oil shale under dry and steam-intensified atmospheres, benchmarked against single-stage pyrolysis coupled to real-time gas speciation with solid- and liquid-phase characterization. Thermogravimetric analyses of fresh, demineralized, Fe-spiked demineralized and Ca-spiked demineralized matrices were performed at multiple heating rates. When resolved by constrained Fraser-Suzuki deconvolution and validated by dual isoconversional methods (Friedman, Starink). Two organic devolatilization events (mass-weighted activation energy 170.6 kJ mol−1) were isolated from a diffusion-controlled carbonate-decomposition event that dominates the bulk mass-loss profile. The native mineral matrix lowers the organic activation energy by 20–30 kJ mol−1, while independently obtained (Ea, ln A) pairs reveal a kinetic compensation effect (isokinetic temperature ≈ 296 °C) explaining why calcium carbonate addition raises, rather than lowers, peak decomposition temperature despite reducing the barrier. Dry MS-IF achieves 8.7% more mass loss than single-stage pyrolysis at equal peak temperature, and resolves two mechanistically distinct H2S release windows around 380 °C and 450 °C. Steam co-feeding advances sulfur mobilization to lower temperature and drives a strong water-gas shift, increasing H2 yield up to 16-fold at high temperatures. Liquid condensates remain organosulfur-dominated (47–63%), with the 350 °C stage identified as sulfur-selective. These findings establish MS-IF as a mechanistic and process framework for decoupling volatile sulfur evolution and liquid organosulfur partitioning from hydrocarbon and syngas generation in high-sulfur oil shale valorization.