Carbon offsets are important tools to meet greenhouse gas emissions reduction objectives while providing ecosystem services and social public goods globally. This assessment of policies for forest carbon markets examines the opportunities and barriers to installing high-integrity, socially responsible forest-based carbon projects at multiple locations across the Americas – Pennsylvania, USA; Jujuy and Misiones, Argentina; Meta, Colombia; and Paraná, Brazil. The paper takes a comparative approach to critically examine forest carbon projects including private landowners’ roles and relationships with government, civil society, and private-sector project developers on non-industrial forestlands. The review critically assesses income stacking (combining additional income especially from payments for biodiversity conservation and source-water protection) while considering co-benefits and barriers to landowners, project developers and public agencies involved in land management. Each site has a unique regulatory and incentives framework – national or state/ provincial – allowing for analysis of a range of private goods (monetized credits and income streams) combined with public goods (carbon, biodiversity, and water goals). The paper synthesizes comparative understanding of risk analysis for high-integrity carbon credits as well as complementarities and tradeoffs of managing for multiple forest-based ecosystem services. We conclude that forest carbon currently sits within a fragmented and often misaligned policy landscape where land‐use, climate, biodiversity, water, and socio‐economic goals intersect. This fragmentation creates investment and capital risks for landowners and project developers that in turn heighten the likelihood of inequitable outcomes and weakened project integrity. Policies that enhance landowners’ income stacking and incentivize developers to address multiple ecosystems services promote durable, socially just, ecologically effective, and commercially viable solutions. Yet, these require at least four enabling conditions: secure land tenure and rights to ecosystem services (more generally but also including under Indigenous and traditional ownership), inclusive participation, equitable benefit‐sharing, and transparent safeguards.