Plantain (Plantago lanceolata) is an herb used to reduce the forage deficit of ryegrass-based pastures during the summer. This herb is being promoted for its reduced environmental impact in terms of nitrogen emissions, particularly reducing urinary nitrogen. However, the effect of plantain on emissions of enteric CH4, the main greenhouse gas produced from ruminant-based production systems, is not known. The aim of the present trial was to determine CH4 emissions and rumen fermentation characteristics of nonlactating dairy cows fed 100% plantain (PLT) or 100% perennial ryegrass (RG; Lolium perenne) in 2 experiments (E1 and E2). The forages were in a vegetative growth stage in E1 and were in a reproductive growth stage in E2. Methane emissions from 16 cows in each experiment were measured in respiration chambers for 2 d. Methane emissions per unit of dry matter intake (CH4 yield) were 15 and 28% less for cows fed PLT than those fed RG in E1 and E2, respectively. Dry matter digestibility of PLT was 7 and 27% less than that of RG in E1 and E2, respectively, and CH4 per unit of dry matter digested was similar for PLT and RG in both experiments. There were only minor (but some significant) differences in rumen fermentation characteristics between cows fed PLT and RG in both experiments. In conclusion, CH4 yield was lower for cows fed PLT compared with those fed RG in both experiments and this reduction was largely explained by the lesser dry matter digestibility of PLT.
Global ruminant methane (CH4)-mitigation strategies rely on data from in vivo CH4-emission measurements. This survey of 415 peer-reviewed studies of in vivo enteric-CH4 measurements from farmed ruminants details research objectives, diets, and methodology as well as groups within ruminant species. The survey results have been evaluated in relation to ruminant population data and the contributions of each species to CH4 emissions. Despite the highest estimated total CH4 emissions from ruminants in Asia, South America and Africa (accounting for 37%, 23% and 17% of total enteric-CH4 emissions respectively), the number of in vivo studies of CH4 measurements were 15%, 9% and 1% of global studies respectively. Globally, the most studied species were cattle (64%) and sheep (22%), whereas goats and buffalo accounted for 7% and 5% of studies respectively. These species account for 75%, 7%, 5% and 12% of total enteric-CH4 emissions respectively. Most cattle studies were with Bos taurus and only 12% of the cattle studies were with Bos indicus. Respiration chambers have been used in 51% of studies and, despite the development of other methodologies, they remain the dominant technique for measurement of enteric-CH4 production. Most studies involved animals fed high-forage diets; these were 56% of the studies with cattle, 73% with sheep, 47% for goats, but only 15% of studies with buffalo. The evaluation of diets as a mitigation strategy was the prime objective of all regions. The number of studies that have measured CH4 from cattle aligns with their contribution to enteric emissions; however, buffalo, Bos indicus cattle and mature beef cows were under-represented relative to their global populations and contribution to global emissions. Dominance of measurements from cattle was evident in all continents.
1 June 2024 in New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research
The current New Zealand greenhouse gas inventory predictions assume that dairy cows consume pasture only, but the use of supplemental feeds, including concentrates, on New Zealand dairy farms has increased greatly in recent decades. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of feeding graded levels of concentrates on methane (CH 4 ) emissions in lactating dairy cows within a pastoral system. Early lactation dairy cows ( n = 72) were allocated ( n = 18 per treatment) to receive 0, 2, 4 and 6 kg dry matter (DM) of treatment concentrates per day during milking. The cows grazed pasture ad libitum and CH 4 emissions were measured in the paddocks using automated emissions monitoring systems called ‘GreenFeed’. Gross CH 4 emissions (g/d) were similar for cows across the four dietary treatments, while CH 4 emissions intensity (g/kg fat and protein corrected milk production (FPCM) and milk solids production) linearly decreased with increasing concentrate inclusion in the diet ( P < 0.02). The CH 4 intensity decreased linearly ( r2 = 0.42) and quadratically ( r2 = 0.53) with increasing FPCM production.
Context: The minimum number of days needed to measure gas emissions from cattle by using spot sampling methods is the result of the visit frequency, within animal variation and among animal variations. Aims: To estimate (a) the effect of the length of the measurement period on the variation in methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions and (b) the number of animals required to detect a difference of 10% between two treatment means for CH4 and CO2. Methods: Gas emissions from 72 dairy cows, supplemented with different concentrate diets, and 72 heifers, weaned at different ages, in two separate experiments, were measured for 3–5 weeks using GreenFeed units. In all four experiments, the animals grazed ryegrass-based pasture. The cows received various concentrate treatments twice daily during milking. The gas emissions in heifers were measured at 280 and 370 days of age. Data from 76 cows and 77 heifers were used in the data analysis. The coefficient of variation (CV) and number of animals required to detect a difference of 10% between the two means were modelled for periods of 3–36 days at 3-day steps. Key results: The CV of CH4 emissions became stable between Days 12 and 18 of measurements in the cows and heifers, respectively (17–37 visits for cows and 43–73 visits for heifers) and then 13–19 cows and 9–11 heifers were required per treatment to detect differences of 10% between means. The CV of CO2 emissions became stable few days earlier than did the CH4 emissions and the variation was smaller. Conclusions: A minimum of 12 and 18 measurement days are recommended to estimate CH4 emission in grazing lactating cows and heifers respectively, and 9–19 animals per treatment were required to detect differences of 10% between means for the conditions of the current studies. Implications: The current analysis has provided information about among-animal variation of gas emissions when performing GreenFeed measurements with grazing cattle, within the experimental conditions of the data sets used for the current study, which can be used to design future cattle studies.
The use of supplementary feeds, including concentrates, on New Zealand dairy farms has increased in recent decades and this could have mitigated methane (CH4) emissions by decreasing the forage-to-concentrate ratio. The forage-to-concentrate ratio in the diet can be easily managed in cows that receive a total mixed ration, but under grazing conditions, the cows select their own diets by increasing or decreasing the herbage intake, likely depending on the amount of concentrates eaten. The feed selection will have a direct effect on the forage-to-concentrate ratio and the potential mitigation of CH4 emissions. The objective of the current study was to determine the effect of feeding increasing levels of concentrates in pasutre fed early lactation dairy cows on CH4 emissions. Thirty-two early lactation dairy cows fed fresh cut ryegrass-based herbage ad libitum were allocated to receive 0, 2, 4 and 6 kg dry matter of concentrates (n = 8 per treatment) per day in two equal meals during milking. The cows were on their respective full treatment diets for at least 14 days before CH4 measurements started. The CH4 emissions were measured in respiration chambers for 48 h. The CH4 yield (g/kg dry matter intake) and intensity (g/kg milk solids) decreased linearly by 0.76 and 5.3 units per kg of concentrate in the diet (P = 0.001 and P = 0.009), respectively, with increasing the concentrate level. The variations in CH4 emissions after each feeding increased quadratically and linearly (P = 0.023 and P = 0.038) after morning and afternoon feeding, respectively and the CH4 emissions reached the peak more rapidly after morning feeding (linear effect; P = 0.029) when the concentrate level increased. For short-chain fatty acids, the proportion of acetate decreased by 0.72 units (P = 0.003) while the proportion of propionate increased by 0.16 units (P = 0.006) per kg of concentrate in the diet. Feeding concentrates is a simple feeding strategy to mitigate CH4 emissions from dairy cows. CH4 yield decreased linearly by increasing the concentrate inclusion level of the diet.
High-fiber and high-starch concentrates are used as supplements to meet the energy demand of lactating cows or to fill herbage shortage in pastoral systems. Additionally, concentrates can be a tool to mitigate enteric methane (CH4) per unit of DMI (CH4 yield) and per unit of milk production. This study aimed to compare the effects of supplementing herbage-fed late-lactation dairy cows with high-fiber (FIB), high-starch (STA), or a 50:50 mix of both concentrates (MIX) compared with no supplementation (CON) on CH4 emission parameters and ruminal fermentation. Multiparous cows (Friesian × Jersey, average ± SD; 3.8 ± 0.8 yr old; 519 ± 50 kg BW, 211 ± 10 DIM; n = 32) were blocked by lactation number and then randomly allocated to receive (on a DM basis) the following: 0 kg/d of concentrate (CON), 5 kg/d of STA, 5 kg/d of FIB, or 5 kg/d of MIX (2.5 kg each of STA and FIB). After at least 14 d of diet adaptation, the CH4 emissions, DMI, and milk production were measured in respiration chambers for 48 h, ruminal fluid was collected after chamber measurements, and short-chain fatty acids (SCFA) were analyzed. Daily milk production was recorded, and milk samples were analyzed for milk composition. The CH4 production (g/d) trended to be greater in concentrate-fed cows than CON cows. The CH4 yield was similar across the dietary treatments. The CH4 per kilogram of TS (calculated as fat plus protein production) was 22% less and trended to be up to 24% less per kilogram of fat- and protein-corrected milk (FPCM) in concentrate-fed cows than CON cows mainly due to an increase in FPCM production. After morning and afternoon feeding, the time to reach peak CH4 emissions was less in concentrate-fed cows than CON cows. The variation in the CH4 emission rate after morning feeding was greater in concentrate-supplemented cows than CON cows. The ruminal SCFA profile was similar among treatments. Regardless of the dietary treatment, the acetate plus butyrate to propionate plus valerate ratio was positively associated with CH4 yield, FPCM, and peak CH4 emission rate and negatively associated with the CH4 decline rate after peak emissions. High-starch, high-fiber, or mixed (50:50) concentrates trended to reduce the CH4 per unit of FPCM by up to 24% in lactating cows eating fresh herbage as a basal diet.