C. McPhail

C. McPhail

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

C. McPhail

School of Civil, Environmental, and Mining Engineering University of Adelaide Adelaide South Australia Australia

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

9Years (2018-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
6 February 2018 in Earth's Future
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CMC. McPhail
C. McPhail
HMHolger Robert Maier
Holger Robert Maier
J.H. (Jan)  KwakkelJ.H. (Jan) Kwakkel
J.H. (Jan) Kwakkel
MGMatteo Giuliani
Matteo Giuliani
ACA. Castelletti
A. Castelletti
SWS. Westra
S. Westra
Robustness is being used increasingly for decision analysis in relation to deep uncertainty and many metrics have been proposed for its quantification. Recent studies have shown that the application of different robustness metrics can result in different rankings of decision alternatives, but there has been little discussion of what potential causes for this might be. To shed some light on this issue, we present a unifying framework for the calculation of robustness metrics, which assists with understanding how robustness metrics work, when they should be used, and why they sometimes disagree. The framework categorizes the suitability of metrics to a decision‐maker based on (1) the decision‐context (i.e., the suitability of using absolute performance or regret), (2) the decision‐maker's preferred level of risk aversion, and (3) the decision‐maker's preference toward maximizing performance, minimizing variance, or some higher‐order moment. This article also introduces a conceptual framework describing when relative robustness values of decision alternatives obtained using different metrics are likely to agree and disagree. This is used as a measure of how “stable” the ranking of decision alternatives is when determined using different robustness metrics. The framework is tested on three case studies, including water supply augmentation in Adelaide, Australia, the operation of a multipurpose regulated lake in Italy, and flood protection for a hypothetical river based on a reach of the river Rhine in the Netherlands. The proposed conceptual framework is confirmed by the case study results, providing insight into the reasons for disagreements between rankings obtained using different robustness metrics.

27 August 2020 in Water Resources Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CMC. McPhail
C. McPhail
HMHolger Robert Maier
Holger Robert Maier
SWS. Westra
S. Westra
J.H. (Jan)  KwakkelJ.H. (Jan) Kwakkel
J.H. (Jan) Kwakkel
LLL. van der Linden
L. van der Linden
Multiple plausible future scenarios are being used increasingly in preference to a single deterministic or probabilistic prediction of the future in the long‐term planning of water resources systems. These scenarios enable the determination of the robustness of a system—the consideration of performance across a range of plausible futures—and allow an assessment of which possible future system configurations result in a greater level of robustness. There are many approaches to selecting scenarios, and previous studies have observed that the choice of scenarios might affect the estimated robustness of the system. However, these observations have been anecdotal and qualitative. This paper develops a systematic, quantitative methodology for exploring the influence of scenario selection on the robustness and the ranking of decision alternatives. The methodology is illustrated on the Lake Problem. The quantitative results obtained confirm the qualitative observations of previous works, showing that the selection of scenarios is important, as it has a large influence on the robustness value calculated for each decision alternative. However, we show that it has a relatively small influence on how those decision alternatives are ranked. This implies that despite the difference in robustness values, similar decision outcomes will be reached in this case study, regardless of the basis on which the scenarios are obtained. It is also revealed that the impact of the scenarios on the robustness values is due to complex interactions with the system model and robustness metrics.

1 August 2021 in Environmental Modelling & Software
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CMC. McPhail
C. McPhail
HMH.R. Maier
H.R. Maier
SWS. Westra
S. Westra
LLL. van der Linden
L. van der Linden
JKJ.H. Kwakkel
J.H. Kwakkel