5 September 2012 in Agronomy for Sustainable Development
1 October 2005 in Agronomy for Sustainable Development
28 March 2023 in International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability
Assessing benefits and limits of agroecological transitions in different contexts is of foremost importance to steer and manage agroecological transitions and to feed evidence-based advocacy. However, assessing agroecological transitions remains a methodological challenge. The objective of this research was to investigate to what extent existing multiscale and multidimensional assessment methods were suitable to assess agroecological transitions. We used a literature review to identify and select 14 existing multiscale and multidimensional assessment methods related to sustainable or resilient agriculture. We then analyzed these 14 methods according to five evaluation criteria that reflected key requirements for assessing agroecological transitions: 1) be adaptable to local conditions, 2) consider social interactions among stakeholders involved in the transitions, 3) clarify the concept of agroecology, 4) consider the temporal dynamics of the transitions to better understand barriers and levers in their development and 5) use a participatory bottom-up approach. The methods adopted different approaches to consider each evaluation criterion, but none of them covered all five. The two evaluation criteria most often employed were the adaptability to local conditions (used by 13 of the methods) and the consideration of social interactions (used by all 14 of the analyzed methods). To be adaptable, methods mobilized generic guidelines with flexible content and/or included a contextualization phase. For social interactions, most methods mobilized social-related indicators, and two included stakeholder mapping. Two methods clarified the agroecological concept by mobilizing different sets of principles. Two other methods considered temporal dynamics of the transitions, mobilizing a trajectory of change to understand barriers and levers in their development. Finally, seven methods adopted a bottom-up participatory approach, involving stakeholders in both their development and use. To balance the existing trade-offs between the evaluation purpose, the time requirement and the level of participation in the different approaches adopted by the 14 methods studied, we suggest combining some of the approaches in a complementary mode to cover all 5 criteria and therefore improve the assessment of agroecological transitions.
1 August 2008 in Revista Brasileira de Engenharia Agrícola E Ambiental
Embora associada à adoção de tecnologias de conservação do solo, a intensificação dos sistemas de produção agropecuária tem induzido a um dos principais problemas enfrentados pelos agricultores, a compactação do solo, seja em sistemas de plantio direto ou em sistemas de plantio convencional e pastagem. Este estudo foi realizado em Rio Verde, GO, em Latossolo Vermelho Amarelo, nos seguintes sistemas: plantio direto há 14 anos (SD14); plantio direto há oito anos (SD8); plantio direto há dois anos (SD2); preparo convencional (PC); pastagem (P) e floresta (F). A resistência à penetração do solo foi determinada utilizando-se o penetrômetro de Impacto Modelo IAA/Planalsucar - Stolf, a partir da superfície do solo até a profundidade de 0,40 m; determinaram-se, também, a densidade do solo e a granulometria. O plantio convencional apresentou menor resistência à penetração, na profundidade 0-0,10 m, enquanto o SD2 indicou maior resistência à penetração até 0,40 m de profundidade. Abaixo da profundidade de 0,15 m não houve diferença significativa entre os tratamentos PC, SD8, SD14. Os dois primeiros anos de adoção do sistema de plantio direto são críticos quanto à resistência a penetração nas camadas superficiais do solo.
1 May 2006 in Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira
FSFernando Antônio Macena da Silva
Fernando Antônio Macena da Silva
O objetivo deste trabalho foi avaliar o efeito das palhadas de milho, milheto e soja na capacidade de interceptação e de armazenamento de água, velocidade de dessecamento, porcentagem de cobertura do solo, interceptação da radiação solar e escoamento superficial, assim como incorporar estes efeitos em um modelo de crescimento de plantas. As palhadas de milheto e de milho apresentaram capacidade maior de armazenar água do que a de soja: 3,26, 3,24 e 2,62 g de água por grama de palhada, respectivamente. A quantidade de água perdida pelos resíduos foi proporcional à evapotranspiração potencial. As taxas de cobertura foram equivalentes nos três tipos de material. Os três tipos de palhada foram similares na interceptação das radiações fotossinteticamente ativa e infravermelha. Os resíduos do milheto foram eficientes no controle do escoamento superficial: do total de 843,5 mm de água precipitada, apenas 45,5 mm foram perdidos pelo escoamento superficial no sistema de plantio direto enquanto no convencional as perdas de água foram de 222,5 mm. Os modelos linear e exponencial expressam de forma significativa a maior parte das relações estudadas.
9 July 2020 in International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability
Conservation agriculture (CA) is recognized as a promising crop management strategy for sustainable agricultural intensification. The objective of this study was to evaluate CA cropping systems for rainfed maize as an alternative to the traditional tillage-based cropping systems (CT) in the context of family farms, using a multi-criteria model that represents the point of view of farmers. Farmers considered several aspects for evaluating the cropping systems, thatwere systematized in the model through five criteria (with sub-criteria): (a) costs; (b) yield; (c) labour; (d) human health and environment; and (e) production risks. CA did not differ from CT for the ‘costs’ criterion but was superior for the ‘yield’ and ‘labour’ criteria. In contrast, CT obtained better ratings for the criteria ‘human health and environment’ and ‘production risks’. Considering all criteria, CA was better appraised than CT. However, a new local policy measure that subsidizes the hiring of mechanized tillage services overturns this outcome, indicating the importance of exogenous factors. Overall, the participatory processes in building the model allowed us to better understand the reasons of adoption or non-adoption of CA by small-scale farmers in the tropics.