11 March 2022 in The Lancet
1 August 2024 in European Journal of International Law
This article sheds new and critical light on the notion, enshrined in international law, that child refugees are a uniquely vulnerable and dependent age group requiring special protection. Although protection is not inherently detrimental, this conception of child protection often ends up harming refugees of all ages. It casts adult refugees as less vulnerable, less dependent and less deserving of protection than their younger counterparts. It downplays the contextual, relational and socially constructed nature of vulnerability, dependence and childhood. It potentially contributes to the disregard for the capacity and wishes of child refugees. It usually affords these children only temporary protection, thereby increasing their uncertainty, driving them to disengage from welfare services and incentivizing the state to delay decisions about their entitlements. Meanwhile, international law not only places great value on children’s relationships with their parents but also authorizes the punishment of supposedly unfit parents, and this ambivalence helps states weaponize legal principles of child protection against refugee families. What is needed, however, is not for child refugees to be denied protection. Rather, a fundamental reimagining of protection is in order: a shift from hierarchies of vulnerability, dependence and deservingness towards free global movement based on solidarity and equity.
1 June 2022 in International Journal of Refugee Law
This article focuses on a unique provision, article 9 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), which stipulates a right to family reunification for all children, including those seeking international protection. Relying on the rules of treaty interpretation of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT), the article argues that the desirable interpretation of article 9 prescribes a positive obligation upon States to provide entry to the territory of a State for the purposes of family unity. It also challenges the prevailing academic view that only article 10 of the CRC applies in the migration context, while article 9 of the CRC is applicable exclusively within State borders. The article contends that the text of these provisions, as well as the context of the CRC, does not support the opinion of a considerable number of scholars, who argue that children seeking international protection fall outside the scope of article 9 of the CRC. It suggests that the interpretation of article 9 of the CRC, using the proper interpretative methodology of the VCLT, demands the articulation of a distinctive child-centred approach to family reunification and a presumption against family separation of children seeking international protection.
14 June 2024 in Journal of Refugee Studies
Estella Carpi’s book The Politics of Crisis-Making. Forced Displacement and Cultures of Assistance in Lebanon offers a timely exploration of chronic crises and refugee influxes in Lebanon. Given the reignited conflict in the Middle East and the lack of any foreseeable resolution, the book is bound to become essential reading for scholars, policymakers, and humanitarian workers seeking insight into the region. Moreover, as I will elaborate later, the arguments and observations in the book hold relevance beyond Lebanon, offering critical perspectives on humanitarian systems and interventions in need of urgent reform.
1 January 2024 in German Yearbook of International Law
In the wake of Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, reports have surfaced, indicating the systematic and widespread forcible transfers of Ukrainian children from temporarily occupied territories to Russia. Mounting evidence suggests Russia’s efforts to indoctrinate these children and erode their national identity are reminiscent of historical colonial practices. Although not unique to Russia, forcible child transfers have historical precedents globally. Understanding this history is essential for comprehensively addressing genocide, particularly, as defined in Article II(e) of the Genocide Convention. This article explores the classification of forcible child transfers as a form of genocide, with a focus on the Ukrainian context. Examining the impact of colonial powers on the drafting of the Genocide Convention, this article provides historical context for the limitations of international law, particularly the law of genocide, which hinders the legal challenge of colonial violence within its framework. It demonstrates how Article II(e) can be seen as a trace of Raphael Lemkin’s original idea, which famously included cultural genocide. The article analyses the challenges in establishing genocidal intent for forcible transfer of children and the role of indoctrination in facilitating the biological absorption of one group into another. Additionally, it provides a historical overview of Russia’s colonial practices, drawing parallel with present-day transfers. The article concludes by examining the ongoing forcible transfers of Ukrainian children to Russia, highlighting Russia’s policies on re-education and military training as tools to dissolve the national Ukrainian identity and absorb Ukrainian children into the Russian population.