The first review of the various electrolytes currently used and developed for sodium-ion batteries (SIBs), both in terms of materials and concepts, is presented. In contrast to the Li-ion battery (LIB), which is a mature technology for which a more or less unanimously accepted “standard electrolyte” exists: 1 M LiPF6 in EC/DMC, the electrolyte of choice for SIBs has not yet fully conformed to a standard. This is true for both materials: salts, solvents, or additives, and concept, using the main track of organic solvents or aiming for other concepts. SIB research currently prospers, benefitting from using know-how gained from 30 years of LIB R&D. Here the currently employed electrolytes are emphasized and their effects on practical SIB performance are outlined, scrutinizing the rationale for specific choices made, salts, solvents, additives, concentrations, etc. for each specific cell set-up and usage conditions.
A comprehensive study is reported entailing optimization of sodium ion electrolyte formulation and compatibility studies with positive and negative electrode materials. EC:PC:DMC and EC:PC:DME were found to exhibit optimum ionic conductivities and lower viscosities. Yet, hard carbon negative electrode materials tested in such electrolytes exhibit significant differences in performance, rooted in the different resistivity of the SEI, which results in too large polarization and concomitant loss of capacity at low potentials when DME is used as a co-solvent. EC0.45:PC0.45:DMC0.1 was found to be the optimum composition resulting in good rate capability and high capacity upon sustained cycling for hard carbon electrodes. Its compatibility with positive Na3V2(PO4)2F3 (NVPF) electrodes was also confirmed, which led to the assembly of full Na-ion cells displaying an operation voltage of 3.65 V, very low polarisation and excellent capacity retention upon cycling with ca. 97 mA h g−1 of NVPF after more than 120 cycles together with satisfactory coulombic efficiency (>98.5%) and very good power performance. Such values lead to energy densities comparable to those of the current state-of-the-art lithium-ion technology.
A comprehensive study is reported entailing a comparison of Li, Na, K, Mg, and Ca based electrolytes and an investigation of the reliability of electrochemical tests using half-cells. Ionic conductivity, viscosity, and Raman spectroscopy results point to the cation-solvent interaction to follow the polarizing power of the cations, i.e. Mg2+ > Ca2+> Li+ > Na+ > K+ and to divalent cation based electrolytes having stronger tendency to form ion pairs – lowering the cation accessibility and mobility. Both increased temperature and the use of anions with delocalized negative charge, such as TFSI, are effective in mitigating this issue. Another factor impeding the divalent cations mobility is the larger solvation shells, as compared to those of monovalent cations, that in conjunction with stronger solvent - cation interactions contribute to slower charge transfer and ultimately a large impedance of Mg and Ca electrodes. An important consequence is the non-reliability of the pseudo-reference electrodes as these present both significant potential shifts as well as unstable behaviors. Finally, experimental protocols in order to achieve consistent results when using half-cell set-ups are proposed.
6 October 2020 in Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics
In-depth physico-chemical and molecular characterization of EC:DMC Na+-electrolytes is provided while we observed several DMC conformers in the solvation shells.
Hybrid electrolytes aimed at application in sodium-ion batteries (SIB) consisting of an organic solvent\ud mixture (EC:PC) and different ionic liquids (ILs); EMImTFSI, BMImTFSI, and Pyr13TFSI, and with the\ud NaTFSI salt providing the Naþ charge carriers have here been extensively studied. The physico-chemical\ud and electrochemical characterisation includes ionic conductivity, viscosity, density, cation coordination\ud and solvation, various safety measures, and electrochemical stability window (ESW). Hybrid electrolytes\ud with 10e50% of IL content were found to have ionic conductivities on par with comparable organic\ud solvent based electrolytes, but with highly enhanced safety properties. A systematic Raman spectroscopy\ud study of the cation coordination and solvation before and after electrolyte safety tests by ignition suggest\ud that IL cations and TFSI remain stable when ignited while organic solvents are consumed. Finally, the\ud solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) formed when using hybrid electrolytes has both better mechanical and\ud electrochemical stability than the SEI derived from pure IL based electrolytes. For a half-cell with a hard\ud carbon (HC) electrode and a hybrid electrolyte with a composition of 0.8 m NaTFSI in EC0.45:PC0.45:-\ud Pyr13TFSI0.10 encouraging results were obtained for IL based electrolytes e ca. 182 mAhg1 at C/10 over\ud 40 cycles.We acknowledge the ALISTORE-ERI members for many fruitful\ud discussions and the Swedish Research Council (VR), the Swedish\ud Energy Agency (STEM), the Swedish Research Council for Environment,\ud Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning (FORMAS) and\ud Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovacion (Spain, grant MAT2014-53500-\ud R) for research funding. DM is grateful for a travel grant to ICMAB\ud from Chalmers Area of Advance Energy. PJ acknowledges the\ud continuous funding from several of Chalmers Areas of Advance:\ud Energy, Materials Science, and Transport.Peer reviewe