Melanie Hirsch

Melanie Hirsch

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Melanie Hirsch

University of Vienna

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
17 March 2022 in Journal of Information Technology & Politics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
Jörg MatthesJörg Matthes
Jörg Matthes
MHMelanie Hirsch
Melanie Hirsch
MSMarlis Stubenvoll
Marlis Stubenvoll
ABAlice Binder
Alice Binder
SKSanne Kruikemeier
Sanne Kruikemeier
LOLukas Otto
Lukas Otto
With the increasing availability of big digital voter data, there are rising concerns that online political micro-targeting (PMT) may be harmful for democratic societies. However, PMT may also be beneficial to democracy because it targets voters with content that matches with their predispositions, potentially increasing political interest. For both, harmful and beneficial outcomes of PMT, we lack empirical evidence on the side of citizens. In a two-wave panel survey study, we tested the reciprocal relationships over time between perceived online PMT, trust in democracy, and political interest. We found that perceived online PMT leads to a decrease of trust in democracy, but also to an increase in political interest. The effect on political interest was independent from age. No reciprocal effects of trust in democracy and political interest on perceived PMT were observed. Overall, the results suggest that the democratic implications of PMT are more nuanced than previously assumed.

9 February 2022 in Journal of Advertising
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
ABAlice Binder
Alice Binder
MSMarlis Stubenvoll
Marlis Stubenvoll
MHMelanie Hirsch
Melanie Hirsch
Jörg MatthesJörg Matthes
Jörg Matthes
Political advertising on social media heavily capitalizes on the fact that citizens leave behind data traces through their online behaviors. Even though this allows parties to target citizens based on their age, gender, or even specific interests, there is often a mismatch between the parties and the individuals’ party preferences. This study investigates how different degrees of targeting disclosures (demographic/location-based targeting disclosure versus preference-based targeting disclosure) and the political fit of targeted ads (high fit versus low fit) affect participants’ party evaluation and online privacy behaviors. Two dimensions of persuasion knowledge, perceived manipulative intent (PMI) and targeting knowledge (TK), act as mediators. Results from an online experiment (N = 430) reveal that the degree of targeting disclosure did not activate these dimensions. However, high political fit of the ads led to lower PMI and higher TK. In addition, political fit improved party evaluations via PMI and TK and reduced privacy behaviors via PMI. We conclude that citizens do not activate their defense mechanisms against targeted ads when the targeting comes from a favored party.

1 March 2022 in Computers in Human Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
Jörg MatthesJörg Matthes
Jörg Matthes
KKKathrin Karsay
Kathrin Karsay
MHMelanie Hirsch
Melanie Hirsch
ASAnja Stevic
Anja Stevic
DSDesirée Schmuck
Desirée Schmuck

23 March 2023 in Journal of Advertising
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MHMelanie Hirsch
Melanie Hirsch
MSMarlis Stubenvoll
Marlis Stubenvoll
ABAlice Binder
Alice Binder
Jörg MatthesJörg Matthes
Jörg Matthes
Targeted political advertising (TPA) on social media builds on tailoring messages to (groups of) individuals’ characteristics based on user data. Questions have been raised about the impact of TPA on recipients and society. In this study, we focus on the fit of TPA, that is, the congruence between TPA and recipients’ preferences, and draw on congruity theories, social identity theory (SIT), and persuasion knowledge. In a two-wave panel study (N = 428) during a Viennese state election, we investigated the relationships between individuals’ perceived fit and misfit of TPA on perceptions about the manipulative intent as well as the benefits and harms for democracy. The findings showed that perceived fit of TPA at Time 1 decreased perceived manipulative intent and increased perceived benefits of TPA at Time 2. The perceived misfit of TPA at Time 1 did not influence individuals’ perceptions at Time 2, and perceptions about the harms of TPA to democracy stayed stable. Findings imply that political campaigners might benefit from targeting but raise questions about individuals’ defense mechanisms against the persuasive technique.

29 November 2022 in Communication Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MSMarlis Stubenvoll
Marlis Stubenvoll
ABAlice Binder
Alice Binder
SNSelina Noetzel
Selina Noetzel
MHMelanie Hirsch
Melanie Hirsch
Jörg MatthesJörg Matthes
Jörg Matthes
Political parties increasingly rely on sophisticated targeting strategies to persuade potential voters. However, questions have been raised about the effectiveness of targeted political ads, considering that citizens frequently oppose the use of their data for political purposes. In this study, we investigate three avoidance behaviors that citizens might employ in order to circumvent targeted political ads: cognitive avoidance, blocking behaviors, and privacy-protective behaviors. We test if privacy concerns, perceived personalization, and overload explain why individuals resort to avoidance behaviors. Moreover, we explore interrelations between the different avoidance strategies. Findings from a two-wave panel study ( N = 428) in the context of the Viennese state election showed that privacy concerns increased cognitive avoidance and privacy-protective behaviors. In contrast, perceived personalization decreased cognitive avoidance and blocking behaviors. Cognitive avoidance further reduced privacy-protective behaviors over time, indicating that low-effort strategies might inhibit preventive actions against data collection practices.