20 March 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity
An open-source Finite Element Quench Simulator (FiQuS) is being developed as part of the STEAM framework following CERN's open science policy (CERN, 2022). The tool is based solely on open-source software and uses Python to generate geometries and meshes with Gmsh and compute solutions with GetDP. FiQuS scripts have a modular structure to accommodate a broad range of geometries and simulation requirements, focusing mainly on superconducting accelerator magnets. At its advanced stage, the tool will be capable of 1D, 2D, and 3D geometry generation of superconducting elements such as bus bars, multi-pole, solenoid, and canted-cos-theta (CCT) magnets. It already has the capability for parametrized mesh control and subsequent model generation of 2D multi-pole and 3D CCT magnets. It will be possible to perform either electromagnetic (EM), thermal (TH), or coupled EM-TH simulations for static or transient analysis. The focus is on aspects related to the powering and quench transients, enabling parametric analyses and co-simulations to support comprehensive quench protection studies. In this contribution, we lay the foundation of FiQuS by presenting its structure and three specific capabilities that represent the basis upon which the future modules will be built, mainly: enabling cooperative simulations and the Single Source Of Truth (SSOT) practice; seamlessly integrating magnet design details around a set of input files; enabling parametric analysis and multi-objective optimization with Dakota software developed by Sandia National Laboratories. These capabilities showcase the integration of FiQuS with software developed at CERN, at other national laboratories, and within the STEAM framework.
20 March 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity
When simulating no-insulation high-temperature superconducting pancake coils with the finite element (FE) method, the high aspect ratio of the thin turn-to-turn contact layer (T2TCL) leads to unfavorable meshes in these thin layers as manifested by a high number of degrees of freedom (DoF) or mesh elements of poor quality which decrease the accuracy of the simulation results. To mitigate this issue, we propose to collapse the T2TCL volume into a surface using a thin shell approximation (TSA) for three-dimensional FE analysis. A $\vec{H}-\phi$ formulation is used and solves for the magnetic field strength $\vec{H}$ in conducting domains and the magnetic scalar potential $\phi$ in insulating domains. This formulation avoids spurious currents and reduces the number of DoF in insulating domains. Automatically created thick cuts are used to deal with multiply connected domains. Particular attention is paid to the interpretation of these cuts and the corresponding basis functions in the context of pancake coil geometries. The efficiency of the formulation facilitates the resolution of each turn. In this way, local phenomena such as quench can be captured in a straightforward way. The TSA formulation is verified by comparison against a reference model with volumetrically meshed T2TCL and is shown to be accurate and efficient, significantly reducing the solution time while reducing the effort for creating high-quality meshes. The TSA is implemented in an open-source FE framework and the source code is shared alongside this paper.
8 March 2023 in Superconductor Science and Technology
Superconducting electromagnets commonly exhibit thin layers with high aspect ratio such as insulation layers or turn-to-turn contacts. A finite element (FE) analysis of these devices can lead to unfavorable meshes in these thin layers, either because of a high number of degrees of freedom or mesh elements of poor quality which decrease the accuracy of the simulation results. To mitigate these issues when conducting a thermal FE analysis solving the heat equation, this work proposes to collapse thin volume layers into surfaces by using a thermal thin shell approximation (TSA). The proposed method uses one-dimensional Lagrange elements across the thickness of the thin layer and can handle a variety of interface conditions, multi-layered structures, heat sources, nonlinear material behavior or coupling to physics other than heat transfer. The efficiency of the proposed approximation is highlighted by comparison with a reference model with a conventionally meshed insulation for a model problem exhibiting a brick wall structure where a stationary heat equation is solved. The formulation is then verified against reference models with meshed insulation solving a transient heat equation for an insulated high-temperature superconductor pancake coil exhibiting a local defect which causes a thermal runaway. The benefit of using the model with the TSA is studied by analyzing pancake coils with different ratios of the insulation layer to the coated conductor thickness. It is shown that the smaller the ratio, the shorter the solution time and the lower the number of unknowns of the thin shell model when compared to the conventionally meshed insulation in order to reach the same numerical accuracy. The method is implemented in an open-source FE framework and a reference implementation for a simple model problem is shared alongside this paper.
8 December 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity
For finite element (FE) analysis of no-insulation (NI) high-temperature superconducting (HTS) pancake coils, the high aspect ratio of the turn-to-turn contact layer (T2TCL) leads to meshing difficulties which result in either poor quality mesh elements resulting in a decrease of the solution accuracy or a high number of degrees of freedom. We proposed to mitigate this issue by collapsing the T2TCL volume into a surface and using a so-called thin shell approximation (TSA). Previously, two TSA have been introduced, one to solve the heat equation and the other for an $\vec{H}$ −φ magnetodynamic formulation. In this work, we propose to combine the magnetodynamic and thermal TSA to create a coupled magneto-thermal TSA for three-dimensional FE analysis. Particular attention is paid to the detailed derivation of the coupling terms. In the context of NI HTS pancake coils, the TSA represents the electric and thermal contact resistance of the T2TCL. For the HTS coated conductor (CC) itself, an anisotropic homogenization is used which represents its multi-layered structure. In axial and azimuthal direction, it resolves the current sharing between the HTS and other layers of the CC. The coupled TSA formulation is verified against a reference model with volumetric T2TCL. The coupled TSA is shown to significantly reduce the solution time as well as the manual effort required for high-quality meshes of the T2TCL. The implementation is open-source and a reference implementation is made publicly available
29 July 2024 in Superconductor Science and Technology
In this paper, we propose the Coupled Axial and Transverse currents (I) (CATI) method, as an efficient and accurate finite element approach for modelling the electric and magnetic behavior of periodic composite superconducting conductors. The method consists of a pair of two-dimensional models coupled via circuit equations to account for the conductor geometrical periodicity. This allows to capture three-dimensional effects with two-dimensional models and leads to a significant reduction in computational time compared to conventional three-dimensional models. After presenting the method in detail, we verify it by comparison with reference finite element models, focussing on its application to twisted multifilamentary superconducting strands. In particular, we show that the CATI method captures the transition from uncoupled to coupled filaments, with accurate calculation of the interfilament coupling time constant. We then illustrate the capabilities of the method by generating detailed loss maps and magnetization curves of given strand types for a range of external transverse magnetic field excitations, with and without transport current.
20 March 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity
The next generation of Nb $_{3}$ Sn accelerator magnets are pushed to higher magnetic fields, higher stored energy and higher energy density. This brings additional challenges when it comes to quench protection. At CERN, a fast quench protection system is under development that introduces normal zones directly in the coil's conductor by inductive heating. This system is called External coil Coupled Loss Induced Quench (E-CLIQ). The E-CLIQ device comprises many small copper coils that are strategically placed near the main coils. Once a quench is detected, a capacitor is discharged in to the E-CLIQ coils, resulting in the characteristic damped oscillating current of an RLC circuit. This results in a large, but local applied dB/dt on the conductor of the main magnet system, which locally heats it by induced interfilament and interstrand coupling loss. Such a system has the advantage of being fast by introducing normal zones in potentially less than 10 ms, it doesn't rely on heat flow through the insulation layers of the coil, as is the case with traditional quench heaters, and it is not electrically connected to the main circuit. In this paper, the E-CLIQ system is introduced, several first demonstrator coils are presented and the results of a first proof-of-concept test are shown.