Karan Bhuwalka

Karan Bhuwalka

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Karan Bhuwalka

Department of Mechanical Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge Massachusetts USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

6Years (2021-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
15 February 2022 in Journal of Industrial Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JRJohn Ryter
John Ryter
XFXinkai Fu
Xinkai Fu
KBKaran Bhuwalka
Karan Bhuwalka
RRRichard Roth
Richard Roth
EOElsa Olivetti
Elsa Olivetti
Material production drives an increasingly large fraction of CO2-equivalent emissions. Material efficiency strategies such as recycling serve to reduce these emissions. Current analyses of the effectiveness of such strategies do not include economically induced rebound effects, overestimating the associated environmental benefits. We present a dynamic supply chain simulation model for copper through 2040 incorporating inventory-driven price evolution, dynamic material flow analysis, and life cycle assessment alongside mine-level economic evaluation of opening, closing, and production decisions. We show that permanent increases in recycling displace ∼0.5 kilotonnes mine production per kilotonne increase in scrap supply on average, while short-lived recycling policies can lead to increased mine production. We find evidence for supply chain evolution pathways minimizing the rebound effect and maximizing displacement of primary material, where increasing refined copper and concentrate prices and decreasing demand serve to decrease mining. However, even in best-case scrap supply scenarios, CO2e emissions from the copper sector increase 25% by 2040 relative to 2018 due to demand growth, ore grade decline, and lower displacement among large scrap supply changes. With implementation of best available technologies across all supply chain components, we estimated 2040 CO2e emissions 10% below those of 2018 are possible, though still well short of 2°C emissions targets. We find increasing mine taxes and royalties, reclamation costs, and exploration costs further increase displacement, as does the inclusion of scrap prices on major futures exchanges. These results highlight the importance of considering the economics of the entire material supply chain when implementing material efficiency strategies. This article met the requirements for a Gold-Gold JIE data openness badge described at http://jie.click/badges.

2 July 2021 in Environmental Science & Technology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
KBKaran Bhuwalka
Karan Bhuwalka
FFFrank R. Field
Frank R. Field
RKRobert D. De Kleine
Robert D. De Kleine
HKHyung Chul Kim
Hyung Chul Kim
TWTim Wallington
Tim Wallington
RKRandolph E. Kirchain
Randolph E. Kirchain

18 June 2024 in Journal of Industrial Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
RBR. Basuhi
R. Basuhi
KBKaran Bhuwalka
Karan Bhuwalka
RRRichard Roth
Richard Roth
EOElsa A. Olivetti
Elsa A. Olivetti
In the United States, polyethylene terephthalate (PET) bottle collection rates have not increased in a decade. Recycling rates remain abysmal while industry commitments and policy targets escalate the demand for recycled plastics. We investigate the PET bottle recycling system, where collection is a critical bottleneck and recycled PET supply is not meeting the expected demand. We characterize demand for recycled PET (R‐PET), analyze scenarios of expanding deposit return systems (DRS), and quantify cost barriers to improving PET bottle recycling. We find that a nation‐wide DRS can increase PET bottle recycling rates from 24% to 82%, supplying approximately 2700 kt of recycled PET annually. With stability in demand, we estimate that this PET bottle recycling system can achieve 65% bottle‐to‐bottle circularity, at a net cost of 360 USD/tonne of PET recycled. We also discuss environmental impacts, stakeholder implications, producer responsibility, and complimentary policies toward an efficient and effective recycling system.

16 November 2022 in Journal of Industrial Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
KBKaran Bhuwalka
Karan Bhuwalka
RKRandolph E. Kirchain
Randolph E. Kirchain
EOElsa A. Olivetti
Elsa A. Olivetti
RRRichard Roth
Richard Roth
Raw materials costs form an increasingly significant proportion of the total costs of renewable energy technologies that must be adopted at unprecedented rates to combat climate change. As the affordable deployment of these technologies grows vulnerable to materials price changes, effective strategies must be identified to mitigate the risk of higher input costs faced by manufacturers. To better understand potential threats to deployment, a market modeling approach was developed to quantify economic risk factors including material demand, substitutability, recycling, mining productivity, resource quality, and discovery. Results demonstrate that price changes are determined by interactions between demand growth, mining productivity, and resource quality. In the worst cases with high demand and low productivity, development of material substitutes and large recycling rates help reduce the prevalence of price risk from over 90% to under 10%. Investing in these strategies yields significant benefits for manufacturers and governments concerned about costs of materials critical to decarbonization and other advanced technologies.

17 October 2022 in Journal of Industrial Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
KBKaran Bhuwalka
Karan Bhuwalka
ECEunseo Choi
Eunseo Choi
EMElizabeth A. Moore
Elizabeth A. Moore
RRRichard Roth
Richard Roth
RKRandolph E. Kirchain
Randolph E. Kirchain
EOElsa A. Olivetti
Elsa A. Olivetti
Predictions of metal consumption are vital for criticality assessments and sustainability analyses. Although demand for a material varies strongly by region and end‐use sector, statistical models of demand typically predict demand using regression analyses at an aggregated global level (“fully pooled models”). “Un‐pooled” regression models that predict demand at a disaggregated country or regional level face challenges due to limited data availability and large uncertainty. In this paper, we propose a Bayesian hierarchical model that can simultaneously identify heterogeneous demand parameters (like price and income elasticities) for individual regions and sectors, as well as global parameters. We demonstrate the model's value by estimating income and price elasticity of copper demand in five sectors (Transportation, Electrical, Construction, Manufacturing, and Other) and five regions (North America, Europe, Japan, China, and Rest of World). To validate the benefits of the Bayesian approach, we compare the model to both a “fully pooled” and an “un‐pooled” model. The Bayesian model can predict global demand with similar uncertainty as a fully pooled regression model, while additionally capturing regional heterogeneity in income elasticity of demand. Compared to un‐pooled models that predict demand for individual countries and sectors separately, our model reduces the uncertainty of parameter estimates by more than 50%. The hierarchical Bayesian modeling approach we propose can be used for various commodities, improving material demand projections used to study the impact of policies on mining sector emissions and informing investment in critical material production.

8 July 2024 in Journal of Industrial Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JRJohn Ryter
John Ryter
KBKaran Bhuwalka
Karan Bhuwalka
MOMichelena O'ROurke
Michelena O'ROurke
LMLuca Montanelli
Luca Montanelli
DCDavid Cohen‐Tanugi
David Cohen‐Tanugi
EOElsa Olivetti
Elsa Olivetti
The low‐carbon energy transition requires significant increases in production for many mineral commodities. Understanding demand, technological requirements, and prices associated with this production increase requires understanding the supply chain dynamics of many minerals simultaneously, and via a consistent framework. A generalized economics‐informed material flow method, global materials modeling using Bayesian optimization, captures the market dynamics of key mineral commodities. The method relies only on a limited set of widely available historical data as input, enabling quantification of economic relationships (elasticities) for supply chain components where data are sparse, and relationships cannot be obtained via traditional statistical approaches. Building upon established material flow analysis (MFA) and economic modeling techniques, Bayesian optimization was applied to fit an economics‐informed MFA model to global historical demand, supply, and price for aluminum, copper, gold, lead, nickel, silver, iron, tin, and zinc. This approach enables estimates for the evolution of ore grades, mine costs, refining charges, sector‐specific demand, and scrap collection for each commodity. Economic relationships were quantified and compared with a database compiled from the literature, including 1333 values from 213 analyses across 65 publications. Discrepancies in methods and limited coverage make use of these parameters in modeling efforts difficult. This work provides a single, homogeneous, probabilistic approach to identifying economic relationships across mineral supply chains, with uncertainty quantification, a literature database for comparison, and a modeling framework in which to use them. This article met the requirements for a Gold‐Gold JIE data openness badge described at http://jie.click/badges .