David Kleijn
Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

David Kleijn

Plant Ecology and Nature Conservation Group Wageningen University & Research Wageningen The Netherlands

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

31Years (1996-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
24 January 2012 in Biological Reviews
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
TTTeja Tscharntke
Teja Tscharntke
JTJason Tylianakis
Jason Tylianakis
TRTatyana A. Rand
Tatyana A. Rand
RDRaphael K. Didham
Raphael K. Didham
LFLenore Fahrig
Lenore Fahrig
CWCatrin Westphal
Catrin Westphal

1 April 2013 in Trends in Ecology & Evolution
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
RBRiccardo Bommarco
Riccardo Bommarco
DKDavid Kleijn
David Kleijn
SPSimon G. Potts
Simon G. Potts

15 December 2003 in Journal of Applied Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
DKDavid Kleijn
David Kleijn
WSWilliam J. Sutherland
William J. Sutherland
Summary: Increasing concern over the environmental impact of agriculture in Europe has led to the introduction of agri‐environment schemes. These schemes compensate farmers financially for any loss of income associated with measures that aim to benefit the environment or biodiversity. There are currently agri‐environment schemes in 26 out of 44 European countries. Agri‐environment schemes vary markedly between countries even within the European Union. The main objectives include reducing nutrient and pesticide emissions, protecting biodiversity, restoring landscapes and preventing rural depopulation. In virtually all countries the uptake of schemes is highest in areas of extensive agriculture where biodiversity is still relatively high and lowest in intensively farmed areas where biodiversity is low. Approximately €24·3 billion has been spent on agri‐environment schemes in the European Union (EU) since 1994, an unknown proportion of it on schemes with biodiversity conservation aims. We carried out a comprehensive search for studies that test the effectiveness of agri‐environment schemes in published papers or reports. Only 62 evaluation studies were found originating from just five EU countries and Switzerland (5). Indeed 76% of the studies were from the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, where until now onlyc. 6% of the EU agri‐environmental budget has been spent. Other studies were from Germany (6), Ireland (3) and Portugal (1). In the majority of studies, the research design was inadequate to assess reliably the effectiveness of the schemes. Thirty‐one percent did not contain a statistical analysis. Where an experimental approach was used, designs were usually weak and biased towards giving a favourable result. The commonest experimental design (37% of the studies) was a comparison of biodiversity in agri‐environment schemes and control areas. However, there is a risk of bias if either farmers or scheme co‐ordinators select the sites for agri‐environment schemes. In such cases the sites are likely to have a higher biodiversity at the outset compared to the controls. This problem may be addressed by collecting baseline data (34% of studies), comparing trends (32%) or changes (26%) in biodiversity between areas with and without schemes or by pairing scheme and control sites that experience similar environmental conditions (16%). Overall, 54% of the examined species (groups) demonstrated increases and 6% decreases in species richness or abundance compared with controls. Seventeen percent showed increases for some species and decreases for other species, while 23% showed no change at all in response to agri‐environment schemes. The response varied between taxa. Of 19 studies examining the response of birds that included a statistical analysis, four showed significant increases in species richness or abundance, two showed decreases and nine showed both increases and decreases. Comparative figures for 20 arthropod studies yielded 11 studies that showed an increase in species richness or abundance, no study showed a decrease and three showed both increases and decreases. Fourteen plant studies yielded six studies that showed increases in species richness or abundance, two showed decreases and no study showed both increases and decreases. Synthesis and applications. The lack of robust evaluation studies does not allow a general judgement of the effectiveness of European agri‐environment schemes. We suggest that in the future, ecological evaluations must become an integral part of any scheme, including the collection of baseline data, the random placement of scheme and control sites in areas with similar initial conditions, and sufficient replication. Results of these studies should be collected and disseminated more widely, in order to identify the approaches and prescriptions that best deliver biodiversity enhancement and value for money from community support.

21 May 2015 in Conservation Biology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
PBPéter Batáry
Péter Batáry
LDLynn Dicks
Lynn Dicks
DKDavid Kleijn
David Kleijn
WSWilliam J. Sutherland
William J. Sutherland
Over half of the European landscape is under agricultural management and has been for millennia. Many species and ecosystems of conservation concern in Europe depend on agricultural management and are showing ongoing declines. Agri‐environment schemes (AES) are designed partly to address this. They are a major source of nature conservation funding within the European Union (EU) and the highest conservation expenditure in Europe. We reviewed the structure of current AES across Europe. Since a 2003 review questioned the overall effectiveness of AES for biodiversity, there has been a plethora of case studies and meta‐analyses examining their effectiveness. Most syntheses demonstrate general increases in farmland biodiversity in response to AES, with the size of the effect depending on the structure and management of the surrounding landscape. This is important in the light of successive EU enlargement and ongoing reforms of AES. We examined the change in effect size over time by merging the data sets of 3 recent meta‐analyses and found that schemes implemented after revision of the EU's agri‐environmental programs in 2007 were not more effective than schemes implemented before revision. Furthermore, schemes aimed at areas out of production (such as field margins and hedgerows) are more effective at enhancing species richness than those aimed at productive areas (such as arable crops or grasslands). Outstanding research questions include whether AES enhance ecosystem services, whether they are more effective in agriculturally marginal areas than in intensively farmed areas, whether they are more or less cost‐effective for farmland biodiversity than protected areas, and how much their effectiveness is influenced by farmer training and advice? The general lesson from the European experience is that AES can be effective for conserving wildlife on farmland, but they are expensive and need to be carefully designed and targeted.

11 October 2019 in Science Advances
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MDMatteo Dainese
Matteo Dainese
EMEmily A. Martin
Emily A. Martin
MAMarcelo A. Aizen
Marcelo A. Aizen
MAMatthias Albrecht
Matthias Albrecht
IBIgnasi Bartomeus
Ignasi Bartomeus
ISIngolf Steffan-Dewenter
Ingolf Steffan-Dewenter
Biodiversity benefits pollination, pest control, and crop productivity but suffers from land-use intensification.

30 November 2015 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
RRRomina Rader
Romina Rader
IBIgnasi Bartomeus
Ignasi Bartomeus
LGLucas Alejandro Garibaldi
Lucas Alejandro Garibaldi
MGMichael PD Garratt
Michael PD Garratt
BHBrad Howlett
Brad Howlett
MWMichal Woyciechowski
Michal Woyciechowski
Significance: Many of the world’s crops are pollinated by insects, and bees are often assumed to be the most important pollinators. To our knowledge, our study is the first quantitative evaluation of the relative contribution of non-bee pollinators to global pollinator-dependent crops. Across 39 studies we show that insects other than bees are efficient pollinators providing 39% of visits to crop flowers. A shift in perspective from a bee-only focus is needed for assessments of crop pollinator biodiversity and the economic value of pollination. These studies should also consider the services provided by other types of insects, such as flies, wasps, beetles, and butterflies—important pollinators that are currently overlooked.