20 April 2010 in Journal of Ecology
Summary: 1. Functional traits are increasingly used to investigate community structure, ecosystem functioning or to classify species into functional groups. These functional traits are expected to be variable between and within species. Intraspecific functional variability is supposed to influence and modulate species responses to environmental changes and their effects on their environment. However, this hypothesis remains poorly tested and species are mostly described by mean trait values without any consideration of variability in individual trait values. 2. In this study, we quantify the extent of intraspecific plant functional trait variability, its spatial structure and its response to environmental factors. Using a sampling design structured along two direct and orthogonal climatic gradients in an alpine valley, we quantified and analysed the intraspecific variability for three functional traits (height, leaf dry matter content and leaf nitrogen content) measured on sixteen plant species with contrasting life histories. 3. Results showed a large variability of traits within species with large discrepancies between functional traits and species. This variability did not appear to be structured within populations. Between populations, the overall variability was partly explained by the selected gradients. Despite the strong effects of temperature and radiation on trait intraspecific variability, the response curves of traits along gradients were partly idiosyncratic. 4. Synthesis. Giving a comprehensive quantification of intraspecific functional variability through the analysis of an original data set, we report new evidence that using a single trait value to describe a given species can hide large functional variation for this species along environmental gradients. These findings suggest that intraspecific functional variability should be a concern for ecologists and its recognition opens new opportunities to better understand and predict ecological patterns in a changing environment. Further analyses are, however, required to compare inter‐ and intraspecific variability.
8 December 2014 in Functional Ecology
Summary: The prevalence of phylogenetic niche conservatism (PNC) in nature is still a conflicting issue. Disagreement arises from confusion over its precise definition and the variety of approaches to measure its prevalence. Recent work highlighted that common measures ofPNCstrongly depend on the assumptions of the underlying model of niche evolution. However, this warning has not been well recognized in the applied literature and questionable approaches are still frequently applied. The aim of this study is to draw attention to the assumptions underlying commonly applied simple measures ofPNC. We used a series of simulations to illustrate how misleading results can be if assumptions of niche evolution are violated, that the violation of assumptions is a common phenomenon and that testing assumptions requires in‐depth pretest. We conclude that the seemingly simple measures ofPNC, such as phylogenetic signal (PS) and evolutionary rate, are not so easy to apply if one accounts for the necessity to test model assumptions. In addition, these measures can be difficult to interpret. The common assumption that strong PS indicatesPNCwill be often invalid. In addition, the interpretation of some measures, for example the conclusion that evolutionary rate is slow enough to indicatePNC, requires a comparison with another clade, another trait or well‐developed null model assumptions and thus additional data. We suggest that studies investigatingPNCshould always compare alternative evolutionary models and that model comparisons should in particular include flexible niche evolution models such as multiple‐optimaOUmodels, although these are computational intensive. These models are directly inherited from the concept of macroevolutionary adaptive landscape and can indicatePNCeither by relative few peak shifts or by narrow peaks in the adaptive landscape. A test ofPNCthus requires comparing these parameters of the macroevolutionary landscape between clades or time periods. The general prevalence ofPNCin nature should be evaluated only based on studies keeping up to the high standards of communicating the used definition ofPNC, testing the assumptions made in the modelling approaches and including newly developed models in a model comparison approach.
22 March 2014 in Alpine Botany
20 October 2015 in Journal of Biogeography
13 October 2011 in Evolution
Relatively, few species have been able to colonize extremely cold alpine environments. We investigate the role played by the cushion life form in the evolution of climatic niches in the plant genus Androsace s.l., which spreads across the mountain ranges of the Northern Hemisphere. Using robust methods that account for phylogenetic uncertainty, intraspecific variability of climatic requirements and different life-history evolution scenarios, we show that climatic niches of Androsace s.l. exhibit low phylogenetic signal and that they evolved relatively recently and punctually. Models of niche evolution fitted onto phylogenies show that the cushion life form has been a key innovation providing the opportunity to occupy extremely cold environments, thus contributing to rapid climatic niche diversification in the genus Androsace s.l. We then propose a plausible scenario for the adaptation of plants to alpine habitats.
1 May 2014 in The American Naturalist
Recent debate on whether climatic niches are conserved through time has focused on how phylogenetic niche conservatism can be measured by deviations from a Brownian motion model of evolutio...