31 July 2017 in Physical Review D
We construct an updated and extended compilation of growth-rate data based on recent redshift-space distortion measurements. The data set consists of 34 data points and includes corrections for model dependence. In order to minimize overlap and maximize the independence of the data points, we also construct a subsample of this compilation (a “gold” growth data set) which consists of 18 data points. We test the consistency of this data set with the best-fit parameters in the context of General Relativity using the evolution equation for the growth factor with a background. We find tension at the level between the best-fit parameters (the dark energy equation of state), (the matter density parameter), and (the matter power spectrum normalization on scales ) and the corresponding parameters (, , and ). We show that the tension disappears if we allow for evolution of the effective Newton constant, parametrized as with where and are parameters of the model, is the scale factor, and is the redshift. This parametrization satisfies three important criteria: a) positive energy of the graviton (), b) consistency with big bang nucleosynthesis constraints (), and c) consistency with Solar System tests ( and ). We show that the best-fit form of obtained from the growth data corresponds to weakening gravity at recent redshifts (decreasing function of ), and we demonstrate that this behavior is not consistent with any scalar-tensor Lagrangian with a real scalar field. Finally, we use MGCAMB to find the best-fit obtained from the Planck cosmic microwave background power spectrum on large angular scales and show that it is a mildly increasing function of , in tension with the corresponding decreasing best-fit obtained from the growth data.
4 May 2016 in Physical Review D
Dark energy equation of state parametrizations with two parameters and given monotonicity are generically either convex or concave functions. This makes them suitable for fitting either freezing or thawing quintessence models but not both simultaneously. Fitting a data set based on a freezing model with an unsuitable (concave when increasing) parametrization [like Chevallier-Polarski-Linder (CPL)] can lead to significant misleading features like crossing of the phantom divide line, incorrect , incorrect slope, etc., that are not present in the underlying cosmological model. To demonstrate this fact we generate scattered cosmological data at both the level of and the luminosity distance based on either thawing or freezing quintessence models and fit them using parametrizations of convex and of concave type. We then compare statistically significant features of the best fit with actual features of the underlying model. We thus verify that the use of unsuitable parametrizations can lead to misleading conclusions. In order to avoid these problems it is important to either use both convex and concave parametrizations and select the one with the best or use principal component analysis thus splitting the redshift range into independent bins. In the latter case, however, significant information about the slope of at high redshifts is lost. Finally, we propose a new family of parametrizations which generalizes the CPL and interpolates between thawing and freezing parametrizations as the parameter increases to values larger than 1.
7 November 2016 in European Journal of Physics
Mechanical angular momentum is not conserved in systems involving electromagnetic fields with non-zero electromagnetic field angular momentum. Conservation is restored only if the total (mechanical and field) angular momentum is considered. Previous studies have investigated this effect, known as ‘Feynman’s Electromagnetic Paradox’ or simply ‘Disk Paradox’ in the context of idealized systems (infinite or infinitesimal solenoids and charged cylinders etc). In the present analysis we generalize previous studies by considering more realistic systems with finite components and demonstrating explicitly the conservation of the total angular momentum. This is achieved by expressing both the mechanical and the field angular momentum in terms of charges and magnetic field fluxes through various system components. Using this general expression and the closure of magnetic field lines, we demonstrate explicitly the conservation of total angular momentum in both idealized and realistic systems (finite solenoid concentric with two charged cylinders, much longer than the solenoid) taking all the relevant terms into account including the flux outside of the solenoid. This formalism has the potential to facilitate a simpler and more accurate demonstration of total angular momentum conservation in undergraduate physics electromagnetism laboratories.