1 January 2026 in Journal of Advanced Transportation
Unobserved heterogeneity is a key factor leading to biased estimates and unreliable crash predictions, undermining the effectiveness of safety countermeasures. Two common options to address it are separating crash types and leveraging advanced statistical models. While finite mixture models have recently demonstrated superiority in this regard, they fail to account for correlations between different crash types. This study thus integrates the two approaches by developing bivariate finite mixture (BFM) models while decomposing crashes into single‐vehicle (SV) and multivehicle (MV) crashes so as to simultaneously address the correlation feature and unobserved heterogeneity. Two variants of the BFM model are developed with SV and MV crash counts as the bivariate response variable. The first variant, BFM‐I‐2, measures the correlation using multivariate normally distributed random error terms, while the second, BFM‐II‐2, employs a joint probability density function. Both bivariate models categorize SV and MV crashes into two subgroups, respectively. Among these models, BFM‐I‐2 exhibits better performance than BFM‐II‐2; it not only verifies the positive correlations between SV and MV crashes but also highlights substantial differences in the key contributing factors across the two crash types. Traffic volume exerts opposing effects on the two subgroups of SV crashes, indicating that unobserved heterogeneity may explain the inconsistent findings regarding its influence in previous research. For MV crashes, the two subgroups share few common risk factors: those in Component 1 are predominantly associated with traffic flow conditions, whereas Component 2 is largely affected by road geometry. These findings can support developing tailored freeway safety interventions.